Thursday, January 19, 2012

The Prophecy of Ayn Rand


So there's a movie out now at Studio Movie Grill (only 2 nights, Jan 17th and 26th) called Ayn Rand & the Prophecy of “Atlas Shrugged.” I have to admit I have never read the 1200 page tome, but since I had a Groupon to SMG, I decided to go. Verrry interesting. Supposedly, her early 20th century ideas "perfectly predicted" the economic mess we are in now. http://atlasshrugged-thedoc.com/

The theater was full of 50 somethings, and there was a lot of verbal agreement from the audience when Rand would say something they liked. Almost like "amen," if old secularists were to say it. The one life-experience I have with the book is this guy I knew who held it as his "life philosophy." He was kind of a jerk and went onto be a neurosurgeon, so I decided at that point that whatever the book stood for, it must be whacked out.

From what I understand, Ayn Rand was pretty upset that the communists took all her dad's property when she was young. So she came to the states with the hope for a new life of freedom where the government would let you make your money and leave you alone. Then the Progressive Era came along when the politicians were laying a major guilt trip on the money-making American business class with regards to giving to the poor. So that's when the welfare state came into being and taxes went up, etc. So the way Rand perceived the state of things was the division of the world into the "producers" and the "moochers." She wasn't really against benevolence or charity as such, just against mandatory taxation for "charity." This is where her ethics of self-interest comes into play. If everyone would just do what's right for them, the economy would hum along and....I dunno, poverty would disappear?? Not quite connecting the dots on how she thinks it would solve the world's problems. I guess I should read it.

The book is supposed to ask the question, "what would the world look like if all the contributing members went on strike and did not show up to work, what then?" It's an interesting thought.

So I went into the theater expecting to hate Ayn Rand, but I think she has some valid points. I agree with points of Objectivism and the importance of Reason. But as a Christian I have to disagree that reason is the only source of information about life. And I also have to disagree with the ethics of self-interest because it has a lot of potential to go awry and leave the little guy completely helpless and trampled beneath the powerful. I bet, though, that if you were to present Rand's ideas to most evangelicals, who also happen to be right wing tea party types, they would agree whole heartedly. (Despite the fact that she was blatantly anti-religious and saw Christian ethics as a part of the problem).

My question is this: is it possible to develop a political system that is completely just, honors individual freedom, but also has protections for the genuinely poor? I don't think so, but that's because I'm jaded and am just waiting for Jesus to come back and run for President.

Anyone?