Love me some David Bentley Hart. What a prodigy.
http://www.firstthings.com/article/2013/08/no-enduring-city
A little prudent providentialism, however, relieves one of the anxious urge to pronounce some absolute verdict on Christian history as a whole, or to pretend to understand how the Holy Spirit might or might not reweave the tangles of human sin into unexpected occasions of charity or truth. It allows one simply to accept the inscrutable complexities of a world that, if it has been redeemed, nevertheless still groans in anticipation of a glory yet to be revealed, and so of a world in which all good is inextricably bound up with moral failure.
http://www.firstthings.com/article/2013/08/no-enduring-city
A little prudent providentialism, however, relieves one of the anxious urge to pronounce some absolute verdict on Christian history as a whole, or to pretend to understand how the Holy Spirit might or might not reweave the tangles of human sin into unexpected occasions of charity or truth. It allows one simply to accept the inscrutable complexities of a world that, if it has been redeemed, nevertheless still groans in anticipation of a glory yet to be revealed, and so of a world in which all good is inextricably bound up with moral failure.
***
There is no genuinely
faithful proclamation of the Gospel that does not involve a very real and
irreducible element of sheer contrariness towards the most respectable of human
institutions. When the peasant Christ tells the aristocrat Pilate of his
kingdom not of this world, or when Paul warns Christians against any commerce
with the works of the god of this cosmos, or when Christ commands his followers
to forgive those who wrong them in excess of all natural justice, or likens the
wealthy citizen at heaven’s gate to a camel attempting to slip through a
needle’s eye...the
Gospel is announced as something essentially subversive of the accustomed
orders of human power, preeminence, law, social prudence, religion, and
government.
***
Granting that Thomas [Aquinas] and his
order were products of their times, still the use of coercion and murder to
defend the Church cannot be anything other than a betrayal of the Gospel far
graver than any mere doctrinal deviation could ever be. Thomas’ argument is at
once entirely consonant with the principles (social and moral) of Christendom,
and yet entirely alien to the principles of Christianity. And that even so
powerful an intellect as Thomas’ could have failed to grasp this is, to say the
very least, troubling.
***
in the larger world of the empire [Christianity] was, ...positively irreligious in its
implications: a reversal of established sacred truths, the instant in which the
victim of social and religious order was all at once revealed as the righteous
one, the innocent one, even God himself. The pattern established in
Christ—especially in the inexhaustibly suggestive story of his confrontation
with Pilate—was one of martyrdom as victory, of power as the willingness to
become powerless before the violence of the state and thereby to reveal its
arbitrariness, injustice, and spiritual falsehood.
***
Still, of course, the Church
quickly assumed religious configurations appropriate both to its age and to its
own spiritual content... Even then, the alloy was never
entirely stable. At least, it has often seemed as if the Christian event is of
its nature something too refractory—the impulse to rebellion too constitutive
of its own spiritual logic—to be contained even within its own institutions.
This might be one of the reasons why Christianity over the centuries not only
has proved so irrepressibly fissile ... but has also given rise to a culture capable of the most militant
atheism, and even of self-conscious nihilism. Even in its most enduring and
necessary historical forms, there is an ungovernable energy within it,
something that strives not to crystallize but rather to disperse itself into
the future, to start always anew, more spirit than flesh or letter.
***
This was, of course, a fruitful
tension, producing as it did all the immense social goods of the Christian
order: the cultural creativity, the slow amelioration of laws, the birth of the
hospital, the establishment of an immeasurably richer moral grammar than the
West had ever known, a whole vast and various range of artistic, technical, and
scientific achievements—all of which were inseparable in one way or another
from the radical revision of the understanding of the human being and of
nature that Christianity introduced into the world. Yet its moral failures
were no less astonishing or numerous.
***
When Christianity became not only a
pillar of culture, but also a support of the state, and thereby attached itself
to that human reality that necessarily sustains itself through the prudential
use of violence, it attempted to close the spiritual abyss separating Christ
and Pilate on the day of their confrontation in Jerusalem. At the same time,
however, it created a cultural reality animated (or at least haunted) by the
language of the Gospel: the often tacit but always substantial knowledge that
all of human power’s pretenses and delusions and deceits have been exposed for
what they are, and overthrown by God’s Incarnation as a man who was the victim
of all the enfranchised religious, political, and social forces of his time and
place. There was no way for such an alliance to avoid subverting itself.
***
Christendom was that cultural
reality that was constitutionally, materially, morally, intellectually, and
religiously disposed to hear the Gospel as a cosmic truth, to which it was
therefore always open, if not necessarily very obedient. For that, Christians
would be churlish to be ungrateful.
***
So perhaps the best moral sense
Christians can make of the story of Christendom now...is to recall that the Gospel was never bound to the
historical fate of any political or social order, but always claimed to enjoy a
transcendence of all times and places. Perhaps its presence in human history
should always be shatteringly angelic: It announces, even over against one’s
most cherished expectations of the present or the future, a truth that breaks in
upon history, ever and again, always changing or even destroying the former
things in order to make all things new. That being so, surely modern Christians
should find some joy in being forced to remember that they are citizens of a
Kingdom not of this world, that here they have no enduring city, and that they
are called to live as strangers and pilgrims on the earth.