Saturday, September 29, 2007

Is this week 3 already?

Ok, so my energy is already petering out for comprehensive class posts. I did put up my lecture notes for a Science (Hippocratic Oath talk and much rambling by JP) and Art where we discussed the difference b/t a symbol and a sign. My mind is still reeling from that one.

Latin:
Learning the declension of nouns, masculine and feminine.
My favorite phrase is "Si vales, valeo." If you're well, I'm well.

Philosophy:
Discussion of Euthyprho. We decided that the question posed by Socrates and echoed by modern Simon Blackburn is limited. (Is something good because the gods love it, or do the gods love it b/c it's good?) Simon Blackburn adds, Don't you Christians have an external standard of goodness that is apart from God? If you say God loves it because it's good, doesn't that show that God is under compulsion to recognize goodness outside of Himself?

In fact, there is a third option: God is the definition of good. Therefore He is consistent with Himself. Then the standards humans have for justice is a result of God's placing it there. The scripture Dr. Tingley pointed to was Abraham negotiating wtih God over Sodom, "Far be it from you to destroy the righteous along with the wicked." Abraham was admitting that God had laid out a standard and would Himself be consistent with it. God was right all along of course, there were no righteous in Sodom. The "negotiation" was really just Abraham coming to terms with God's ways.

If anyone has thoughts on this, let me know!
Reading: Plato's Apology. The Defense of Socrates.

Art:
Ancient Egyptians and hieroglyphics. The meaning is IN the symbol! Art and images properly constructed become the "locus of the spirit" of the thing depicted. It can speak to everyone who engages with it.

Reading: All the Bible verses containing "image." Talking about the Jews next week.

Science and medicine:
The Hippocratic Oath - what did Hippocrates know that we don't?
1) The threat of judgment and belief in transcendent deities makes moral doctors, who won't kill for their benefit.
2) Life is sacred.
3) Medicine is a moral endeavor.
4) The physician has rights not to violate his conscience.

Our second lecture was on Plato's cosmology: the idea of the forms, spherical earth, orderly deities allowing for scientific exploration vs the capricious Greek gods of Olympus.

Reading: Lindberg 47-54, 62-67.

Music:
The music of the Jews was moved from free expression and emotionality to more structured instrumental liturgical style. The psalms were most likely chanted or sung in a responsive way. The synagogue worship style most likely transferred directly to the early church. Later, the Mass took the place of the sacrifice in the Temple worship.

Reading: Grout 19-29 - Gregorian Chant.

Literature:
We discussed the Odyssey some more, and the idea of "home." The desire to go back to it drove Odysseus. He was not himself away from home, he could not fulfill his duties in society. Loyalty and roles were a huge part of the culture. We all talked about the places we grew up, but decided the people are what make it home.

Reading: Beowulf.

Scripture:
We talked about Genesis a bit, nothing to write home about.
More creation next week...

Trivium:
We finished construction of syllogisms, and looked at how to tell if an argument is valid. We drowned in the quagmire of distributive terms. To be continued next week analyzing a Ronald Reagan argument that morality, religion, and politics are inseparably linked.

We are also writing a lot of precis, distillations of the article down to the main points. Not quite a summary. We are learning to mark up texts learning Tingley's system of identifying arguments.

No comments: