Thursday, March 15, 2007

Heaven, hell, and the frontal lobes

For me, talking with people about "eternal things" is like doing crack, but without the strokes and rhabdo. I'm of the opinion that if there is even the remote possibility that we will exist after death, it's not a waste of time to consider what that might entail. Some people think that it's painful and futile - "You can't know" or they just leave it at "Well, if there is a God and He's good, then I'm not worried." It's fun for me to come across folks that have thought a lot about it and have different views than I do. Consequently, the call night I spent at Parkland on Stroke was not boring after all.

My resident is a Sunni Muslim from Jordan. We somehow got to talking about the end of the world and how he thought it was going to wind down when all of our resources dissipate. "It's a fact, there is no doubt. I feel sorry for my grandkids." He gave civilization about 100-200 years to live. He went on to say he was a creationist and that he had no explanation for why God created the world. We paused the conversation to go see patients. As I was getting ready to leave, I reminded him to finish his point, which started a whole long conversation about God, heaven, hell, mercy, and the relation of morality to the frontal lobes. It was fascinating.

His main objection to Christianity, as many folks have said, is that if you just forgive everyone, no one will have an incentive to behave themselves. You have to have the fear of hell or promise of heaven to keep people "in check," especially "the masses" who are not innately moral according to him. This led into a discussion of Romans (the book answers this question straight up, among others), and how Christian works are motivated out of gratitude to God and also by the Spirit living in us to create in us a desire to obey God. Then he went off into the parts of the self and how the spirit is always battling with the self to keep it in line. He equated this inhibition of evil with the frontal lobes, and placed the seat of desires in the temporal lobes. Wow. Talk about reductionism. His final conclusion was that schizophrenics and insane folk cannot be judged by God because their lobes are not working properly. The safest way to make sure you go to heaven is by going insane. Sweet!! I'll keep that in my back pocket. Fun times.

I really enjoyed talking with him. Good to think about this stuff more often.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

haha, I think that particular resident likes having "deep conversations." I was on short-call with him a few weeks ago and we talked about religion/faith/God/medical ethics. good times. I wish I could be more aware of opportunities for conversations like that...

TK said...

I think I may have had the same resident and we talked about some of the same stuff.