Sunday, February 10, 2008

Academics Week 2-5

More fun times at Augustine College.

Philosophy

This week we are entering the transition to Modern thought. We looked at Martin Luther (excerpts from On the Bondage of the Will, and On the Freedom of a Christian) and Machiavelli, who both take into account for the first time, the INDIVIDUAL in ethics. Luther and Machiavelli both depart from the traditional Catholic understanding of man's nature and happiness.

Luther has a strong idea of the Fall, that in the fall nature was totally corrupt. Before this, we had been making a distinction between man's nature (essentially good as created by God) and his condition (paralyzed in seeing and doing the good). Luther does away with this, and says that apart from God we can do only evil. This is hard for me, because I have been raised in this thinking. All our righteousness is filthy rags before God. I guess the difference would be that our good deeds are never good enough to save us, but our desires and nature are still able to lead us to God if aided by grace? Hmmm.

Machiavelli is pretty awful, but Tingley tried to make the argument that he was essentially looking to bring about the good of his fellow Italians. It's just that he had a radically different ethic: self-preservation is the central good (opposite of Socrates, Jesus, and others). He is the first to judge the merit of an action by its consequences. He assumed that he could calculate the consequences, but this is an error. What human being can possibly calculate all the consequences of an action? Nobody! He also came up with the idea of "reasons of state," the justification to commit acts which would normally be considered atrocities.

Here's some appalling quotes for you.
"for love is preserved by the link of obligation which, owing to the baseness of men, is broken at every opportunity for their advantage; but fear preserves you by a dread of punishment which never fails..." - Chapter XVII

"For my part I consider that it is better to be adventurous than cautious, because fortune is a woman, and if you wish to keep her under it is necessary to beat and ill-use her; and it is seen that she allows herself to be mastered by the adventurous rather than by those who go to work more coldly. She is, therefore, always, woman-like, a lover of young men, because they are less cautious, more violent, and with more audacity command her." - Chapter XXV

reading: Descartes and Pascal excerpts

Art

We looked at art of the Northern Renaissance (Flemish, German, French). It was very interesting. You really see a movement toward emotional expression, imaginative grotesque stuff (Bosch), and a shift in the way the devil is viewed. I posted a giant PDF of the lecture with pics, so if you want to look at it, download it now before I take it down...

We talked about how the artist's works were mainly for use in prayer and contemplation. The subjects they choose to paint next to one another help you to put together truths you might not otherwise think about. A lot of interpretation of the paintings rests on knowing the legends and folklore of the time, which we are getting little by little. I really liked this picture called Ecce Homo (Massys), the first piece that changes the camera angle so to speak, putting the viewer in the crowd.


Music

This week, we finished Haydn and started Mozart. What an incredible guy, he only lived to be 35! Even within the strict musical rules of classical music, he was such an innovator. I loved the solo from Magic Flute of the Queen of the Night, and his piano sonatas.

Next week: Beethoven

Scripture

We continued talking about Aquinas on the atonement and resurrection. I liked his idea that we have a two-fold life and two-fold death. We have a body connected to the soul for physical life, and a soul connected to God for a spiritual life. Both of these were damaged in the fall, so both needed to be restored by Christ. My question is whether or not Christ actually experienced separation from God. It seems to me he had to take on Himself the physical death, but in His divine nature, could He be separated from God? I don't really like splitting up Jesus and saying his "human" part was separated from God. Hmmmm.

Science

We are going through Denton, Evolution: a Theory in Crisis, and looking at the arguments for and against evolution. This week, Chapters 1 and 2 just talked about Darwin's history. He was actually a creationist and a Biblical literalist. He felt the evidence for speciation by natural processes was compelling, and saw this incompatible with the Biblical worldview. He saw no alternatives. It turned out he was right about speciation, the "line of fixity" is not at the level of species but higher up.

The tricky part for me in this is that we know God uses natural causes to affect His will in the earth, so if He intervenes, it doesn't follow that won't be able to detect a natural process that corresponds to His intervention.

JP also went through an argument for showing people that the world is created (since the law of entropy is true, the universe is not eternal. Since a self-creating universe is a logical impossibility, it's not acceptable. So it must be created or an illusion.)

Trivium

We looked at MLK's I have a Dream speech. So amazing.

Literature

We talked about Til We Have Faces, and Lewis' idea of mytopoeia. He had this idea that if your imagination is properly formed, you can read any good story and the true morals or images will jump out at you. The idea of Christ as the fulfillment of all myths throughout history. Each person has some aspect of the Christian story that they will identify with, if the story is true and universal.

1 comment:

Hemmer said...

You can presuppose the bias for this comment if I tell you off the bat that I'm a Lutheran pastor. So, here's my take on Luther's Bondage of the Will.

The freedom of the will is one of the chief doctrines that separates the three streams of theological thought emanating from the Reformation. You're right in classifying Luther to say that apart from God, we can do only evil. We have no free will to do good, particularly in regard to matters of salvation. (In secular matters, I can do whatever I want, and my will is "free." i.e. I can choose what color socks to wear or what profession to study for.) Isaiah 64:6 is good. So is Ephesians 2:1-10. Paul begins by saying that our sins leave us dead and continues by calling us by nature objects of God's wrath. So to ask an unconverted sinner to choose God, in Lutheran thought (and, a Lutheran would say, in Pauline thought), is as foolish as telling a corpse to get out of the casket. But that's OK. As you keep reading, Paul attributes salvation purely to God's action (the gift of faith).

Calvin is generally on board with the Bondage of the Will, calling it "Total Depravity" (T in TULIP), but Arminius contends for man's free will and his ability to contribute that very small action of choosing-to-be-converted/accepting-God's-gift-of-grace. At the risk of overgeneralizing, most American Evangelicals fit better into Arminianism than Calvinism.

A Lutheran finds confidence from looking solely to the Lord as the source of his salvation. If it wasn't up to him to give his life to God in order to be saved, then he never wonders if he's done it correctly or whole-heartedly.

So I'd be interested to hear how this plays out. This is sort of the tip of the Lutheran iceberg.