Showing posts with label church history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label church history. Show all posts

Sunday, July 21, 2013

The Instability of Christendom

Traveling Spain left me in this state of profound inner turmoil about the history of the church. It hit me on multiple occasions, but the most memorable was when we were in the cathedral of Samos Monastery. It's serene, beautiful, romanesque, and maintained by a small group of devout monks. We went to vespers in the cathedral, which has this gorgeous altarpiece of Christ in glory, and an Astorian cross hanging over these massive candles. Then, just when I was flooded with admiration and worship, I glance to my right and see this statue of a conquistador with his foot resting atop a severed head. AHHH! Really? You have to put that right up front? The meditative spirit was at once crushed by disgust, ambivalence, and shame. Shame that my Christian forefathers were so violent and reliant upon the traditional worldly power structures.

It wasn't just that place. The statues are everywhere. St. James the Moorslayer (now the dead Moors are covered by a flower arrangement), Franco's sword in the Toledo treasury, monuments to Cortes, tabernacles of gold pillaged from the New World with blood and avarice. Right next to El Greco's paintings of Peter repenting in tears, St. Francis renouncing all gold and possessions, and the ever-present crucifixion of Christ.

I struggled to reconcile these things in my mind. How could the same church produce magnificent paintings of beauty, masterpieces of architecture, sublime musical works, saints and martyrs who renounced the world and at the same time maintain power through the sword?

Two things have helped give me a structure in which to understand this paradox. 

1) CS Lewis the Last Battle, which we read aloud in the car on the way to Toledo.
The insight here is that just because evil deeds done in the name of God does not mean that God endorses or accepts them as service to Him. 
2) "No Enduring City"
Thank you to David Bentley Hart for writing a great article in First Things this month called "No Enduring City." He argues that Christendom and Christianity are essentially incompatible, and that the revolutionary seeds in the gospel were always bound to destroy Christendom. The historical phenomenon of Christendom was an "unstable alloy" between the gospel and worldly power, an attempt to "bridge the abyss between Jesus and Pilate." He says the structures and forms of Christian culture created an atmosphere where the true injunctions of the gospel could be heard, if not always obeyed.

He points to amazingly "progressive" historical events such as mass liberation of serfs in Bologna in 1256, but contrasts that with Thomas Aquinas' teaching that heretics should be executed to protect the church from falsehood. The liberation of slaves was the consequence of the total saturation of a culture with the language of the gospel over many generations, and the understanding of the value of human life. Aquinas' argument, on the other hand, was a deformation of the gospel produced by the historical reality of Christendom, and a habit of viewing the "Church and Christian society as a single, immense, integrated machine for the manufacture of baptized souls."

The error of Christendom is that it ceased to see the gospel as a new pattern of corporate human life inaugurated by Christ's ministry, and instead saw it as a deposit of sacred doctrine which must defended by the sword. ("for it is occasionally expedient that, for the sake of a Christian nation, one man should die.")

In the end he says that a "simple belief in providence" goes a long way when looking back at this mixed history, and sometimes all we can do is trust that God knows what He is doing. We don't have to accept the evils of massacre and extravagance as intrinsic to the church, nor do we have to reject all of the beauty that sprouted from the true roots of the gospel. 

In the crucifixion and resurrection of Christ, all worldly powers were exposed, judged, and found to be inadequate for bringing about the salvation of human beings or human societies. They are all imperfect, tainted, and unstable. The kingdom of God has come in a real way, but it is not synonymous with the visible church, or any political system. The distance between good and evil in this life is very very small. Every human heart, human institution, and human endeavor contains a mix of both. So seek to keep the baby and throw out the bathwater. Claim all of the good fruits of Christendom for the glory of God, and heed the warnings of the severed head statues. All earthly powers have been disarmed and defeated in Christ, so don't go trying to use them.