Wednesday, November 28, 2007

stuck

Sometimes I'm really enthusiastic. I'm on my game, have mildly intelligent things to say. Other days, like today, I am dull, critical, and spaced out. Nothing is firing between my ears. There are people around and conversations to be had, but I avoid them. Not for shyness, but just because I have nothing to say, and don't want to strain to invent something. It's ok not to be original, I know I'm not original. That's why I'm a med student. This academic stuff may be wearing on me. The pressure to be smart, or at least appear smart. One of my recurring undlerlying fears is that one day I will wake up and everyone will know my secret: I really have nothing interesting to say. Then I'll get old and shrivelled, have no athletic ability, and no friends. People will wonder how I graduated college and med school with such good scores, and I'll be able to say honestly, "It was a miracle." Sometimes God just strikes me with answers to tests. I look back at them and have no idea how I answered them. Like in awe of my former self which has now degenerated into a pile of mediocrity.

That's when I'll fall back on my self soothing techniques. "At least I can read. At least I can bake bread sometimes. At least my parents still love me." HA!

Isn't it amazing how deep insecurity runs? It doesn't change much from junior high, I still have all the same crap running through my head. But I cover it up better with my subsequent additions to the resume. It doesn't help though.

At the end of the day, I can't fall back on anything I've said, done, read, answered, written, won, sung, or given. It's all ashes. That's when I'm glad it's all dung anyway, compared to the gifts of God to me in Christ.

Monday, November 26, 2007

The presence of God

On Friday, we were discussing this essay by Frederick Buechner. He says in this one part that language, writing and speaking, is one of the most holy activities people can engage in. While you'd have to read the essay to see where he's coming from, he makes the statement that words are sacramental, and a library is holy in a similar way to a temple. He's definitely exaggerating to make the point, but he's basically saying that God can reveal Himself through words. Jesus is in fact, the Word, and the origin of words.

This started up a debate, as you can imagine. Where is God present? Isn't He present everywhere all the time, and to the same degree? I was kind of thinking that He is always there, it's only because of particular words we read or states of mind that we enter (through reading scripture, or CS Lewis, or even a profound novel or something) that we experience God more directly. I know for myself I have had the experience of God teaching me things or moving through words other than scripture.

Similar things can be said with the physical world. Christ said that bread and wine are His body, so those physical things are means of grace for us, and directly put us into contact with God in a unique way. Can you say the same for all physical things, like mountains and oceans, etc? Can those usher you into the presence of God?

We kind of concluded that God is present everywhere at all times, but more strongly in some times and places than others. He says where 2 or 3 or gathered, He is there with them. So this must mean He is not present in the same way at all times.

But what about our experience of God? If we are right in our hearts and ask for His presence, will He not show Himself to us? This is where college biology pops into my head. If you plate a wad of bacteria on a dish with penicillin, some will survive because they had previously acquired a resistance gene. But before the scientists knew this, they were really confused. Maybe the penicillin was actually causing resistant colonies rather than selecting them...So maybe God's presence is like the penicillin and kills off all of those who have not acquired the resistance gene to His wrath, i.e. the imputed righteousness of Christ.

But that analogy doesn't work that well. First because God's presence does not kill people (at this point in history), it draws, comforts, and enlightens. And second, because God is not at our command, coming whenever we wish. In fact, it's the other way around. We come when He calls. And sometimes we can do all in our power to prepare the way, and He may not always show up - like the Dark Night of the Soul kind of thing with Mother Theresa. hmmmm.

Thoughts?

Snow and Thanksgiving



First snow, very exciting. We had scripture class cancelled in the afternoon, so Rosie wanted to do Thanksgiving. So we went home and Susan made a ton of food. I made a casserole and some pies, and everyone (almost) came over. We played and sang some songs, and did the traditional "what are you thankful for?" rounds. Good times!


Wednesday, November 21, 2007

What makes people do evil things?


We discussed this a couple of weeks ago, this book called The Lucifer Effect. It examines the social science research that asks how people who are apparently normal end up doing things like working in death camps and abusing others. The book takes the "situationalist" view: anyone is capable of anything in a bad enough situation. The opposing view is the "dispostionalist" view: your actions depend on your nature.


The question that came up in discussion is: where is free will in all of this? Your disposition and your situation are givens that you have no power over. What can you change about your life? Answer: your nature. You can train yourself, before you get in a situation to react in a certain way. You can acquire new habits, a "second nature" so to speak. So DO IT! Guard against the Lucifer Effect! You never know what situation you'll be faced with in the future.

The bus

Last Friday night I rode the bus around for a long time, got off to see a crappy art opening, and got back on. I noticed these same 2 mentally handicapped guys were on the bus when I got off and when I got back on. Apparently this is their Friday night entertainment, which turned out basically to be mine as well. I'm not sure how they understood each other, but they did. They were having a great time. One of them seemed to be the guardian for the other who was less functional. It made me appreciate that I had a warm place to sleep and people to talk to. But it also made me miss my friends.

I broke down crying on the bus (in the back, no one saw). I came home and called Kristin and vented for a long time. It was good to catch up and hear about my other life, the life I will reenter next year: interviews for medicine. But I can't jump ahead too quickly. I am here for a lot of reasons, and I love it. No one said leaving friends and family, living in a foreign country, and examining the great ideas of the west was gonna be easy. I just really miss my car =( Buses force interactions with people when I would rather ride alone. But as we all know, isolation sucks as well. And gas is expensive.

Ramblings

this week has been intense. The semester has reached a bit of a boiling point of emotion, which is to be expected given the amount of time we spend around each other (24 hrs a day, no car). But since we are a Christian group, and have recently been confronted with New Testament ethics in philosophy, conversations have actually been productive. Somethings are now understood that were not previously. Some people when they vent don't want advice, just hugs, ok? OK. Some people are 18 and irresponsibly clueless! OK? Yeah, we are getting it now. Grace, grace, grace. Can't overdo it.

We were going to have a Thanksgiving dinner at the guys house, but have no transportation. So we're just doing a small one with us 3 girls and a friend. I get to try out my "Tipsy Pecan Pie" which I'm excited about. Wish pecans weren't so $$ here. It's gonna be great. Giving thanks is a good thing to do. It keeps us in reality, remembering what we deserve (nothing) and what we have (everything in Christ).

For my part, I hate whining. I just want to say, "You signed up for this! Do you know how lucky you are?" But then I realize that I have ceased to be concerned with what God has for me to do and instead am judging others. whining about whiners. sigh.

Community is fun, but it is not free. Messy, but worth it. Like cornbread dressing.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Week 9 Academics

Philosophy
This week we talked about Stoicism and Epictetus. Stoicism is not just "suck it up and deal," it goes deeper than that. He wants us to see that everything outside of our control is indifferent to us, and we shouldn't get upset by it! We should only call things in our control "good" or "evil" since we are able to control our response to things. We really just need to not desire things that we might not get, and then we will never be disappointed. I find it interesting, but it falls short in Christian terms, he disparages the things of this world that have been given to us by God. He does have a notion of God, though, that is high and exalted, sovreign, and caring for His creatures, which I didn't expect to find in a Stoic.

"True instruction is this:—to learn to wish that each thing should come to pass as it does." XXVI

"Men are disturbed, not by things, but by the principles and notions which they form concerning things. Death, for instance, is not terrible, else it would have appeared so to Socrates. But the terror consists in our notion of death that it is terrible. When therefore we are hindered, or disturbed, or grieved, let us never attribute it to others, but to ourselves; that is, to our own principles. An uninstructed person will lay the fault of his own bad condition upon others. Someone just starting instruction will lay the fault on himself. Some who is perfectly instructed will place blame neither on others nor on himself."

Reading: The New Testament - yay!

Art
This week we talked about the Gothic Cathedrals, those gorgeous art forms that draw the mind up into heaven. The whole church is a textbook to teach you about the way the universe runs, with Christ at the head and creation in His service. The key feature is a use of light as much as possible. It began at St. Denis and exploded all over Europe in a short period of time. These cathedrals were community projects, everyone was involved. The sculpture is also more skillful than the Romanesque artists and looks very orderly and peaceful. I like it a lot.

Science and Medicine
We are giving presentations of our view of faith and reason. How do they relate? We are supposed to give background on our denomination and then give our own view. Mostly people have said "they are complimentary and don't conflict." I'm still not sure what I'm going to say, but it's going to involve a bedsheet, that much is certain.

Literature
Othello - so intense. Why are the good guys so incompetent and the bad guys so fascinating (Iago). This play is a tragedy beginning with an interracial marriage, ruined by political scheming and doubts. Iago makes Othello think his new wife is cheating on him so he smothers her. Horrible! We also learned about Shakespeare's life and how skilled his actors had to be to pull of these stage fights, stabbings, love scenes, etc. Amazing.

Scriptures
More Visitation.

Disputatio
None, we had a visting artist come, the iconographer Father Koufous. He took us to a Melkite Church he painted, which is gorgeous. It's so bright and colorful. I didn't know there were any churches being done like that anymore. And it's just down the street from us!
We also went to an Eastern Catholic Vespers service which was one of the most moving and reverent services I've ever been to. They chant the whole thing, and it's done by candlelight with incense. The harmonies of the voices and the meaning of the liturgy were awesome. Then they had a wine and cheese reception afterwards. I'll be back next month!

Week 8 Academics

Sorry again, it’s gotten crazy here recently. Here is week 8. I put up notes for art and philosophy in the Augustine file).

Philosophy
We finished Aristotle by reading selections from his work on friendship, Book 8 and 9.

He makes the point that friendship is integral to a book on ethics because you have to have good people to have true friends! And also, in politics, “when men are friends they have no need of justice,” because they are in agreement on what is right. He goes through 3 bases for relationships that people arrange: utility (lasts only as long as you meet my needs), pleasure (lasts as long as I find you enjoyable), and goodness (lasts as long as both people remain good). The last form is the only true and enduring friendship.

It seems people haven’t changed much. All of his observations about the short-lived nature of relationships built only on common interests or desires apply today.
“On the other hand the friendship of young people seems to aim at pleasure; for they live under the guidance of emotion, and pursue above all what is pleasant to themselves and what is immediately before them; but with increasing age their pleasures become different. This is why they quickly become friends and quickly cease to be so; their friendship changes with the object that is found pleasant, and such pleasure alters quickly. Young people are amorous too; for the greater part of the friendship of love depends on emotion and aims at pleasure; this is why they fall in love and quickly fall out of love, changing often within a single day. But these people do wish to spend their days and lives together; for it is thus that they attain the purpose of their friendship.
Perfect friendship is the friendship of men who are good, and alike in virtue; for these wish well alike to each other qua good, and they are good themselves. Now those who wish well to their friends for their sake are most truly friends; for they do this by reason of own nature and not incidentally; therefore their friendship lasts as long as they are good -- and goodness is an enduring thing.”
Reading: The Golden Sayings of Epictetus (some of them)

Art
This week we learned about Byzantine and Romanesque Art. The art of the Romanesque churches is kind of scary at times, (monsters, Last Judgment), but most of it shows the events of scripture in a grand and impressive way.
Church art in the West is more varied than in the East where they tended to find forms that worked and repeat them. The Icons in the Byzantine style are amazingly beautiful. I used to think they looked like shiny cartoons, but after having a lecture on it and hearing an iconographer (Father Ted Koufos) talk about his work, I can see the unique achievement of depicting divine truth in the pictures. Very cool.

Reading: Gombric on Gothic Art

Science and Medicine
This week we learned about the “Revival of Learning” in the West. After Rome fell to the barbarians, the Middle Ages struggled to hold onto the few classics they had. Much of the scholarship was happening in Islam in the East, since they had the classics in Arabic. But when the West started to revive again around 1000-1200, there was a flood of new manuscripts into the universities. Since all the learning was attached to churches, the debate became what to do with Aristotle, Plato, and all the other pagans whose teaching was not in line with scripture.

The still-present faith and reason conflict soon arose, starting with scholars who wanted to investigate the natural world without reference to the supernatural. They walked the fine line of acknowledging God to be the Supreme First Cause of natural things and looking for “natural” secondary causes in the universe. Soon, however, this distinction slipped into “naturalistic science” and the church had to keep reason in check with multiple bans. Finally at the end of the Middle Ages, Thomas Aquinas developed his synthesis of Aristotle and Christianity, saying philosophy and faith are compatible roads to truth.
Even though the natural light of human mind [i.e. philosophy] is inadequate to make known what is revealed by faith, nevertheless what is divinely taught to us by faith cannot be contrary to what we are endowed with by nature. One or the other would have to be false, and since we have both of them from God, he would be the cause of our error, which is impossible.
Reading: Lindberg Ch. 10-11.

Music
We looked at the Reformation, since Oct. 31, 1517 is when Luther nailed his theses to the Wittenberg door. There wasn’t much to look at musically. Some of the reformers like Zwingli were anti-music in church, but Luther loved it and wanted German hymns instead of Latin to reach out to the community. He also wrote a lot of tunes, including “A Mighty Fortress.” The reform had a radical impact on European Christianity.

Literature
We read King Lear and talked about all of the themes of aging, darkness, insanity, and truth that come up in that play. I like the Fool, he is the only one speaking truth in the play! I recited my speech from Edmund the Bastard, which was fun. Then Trevor did a fabulous recitation of Lear’s intense speech in the storm. He even dunked his head in water to depict the rain. We were stunned at his dramatic flare.

"Rumble thy bellyful! Spit, fire! Spout, rain!Nor rain, wind, thunder, fire, are my daughters:I tax not you, you elements, with unkindness;I never gave you kingdom, called you children,You owe me no subscription: then, let fallYour horrible pleasure; here I stand, your slave,A poor, infirm, weak, and despised old man."- William Shakespeare, King Lear, 3.2.14

Reading: Othello

Scriptures
We are running through the theme of “The Visitation.” Father Hayman talked about 3 things that happen when God visits men. 1) A call or promise, 2) Holy terror! And 3) salvation and comfort. How you respond to God’s coming depends on your relationship to God. Do you see His fire as a welcome purifying flame or as a fire of destruction?
We also turned in a paper comparing a sermon from Augustine (191) and a homily from Chysostom (10) on the Visitation. I really liked Augustine’s analogy of the church as virgin, even though I don’t agree with the perpetual virginity of Mary. He talks about salvation as “giving birth to Christ” who has been conceived in us by faith. This is in stark contrast to Chrysostom who emphasizes our effort at maintaining purity on our own!

Disputatio
We have been debating manhood, since we spent 2 weeks debating womanhood. Mark Driscoll from Seattle says the men of the church have been “chickified.” True, false, neither?

Monday, November 05, 2007

Montreal








This weekend, Starr and I decided to go to Montreal (pics). Yes, we have homework, but it's only going to get worse. So we sucked Susan into the plan and took a daytrip on Saturday. It was wonderful to get out and see things! Good thing Starr spoke French.


We started with the Basilique de Notre-Dame (where Celine Dion was married!) and it was very impressive. Then we ate lunch at this great crepe place. After that we walked to the waterfront and saw the historic clock tower and bridge. Then we drove up to the top of St. Joseph's Oratorio, one of the most visited shrines in North America. You're supposed to start at the bottom and go up the 300 steps, but we got lost and ended up coming in the back. Time saver! In that church, I particularly liked the long skinny wooden saints. They looked very stern and holy.

Finally, we went to the Parc Mont Royal, looked out at "Lover's Overlook" and saw the cross that marks the commemmoration of the first colonists. When the colony was being assaulted by storms, the founder promised God that if He stopped the flood, he would carry a cross to the top of the mountain. So he did! Now there is a modern cross there.
Overall, we still had a productive weekend schoolwise and finished all our work. It was a great trip. Being the only one over 25 and able to rent a car makes me a somewhat valuable person under certain circumstances.