I used to be frumpy because I was hiding. Now I'm frumpy because I have 2 little kids and no time to shower. For real.
Derek posted this article as a negative example of how men should think of women- When Guys Don't Notice You by Joshua Rodgers. The tagline is "Godly guys care about the beauty of your heart, but you can also put some thought into the way you look on the outside." The article generated a bit of angst in the female world, understandably, since women don't want their singleness blamed on a lack of trying, or on a refusal to conform to "what guys want." Derek wrote a beautiful response to the post, and I highly recommend reading this as an antidote to the first! However, in his defense, Joshua Rogers also wrote this post called Where Have all the Beautiful Women Gone? where he argues that the fault does not lie with women not caring about their appearance but with guys not taking time to behold them with fresh eyes and patience, instead reducing their gaze to a 10 second "hot or not" judgment."
As a female, I want to take an opportunity to address the issue of female beauty as it has played out in my own heart and mind.
Point #1. Beauty is no guarantee
I come from a line of beautiful women. Very beautiful Texas women who care deeply about their appearance and go to great lengths to be beautiful by the culture's standards. Paleo diets, anorexia, bulemia, expensive makeup, body building, marathoning, dyed hair, fake eyelashes, pageants(!), clothes and more clothes. I don't even want to think about how much TIME and MONEY these women have spent on their appearance. And I look at the guys they have ended up with, and I'm like...meh. He's ok, sort of. But actually he was a cheater, and he left, or he was a cheater and he stayed. Or he's kind of a pushover. SO what is the point of exerting all this effort if it doesn't guarantee you a great guy? I decided to go the other direction. Stay frumpy and find a guy who thought I was beautiful in my baseline state and then he would be a good guy. He would see my character! That didn't work. That was like a 12 year phase with no dates. Along with this hope, I had a chip on my shoulder and such a feminazi complex that guys were not interested.
Point #2. Beauty is dangerous.
Beauty is power. I have felt this from a very young age, and it frightened me. I didn't want to wear my hear down because then guys noticed me and stared at me and it made me uncomfortable. On a trip to Laredo I had these men cat calling me even when I was with my parents and I was like 11 years old! Freaked me out. Beauty makes you stand out. It makes men stare at you, holler at you, objectify you. And it makes other women attack you and try to bring you down. Even in the church. They talk about you and judge you for dressing "seductively" or for being superficial. Beautiful women are perceived as a threat by other women and as a sex object by men. I didn't want to be either one of those things. So I stayed frumpy.
It would only take 2 pages of our family photos to convince you of this. I did not want to be noticed and I tried hard to blend in. First, I never liked my appearance as I did not look like the other barbies in my family and in my class. Second, it was too much to deal with emotionally for an insecure girl and woman to walk around in radiant confident beauty. The crown was too heavy.
Point #3. Beauty is hard.
It requires a LOT of courage and self-confident to walk in beauty in the world. Feeling beautiful and walking in confidence is extremely difficult. I still can't do it. I struggle with it. Where is the balance between modesty and confidence? sensibility and vanity? healthy and obsession?
Back in junior high I could hide behind ugly clothes but I was very fit and had a great body, though I never thought so at the time (oh the twistedness of self perception!). Now that I'm a mom of 2 kids and have been unable to shed the weight, I have a legitimate reason to not feel beautiful.
The struggle now is to get healthy. Now I'm am hiding behind excess weight and poor fashion effort because I don't take time for self care and being a marytr mom. I'm really trying to get out of this phase, too, since it's just as dishonest as my previous phase.
Point #4. Beauty is divine.
So what I want to say is this. God has made everything beautiful in his time, including me. If I'm not living in my beauty and displaying the beauty he has put inside me, I'm an not a flourishing human being. I am not glorifying Him. Beauty is so so good and it is a force to draw people to God. (It is also a force to draw people together, we are being dishonest if we ignore that.) Beauty is not manipulative. If you are manipulating through your looks, that's not emotionally healthy. Beauty is being who you are and glorifying God in your body. Just do that and let the haters say what they will say. Now if I could only live by my own words =)
It's a long story how I went from hiding to starting to embrace my beauty and then getting married. It involves my friend Dove, my community house, lots of Brene Brown, and some sort of dating advice CD series I have now forgotten. The main change in me that led me to becoming marriage material was openness to vulnerability. The beauty stuff came after that. Another story for another day.