In particular, the question of "what is death exactly" and further "how do you know it has occurred." This came up in the Thursday worldviews discussion at the med school where we talked about the Catholic view of death and dying. The issue of brain death is a hot topic as well, and many religious people don't know what to think about it. Again, today, Grand Rounds was on DCD, organ Donation after Cardiac Death and how more research is being done to harvest organs after people die rather than from "beating heart" brain dead donors (hip hip hooray). Apparently, this can be done for anyone who wants to withdraw care, including conscious C2/3 quadriplegics who are ventilator dependent. Whoa.
THEN next week, a Catholic bioethicist is coming to speak at UTSW, Josef Seifert. He has done a lot of writing against the concept of brain death. That will be cool to talk with him and ask questions.
Lots of stuff in one week, huh? So what am I supposed to be getting out of all this?
so far I have
- death is the loss of a central organizing principle. In the Garden, Adam and Eve lost their spiritual lives by disconnecting from God. So their spiritual lives no longer had God as the central organizer, instead smaller idols crept into His place, false identities, competing gods. In the same way, I think our souls are the animating principle of our bodies, so when it leaves (or "stops generating the hologram of the body" as Mark would say) then we are dead. The tricky part is knowing when this happens.
- All of our organs are replaceable technologically, but we would die at different speeds if any of them failed. Heart failure is faster than kidney failure obviously. But the brain functions (apart from cortex) can be replaced to an extent with respirators and critical care.
- BUT there's something special about the brain. It allows us to communicate and interact in a specifically human way with other people. At the same time, we cannot be sure that brain dead people are not in communication with God.
- I am really uncomfortable identifying "the relevant part of the person" with the mind/brain. This seems hopelessly reductionistic. It seems like biological life would not persist without a soul for long, even with technology. So when brain dead people have this "life" I don't think it's dismissable. I think calling people without brain function "subhuman" or vegetables devalues all humans with poor functional status or mental function. We cannot say their lives are not worth living b/c we are not them!
- Our society is repulsed by all dependence and disability. We have false ideas about our independence and autonomy. We do not place value on the other side of illness which is caring, unconditional love which will never be reciprocated. Is this caring for the disabled, even brain dead, useless? Is it not "heroic" and Christ-like?
- I don't know Jack about this, but neither does anyone else. and those who sound very sure of their definitions of death scare me. People need to be a little more cautious before they go pulling plugs.
That's it. It's confusing, but an important thing to consider. I like cardiac death myself. I'm old school like that, it's very simple. Although there are cases of people "autoresucitating" after pulselessness of 10-20 minutes or something crazy like that.
No easy answer.
1 comment:
Ah, the mind of Jenny Holmes...such a wonderful thing! Great thoughts, friend. I particularly like #5...our mental separation from others and our surrounding environment is more crippling than physical malady.
Post a Comment