Monday, October 29, 2007

Week 6 and 7 Academics

This will be a catch up since I didn't do Week 6...

Latin
-Today Ed "The Blade" Bleudow taught us about the Battle of Thermopylae. Apparently he liked the movie "300" but thought the 15 foot Xerxes was a little over the top.
"Pugnate cum animis, Lacedaemonii; hodie apud umbras fortasse cenabimus."
"Fight with courage Spartans! Today we will dine among the shades."

Philosophy
We have been looking at Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics.

Book 1: Week 6
He starts off talking about what happiness is. He argues that every human action is aimed at achieving "happiness." He denies that happiness is an emotion or a state of soul. He defines it as "the good for man," "an activity of soul in accordance with excellence." (really long argument, see notes for Week 6).
Book 2: Week 7
Then he talks about excellence, aka virtue. What is it? How do we act in accordance with it? We need to know clearly what we are aiming at if we want to hit it. His definition is compound:

"Virtue is a state of character concerned with choice, lying in a mean relative to us, this being determined by reason and in the way in which the man of practical wisdom would determine it."

Virtue is acquired by habit. The virtuous person does the right thing, at the right time, with the right attitude. Aristotle talks about the golden mean, each vice is the opposite of another vice. i.e. Meekness is the mean between never getting angry and being easily angered. It's a spectrum; each action has to be appropriate for the person and the situation.
It would be brave for the Hulk to intervene in a street fight, but it would be "rash" for me.
Anyway, lots of good considerations. I've never seen such an extensive set of virtues. He makes very little allowance for the excuse of personality. Wherever you are, you can do better and you will be happier.
Reading: Books 8 and 9 on Friendship.

Science
This week, we talked about Islam and how it basically saved all of Greek and classical learning in the "Dark Ages" when the West was in ruins. They used Jews, Christians, and Persians to translate. They also made progress in math (Al Gebra), optics, astronomy, and some philosophical commentaries.

Then JP gave his talk on "How to talk about abortion without causing a riot." Really great! Recommend reading it.
  • Basically, present "the trilemma" - would you all agree that it is wrong to do gratuitous harm to an innocent human being?" Yes.
  • Well then, what would you have to believe to be an ethical abortionist? That life is ultimately meaningless. You have to separate the human person (Valuable life) from the human being (fetus, biological). This has lots of bad consequences for the handicapped, elderly etc.
  • The disagreement is between 2 rationalities based on unprovable premises: 1) Life is meaningless, and 2) Life has eternal significance.
  • Since we can't prove it either way, just look at the outcomes of believing either way. Sketch the picture of utilitarian ethics vs. transcendant ethics. Which world would you want to pass onto your children?
Key for me: "We must not make abortion illegal, we must make it unthinkable."

If we legistlate against it, it will go underground and women will die of septic abortions. If we legistlate mandatory information (ultrasound, details about the procedure), we will be successful. In crisis pregnancy centers, ultrasound is already 90% effective at preventing abortions.

Art
Week 6 we had a romp through Roman history and art. Basically, they took up Greek art and added "Roman realism." The statues were nude, but not idealized, so you got some way to accurate statues, not flattering =) But the emperors were gods, right? So they had to be remembered as is!

Week 7 we looked at early Christian art up to Byzantine Art. I learned that the Christians worshipped underground in the Roman catacombs to escape persecution. They decorated the tombs of believers with scenes from the OT about deliverance (Jonah, Moses). The cool thing is, that when their worship moved above ground, they used the tomb form for the baptistry on purpose. Buried with Christ in baptism...so cool.
The Byzantine art is beautiful too. Hooray for public funds for church buildings! The giant basilicas in Constantinople (Hagia Sophia) and Ravenna are amazing. They were little microcosms of the Christian universe, Christ up top in the dome, angels and saints on the walls, believers on the floor. Recipients of the sacrifice that was being re-presented in the present.

Music
We had a test this week up to Gregorian chant and the development of songs with more than one part (polyphony). After the year 1000, when we figured out how to write notes on a staff, the music scene exploded. Beautiful stuff! (Jasquin Desprez is my fav so far).
Also back then, the Christians started hijacking secular tunes and writing the mass over them. There were 3 separate compostions of the mass using this French pop song L'Homme arme" (the armed man). Pretty sneaky, but the Council of Trent caught on and banned them. Ha!

Literature
This week are reading King Lear and more of Milton (Book 4). We got into a heated discussion about Milton's depiction of Eve. She's swooning over Adam basically, and it seems her only function is to be beautiful and inspire Adam to holiness. Milton gives her a "refractive" relationship with God through Adam, but her job is not to contemplate God as his is:

"For contemplation he and valour formd, For softness she and sweet attractive Grace, He for God only, shee for God in him."
NOT cool, but he was a product of his time. So we talked about some of the good things we could take away from his depiction: the huge responsibility of men, the importance of the roles, etc.

Satan as usual has the best lines in the poem: "Which way I flie is Hell; my self am Hell; And in the lowest deep a lower deep Still threatning to devour me opens wide, To which the Hell I suffer seems a Heav'n."

Reading: king Lear, milton Paradise Lost, book 5.

And I'm reciting my speech this week. Yay.

Scripture
We've been reading Augustine on The Literal Meaning of Genesis. He makes strong statements about the nature of man. He asks what evil is, where it comes from, and why God allowed it. He comes down pretty strong on the Romans 9 side of things - God created the vessels of wrath so that the vessels of mercy would see His glory more clearly.

It's a lot to wrestle with, but I enjoy reading him much more than Chrysostom.
Reading: Augustine Homily 191, and Chrysostom Homily 10. (on the incarnation).
Trivium
We've been writing summaries of articles that Tingley has assigned. They are all interesting! This week it was on Just War, which I had been wanting to read about anyway. The article argues that we moderns have lost touch with Aquinas' orignial criteria for just war and substituted his "prudential" criterial instead. Lots to think about.

Reading: "The Thin Line." Book review of The Lucifer Effect:Understanding How Good People Turn Evil.

Whew, that's it!

No comments: