Monday, July 29, 2013
Thin Man
I recognized him, but he was not the same. He had lost 30 pounds in the last 3 weeks, eating and drinking nothing, only water. It was a medical fast of sorts, but also a spiritual one. When the pain of his life and loss hit him the hardest, his impulse was to binge and to numb. But instead he fasted, transforming his hunger into a force for change, self discipline, and a deeper health inside and out than he has possessed since his younger days. He looks light, weightless, peaceful, holy but at the same time wounded, weakened, and fragile. He is thin and he is pliable in the hands of God.
Sunday, July 21, 2013
The Instability of Christendom
Traveling Spain left me in this state of profound inner turmoil about the history of the church. It hit me on multiple occasions, but the most memorable was when we were in the cathedral of Samos Monastery. It's serene, beautiful, romanesque, and maintained by a small group of devout monks. We went to vespers in the cathedral, which has this gorgeous altarpiece of Christ in glory, and an Astorian cross hanging over these massive candles. Then, just when I was flooded with admiration and worship, I glance to my right and see this statue of a conquistador with his foot resting atop a severed head. AHHH! Really? You have to put that right up front? The meditative spirit was at once crushed by disgust, ambivalence, and shame. Shame that my Christian forefathers were so violent and reliant upon the traditional worldly power structures.
It wasn't just that place. The statues are everywhere. St. James the Moorslayer (now the dead Moors are covered by a flower arrangement), Franco's sword in the Toledo treasury, monuments to Cortes, tabernacles of gold pillaged from the New World with blood and avarice. Right next to El Greco's paintings of Peter repenting in tears, St. Francis renouncing all gold and possessions, and the ever-present crucifixion of Christ.
I struggled to reconcile these things in my mind. How could the same church produce magnificent paintings of beauty, masterpieces of architecture, sublime musical works, saints and martyrs who renounced the world and at the same time maintain power through the sword?
Two things have helped give me a structure in which to understand this paradox.
1) CS Lewis the Last Battle, which we read aloud in the car on the way to Toledo.
The insight here is that just because evil deeds done in the name of God does not mean that God endorses or accepts them as service to Him.
2) "No Enduring City"
Thank you to David Bentley Hart for writing a great article in First Things this month called "No Enduring City." He argues that Christendom and Christianity are essentially incompatible, and that the revolutionary seeds in the gospel were always bound to destroy Christendom. The historical phenomenon of Christendom was an "unstable alloy" between the gospel and worldly power, an attempt to "bridge the abyss between Jesus and Pilate." He says the structures and forms of Christian culture created an atmosphere where the true injunctions of the gospel could be heard, if not always obeyed.
He points to amazingly "progressive" historical events such as mass liberation of serfs in Bologna in 1256, but contrasts that with Thomas Aquinas' teaching that heretics should be executed to protect the church from falsehood. The liberation of slaves was the consequence of the total saturation of a culture with the language of the gospel over many generations, and the understanding of the value of human life. Aquinas' argument, on the other hand, was a deformation of the gospel produced by the historical reality of Christendom, and a habit of viewing the "Church and Christian society as a single, immense, integrated machine for the manufacture of baptized souls."
The error of Christendom is that it ceased to see the gospel as a new pattern of corporate human life inaugurated by Christ's ministry, and instead saw it as a deposit of sacred doctrine which must defended by the sword. ("for it is occasionally expedient that, for the sake of a Christian nation, one man should die.")
In the end he says that a "simple belief in providence" goes a long way when looking back at this mixed history, and sometimes all we can do is trust that God knows what He is doing. We don't have to accept the evils of massacre and extravagance as intrinsic to the church, nor do we have to reject all of the beauty that sprouted from the true roots of the gospel.
He points to amazingly "progressive" historical events such as mass liberation of serfs in Bologna in 1256, but contrasts that with Thomas Aquinas' teaching that heretics should be executed to protect the church from falsehood. The liberation of slaves was the consequence of the total saturation of a culture with the language of the gospel over many generations, and the understanding of the value of human life. Aquinas' argument, on the other hand, was a deformation of the gospel produced by the historical reality of Christendom, and a habit of viewing the "Church and Christian society as a single, immense, integrated machine for the manufacture of baptized souls."
The error of Christendom is that it ceased to see the gospel as a new pattern of corporate human life inaugurated by Christ's ministry, and instead saw it as a deposit of sacred doctrine which must defended by the sword. ("for it is occasionally expedient that, for the sake of a Christian nation, one man should die.")
In the end he says that a "simple belief in providence" goes a long way when looking back at this mixed history, and sometimes all we can do is trust that God knows what He is doing. We don't have to accept the evils of massacre and extravagance as intrinsic to the church, nor do we have to reject all of the beauty that sprouted from the true roots of the gospel.
In the crucifixion and resurrection of Christ, all worldly powers were exposed, judged, and found to be inadequate for bringing about the salvation of human beings or human societies. They are all imperfect, tainted, and unstable. The kingdom of God has come in a real way, but it is not synonymous with the visible church, or any political system. The distance between good and evil in this life is very very small. Every human heart, human institution, and human endeavor contains a mix of both. So seek to keep the baby and throw out the bathwater. Claim all of the good fruits of Christendom for the glory of God, and heed the warnings of the severed head statues. All earthly powers have been disarmed and defeated in Christ, so don't go trying to use them.
The Beauty of Christian Spain
The Seville Cathedral from the bellower
Arca Eucaristica, 16th c. Toledo Museum
Leon Cathedral rose window
Leon Cathedral
Toledo Cathedral altarpiece
Toledo Cathedral choir seat
El Greco, the Burial of Count Orgaz
El Greco, the Repentance of Peter
Medieval tapestry, Toledo museum
The Mass of St. Gregory, Toledo museum
El Greco, El Salvador
Main altar, Salamanca Old Cathedral, Last Judgment
Seville Cathedral ceiling
![]() |
| Martyrdom of St. Catherine, Seville Cathedral |
The dark side of Spanish Christendom
Quotes from No Enduring City - DB Hart
Love me some David Bentley Hart. What a prodigy.
http://www.firstthings.com/article/2013/08/no-enduring-city
A little prudent providentialism, however, relieves one of the anxious urge to pronounce some absolute verdict on Christian history as a whole, or to pretend to understand how the Holy Spirit might or might not reweave the tangles of human sin into unexpected occasions of charity or truth. It allows one simply to accept the inscrutable complexities of a world that, if it has been redeemed, nevertheless still groans in anticipation of a glory yet to be revealed, and so of a world in which all good is inextricably bound up with moral failure.
http://www.firstthings.com/article/2013/08/no-enduring-city
A little prudent providentialism, however, relieves one of the anxious urge to pronounce some absolute verdict on Christian history as a whole, or to pretend to understand how the Holy Spirit might or might not reweave the tangles of human sin into unexpected occasions of charity or truth. It allows one simply to accept the inscrutable complexities of a world that, if it has been redeemed, nevertheless still groans in anticipation of a glory yet to be revealed, and so of a world in which all good is inextricably bound up with moral failure.
***
There is no genuinely
faithful proclamation of the Gospel that does not involve a very real and
irreducible element of sheer contrariness towards the most respectable of human
institutions. When the peasant Christ tells the aristocrat Pilate of his
kingdom not of this world, or when Paul warns Christians against any commerce
with the works of the god of this cosmos, or when Christ commands his followers
to forgive those who wrong them in excess of all natural justice, or likens the
wealthy citizen at heaven’s gate to a camel attempting to slip through a
needle’s eye...the
Gospel is announced as something essentially subversive of the accustomed
orders of human power, preeminence, law, social prudence, religion, and
government.
***
Granting that Thomas [Aquinas] and his
order were products of their times, still the use of coercion and murder to
defend the Church cannot be anything other than a betrayal of the Gospel far
graver than any mere doctrinal deviation could ever be. Thomas’ argument is at
once entirely consonant with the principles (social and moral) of Christendom,
and yet entirely alien to the principles of Christianity. And that even so
powerful an intellect as Thomas’ could have failed to grasp this is, to say the
very least, troubling.
***
in the larger world of the empire [Christianity] was, ...positively irreligious in its
implications: a reversal of established sacred truths, the instant in which the
victim of social and religious order was all at once revealed as the righteous
one, the innocent one, even God himself. The pattern established in
Christ—especially in the inexhaustibly suggestive story of his confrontation
with Pilate—was one of martyrdom as victory, of power as the willingness to
become powerless before the violence of the state and thereby to reveal its
arbitrariness, injustice, and spiritual falsehood.
***
Still, of course, the Church
quickly assumed religious configurations appropriate both to its age and to its
own spiritual content... Even then, the alloy was never
entirely stable. At least, it has often seemed as if the Christian event is of
its nature something too refractory—the impulse to rebellion too constitutive
of its own spiritual logic—to be contained even within its own institutions.
This might be one of the reasons why Christianity over the centuries not only
has proved so irrepressibly fissile ... but has also given rise to a culture capable of the most militant
atheism, and even of self-conscious nihilism. Even in its most enduring and
necessary historical forms, there is an ungovernable energy within it,
something that strives not to crystallize but rather to disperse itself into
the future, to start always anew, more spirit than flesh or letter.
***
This was, of course, a fruitful
tension, producing as it did all the immense social goods of the Christian
order: the cultural creativity, the slow amelioration of laws, the birth of the
hospital, the establishment of an immeasurably richer moral grammar than the
West had ever known, a whole vast and various range of artistic, technical, and
scientific achievements—all of which were inseparable in one way or another
from the radical revision of the understanding of the human being and of
nature that Christianity introduced into the world. Yet its moral failures
were no less astonishing or numerous.
***
When Christianity became not only a
pillar of culture, but also a support of the state, and thereby attached itself
to that human reality that necessarily sustains itself through the prudential
use of violence, it attempted to close the spiritual abyss separating Christ
and Pilate on the day of their confrontation in Jerusalem. At the same time,
however, it created a cultural reality animated (or at least haunted) by the
language of the Gospel: the often tacit but always substantial knowledge that
all of human power’s pretenses and delusions and deceits have been exposed for
what they are, and overthrown by God’s Incarnation as a man who was the victim
of all the enfranchised religious, political, and social forces of his time and
place. There was no way for such an alliance to avoid subverting itself.
***
Christendom was that cultural
reality that was constitutionally, materially, morally, intellectually, and
religiously disposed to hear the Gospel as a cosmic truth, to which it was
therefore always open, if not necessarily very obedient. For that, Christians
would be churlish to be ungrateful.
***
So perhaps the best moral sense
Christians can make of the story of Christendom now...is to recall that the Gospel was never bound to the
historical fate of any political or social order, but always claimed to enjoy a
transcendence of all times and places. Perhaps its presence in human history
should always be shatteringly angelic: It announces, even over against one’s
most cherished expectations of the present or the future, a truth that breaks in
upon history, ever and again, always changing or even destroying the former
things in order to make all things new. That being so, surely modern Christians
should find some joy in being forced to remember that they are citizens of a
Kingdom not of this world, that here they have no enduring city, and that they
are called to live as strangers and pilgrims on the earth.
Wednesday, July 17, 2013
Opposition
I do not believe in karma. I believe in opposition.
I do not believe in a universe where your present suffering stems from your past unconscious short-fallings. I believe in a universe that has fallen into tragedy. We live in enemy-occupied territory. There is not a mathematical equivalence to my present pain and my past sins, nor the sins of the world. The child who dies of malaria is not being punished, she is a casualty of war. Yes, there is an extent to which we suffer consequences of bad decisions, take a toll on our own bodies, and create our own graves. But there is more. There are forces both outside of us and inside of us which resist change, goodness, growth, and redemption. Some of it is not in our control.
Dawn has pointed this out reading through Mark for the past 2 weeks. In the synagogue, in the churches, in the cathedrals, there is opposition, demon possession, darkness, sickness. Jesus calls it out and is not surprised by its presence. Of course, every force results in an equal and opposite reaction. Every push into enemy territory results in a strong defensive and a counter-assault. The physical realm reflects the spiritual truth in this case. In scientific circles, belief in spiritual forces, demons, and powers is frowned upon. How can you prove it? In modern and pop culture, on the other hand, we are encouraged to believe in all kinds of stuff that is not visible or tangible. Freudian psychology, vampires, aliens, the superiority of democracy. Demons are actually not that far fetched, especially if you've spent any time in Africa, Haiti, or other animistic societies. There is stuff that happens that you just have to say does not fit your American paradigm.
So when I undertake worthwhile tasks like going to med school, learning guitar, raising an animal, living in community, I am not surprised that stuff goes wrong. That people get sick, that cars break down, that petty differences become inflamed, that blisters form and bank accounts bleed. Do I blame all struggles on the devil with the red horns? No. Some of it is psychology, brain chemistry, personality, training, education, genetics, or whatever. But Jesus doesn't parse it out (as Dawn says). He just walks up to you and asks the crucial question.
Do you want to be healed?
Healed completely, from the inside out, body, soul, and spirit as only God can do. You have to decide. "Have I made friends with the opposition? Do I kind of like sitting on my mat by the pool all day and begging for food even though I am paralyzed? What if I had to walk? Then my life would get super complicated! Am I cooperating with the opposition?"
If you are healed, if you are whole, if you are redeemed and operating as such in this world that Adam and Eve have left us, you are guaranteed struggle, heartache, and pain. The odds are against you, but Jesus is for you. It's a tough call, it is not a simple decision. Once you join the fight, it is a fight. But it is a good fight. Grab a weapon. Grab an invisible arsenal. You will need all the help you can get.
----------------
Doors of the Sea
More on the problem of evil
Intro to the Silmarillion
I do not believe in a universe where your present suffering stems from your past unconscious short-fallings. I believe in a universe that has fallen into tragedy. We live in enemy-occupied territory. There is not a mathematical equivalence to my present pain and my past sins, nor the sins of the world. The child who dies of malaria is not being punished, she is a casualty of war. Yes, there is an extent to which we suffer consequences of bad decisions, take a toll on our own bodies, and create our own graves. But there is more. There are forces both outside of us and inside of us which resist change, goodness, growth, and redemption. Some of it is not in our control.
Dawn has pointed this out reading through Mark for the past 2 weeks. In the synagogue, in the churches, in the cathedrals, there is opposition, demon possession, darkness, sickness. Jesus calls it out and is not surprised by its presence. Of course, every force results in an equal and opposite reaction. Every push into enemy territory results in a strong defensive and a counter-assault. The physical realm reflects the spiritual truth in this case. In scientific circles, belief in spiritual forces, demons, and powers is frowned upon. How can you prove it? In modern and pop culture, on the other hand, we are encouraged to believe in all kinds of stuff that is not visible or tangible. Freudian psychology, vampires, aliens, the superiority of democracy. Demons are actually not that far fetched, especially if you've spent any time in Africa, Haiti, or other animistic societies. There is stuff that happens that you just have to say does not fit your American paradigm.
So when I undertake worthwhile tasks like going to med school, learning guitar, raising an animal, living in community, I am not surprised that stuff goes wrong. That people get sick, that cars break down, that petty differences become inflamed, that blisters form and bank accounts bleed. Do I blame all struggles on the devil with the red horns? No. Some of it is psychology, brain chemistry, personality, training, education, genetics, or whatever. But Jesus doesn't parse it out (as Dawn says). He just walks up to you and asks the crucial question.
Do you want to be healed?
Healed completely, from the inside out, body, soul, and spirit as only God can do. You have to decide. "Have I made friends with the opposition? Do I kind of like sitting on my mat by the pool all day and begging for food even though I am paralyzed? What if I had to walk? Then my life would get super complicated! Am I cooperating with the opposition?"
If you are healed, if you are whole, if you are redeemed and operating as such in this world that Adam and Eve have left us, you are guaranteed struggle, heartache, and pain. The odds are against you, but Jesus is for you. It's a tough call, it is not a simple decision. Once you join the fight, it is a fight. But it is a good fight. Grab a weapon. Grab an invisible arsenal. You will need all the help you can get.
----------------
Doors of the Sea
More on the problem of evil
Intro to the Silmarillion
Monday, July 15, 2013
Berry Says (my paraphrase)
If you want a maid, hire one.
If you want a cook, get a recipe book and make some effort.
If you want a model, get a magazine.
If you want a fling, go to a bar.
If you want an intellectual conversation, join a book club.
If you want a mother, go find yours.
If you want a best friend, get a dog.
But if you want a woman, be a man.
Don't be a slob.
Don't be a mooch.
Don't be a pimp.
Don't be a playboy.
Don't be a poser.
Don't be a child.
Don't be a tease.
Take pride in your place.
Spend time on your food.
Take care of your body.
Seek true intimacy.
Form your own opinion.
Grow up.
Reciprocate.
Now that isn't so hard is it?
--------
Ref:
On Food
On Economics
On Love and Fidelity
Great Quotes
Berry on struggle
“There are, it seems, two muses: the Muse of Inspiration, who gives us inarticulate visions and desires, and the Muse of Realization, who returns again and again to say "It is yet more difficult than you thought." This is the muse of form. It may be then that form serves us best when it works as an obstruction, to baffle us and deflect our intended course. It may be that when we no longer know what to do, we have come to our real work and when we no longer know which way to go, we have begun our real journey. The mind that is not baffled is not employed. The impeded stream is the one that sings.”
― Wendell Berry
― Wendell Berry
Monday, July 08, 2013
A call for patriots
If you are looking for an outlet for your 4th of July fervor, feel free to come to the VA SCI and help out. These guys have a very difficult existence. Some are paralyzed from the neck down and others from the waist down. They have to lie in bed and rely on others to turn them, feed them, clean them, and interact with them. There is not enough staff to turn them all every 2 hours, so some of them get ulcers while inpatient. Others come in with ulcers. They all seem to get infected eventually, on this road to incurable osteomyelitis or multi-drug resistant pathogens.
Wanna come read? Help turn? Talk to them? Cheer the place up?
There are cries of sadness and hopelessness rising from this unit all the time, up to the ears of God.
Volunteer
Wanna come read? Help turn? Talk to them? Cheer the place up?
There are cries of sadness and hopelessness rising from this unit all the time, up to the ears of God.
Volunteer
Monday, July 01, 2013
Tolkien on Communion
One of the major impacts of touring like 15 of the world's finest medieval cathedrals was creating in me a hunger for the Eucharist. I don't have it right now, but when people talk about it, and when I see all the grandeur devoted to it, I want to want it. And I kind of wonder if I need to be Catholic to get the full effect, but that's a long way off.
This was a great quote that Dove and Woody chose for their wedding, which took on a bit of a "Tolkein theme."
"Out of the darkness of my life, so much frustrated, I put before you the one great thing to love on earth: the Blessed Sacrament. . . . There you will find romance, glory, honour, fidelity, and the true way of all your loves on earth, and more than that: Death.
"By the divine paradox, that which ends life, and demands the surrender of all, and yet by the taste—or foretaste—of which alone can what you seek in your earthly relationships (love, faithfulness, joy) be maintained, or take on that complexion of reality, of eternal endurance, which every man’s heart desires."
He goes onto say that it doesn't matter the atmosphere or the ceremony, you should just go. This was challenging for me as the Cathedral of Santiago was such a circus, with iPads and cameras taking pictures during the mass. But Tolkien (and Lewis) both recognized that the sacraments of God supersede the dullness of men. Our inability to receive limits our experience, but not the presence of God in the sacraments.
"Also I can recommend this as an exercise (alas! only too easy to find opportunity for): make your Communion in circumstances that affront your taste. Choose a snuffling or gabbling priest or a proud and vulgar friar; and a church full of the usual bourgeois crowd, ill-behaved children—from those who yell to those products of Catholic schools who the moment the tabernacle is opened sit back and yawn—open-necked and dirty youths, women in trousers and often with hair both unkempt and uncovered. Go to Communion with them (and pray for them).
"It will be just the same (or better than that) as a mass said beautifully by a visibly holy man, and shared by a few devout and decorous people.
"It could not be worse than the mess of the feeding of the Five Thousand—after which our Lord propounded the feeding that was to come.”
New Leaf
July 1 is always a landmark day for we in the medical community. Today I officially ended my vacation and set back to work at the VA. Thankfully Dr. Smith is my attending, and he always says, "Jennifer, it's so good to have you back." He says it with such Kentucky sincerity that it makes me sing on the inside and want to work my butt off. Funny how good words can motivate.
But not too long after that I was trolling it up. I asked an attending if she was a new intern (oops!) and threw out a couple of "What's your question"s. Back in the saddle again. Osteo, MRSA endocarditis, SCI UTI's, all is right with the world.
I am sad to be done with vacation, and with the joyous, raucous, bacchanalian Dove and Woody wedding. But truly, I am excited about the new year. I've got a few fun-ish research opportunities, Dr. Greenberg is gonna let me crash in his giant Micro office with the wide screen Mac, and I already submitted an IRB. Not too shabby.
Tonight I am at a new LTAC. I have new goals for the new year. I want to write some more. I want to give some talks to medical students and start a reading group called "Poets and Prophets." I want to resume my workout routine that this past year decimated, try to eat healthier, journal more, and...maybe even get a shrink. We'll see how much time I have. Oh, and I have to make some new friends because mine all deserted me. Submit your applications to Mark, he's gonna screen them for me.
But not too long after that I was trolling it up. I asked an attending if she was a new intern (oops!) and threw out a couple of "What's your question"s. Back in the saddle again. Osteo, MRSA endocarditis, SCI UTI's, all is right with the world.
I am sad to be done with vacation, and with the joyous, raucous, bacchanalian Dove and Woody wedding. But truly, I am excited about the new year. I've got a few fun-ish research opportunities, Dr. Greenberg is gonna let me crash in his giant Micro office with the wide screen Mac, and I already submitted an IRB. Not too shabby.
Tonight I am at a new LTAC. I have new goals for the new year. I want to write some more. I want to give some talks to medical students and start a reading group called "Poets and Prophets." I want to resume my workout routine that this past year decimated, try to eat healthier, journal more, and...maybe even get a shrink. We'll see how much time I have. Oh, and I have to make some new friends because mine all deserted me. Submit your applications to Mark, he's gonna screen them for me.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)










