We have spiced up the unit this week with something besides anorexia: gender identity disorder + anorexia! Sweet. What we have now is a boy who wants to be a girl, on hormones since 15, dressed like a girl and talking like one. Scheduled for the operation on his/her 18th birthday. It's pretty obvious to me that she is a boy - she tries so hard to be feminine and dramatic in her tone and movements that it's I feel like I'm watching one of those unreal reality shows. Apparently these kids actually feel like they were born in the wrong body - that the "true me" is female and there was some cosmic mistake that put them in a male body. Hard to imagine.
My first question is - why isn't this classified as a delusion and treated like all the other delusions? And second - what kind of fragmented view of identity allows for a self and body to be so sharply opposed? Wow. Gender for these people is the all-consuming issue. It takes up all their time and energy to convince those around them that they are "authentic." The patient told one staff member that she just wanted to be an authentic woman. The staff observed, "Well, if you were born male, you can't really be authentically female." hmmm...While I have no understanding of how painful and akward this situation must be for the patient, there just seems to be a central misunderstading about what's most important about a person.
The man I refer to as my "rabbi" says that there are only 3 important things about every person. 1) You are created and loved by God. 2) You are fallen into sin, and 3) Saved or unsaved. The other questions are peripheral to those. Black, white, rich, poor, male, female, Republican, Democrat, etc. are temporal and accidental properties that we assign too much importance when valuing one another. One therapist for gender identity kids discovered a way to get kids to accept their biological gender. First, he introduced them to other kids with the problem, letting them know they were not alone, when they had previously been shunned. Second, he affirmed their gifts and encouraged him to be who they were, whereas they had been made to feel ashamed before. After a while the kids stopped asking for the sex change and feeling more at home in their bodies.
These seem like common sense things to a Christian - community, grace, unconditional love. In a way we all have identity disorders of some type, in that we see some aspect of ourselves as more central than that assigned to us by God: new creation, child of God, elect, beloved, priest, brother, heir. Only in an accepting community rooted in Christ can people be free to let go of their definitions of self and grow into the person God created them to be. I feel really bad for these kids. For them the new gender is almost like a promised land of sorts. They will be at home at last, accepted, free in this new body. But like all messiahs in this world, it's bound to be disillusioning in the end. If you hate your body as a male, you'll hate it as a female, until you get to something deeper and higher than gender.
No comments:
Post a Comment