Saturday, October 04, 2008

Movie Review - Religulous


I dropped a lot of coin watching movies today. The first (Religulous) I couldn't convince anyone to see with me so I just went. The second (Ghost Town - hilarious!) Kris and Carlos invited me to, and I don't like to turn down invites. Talk about dramatically different films!

Religulous

Of course, if you've seen the previews, you know his selection bias is ridiculous. He picks mostly extreme cases of corruption or lunacy, but some of his critiques of religion are valid. I actually laughed through the first half, which I didn't expect to do. We have the right to laugh at ourselves sometimes, right? We know a lot of what we do is non-sensical to the outsider, and that's hard to avoid. But really - the bling, the claiming to be Jesus incarnate, and the Creation museum are easy prey. He did not interview any intelligible or moderate Christians until the end, a Catholic astronomer explained a few things to him.

In general, he was equally dismissive of all religions, including Islam, Judaism, Mormonism, Christian Science, and Catholicism. I agree with him that faith is often preached as a substitute for thinking, and so religious people sometimes abdicate from rational self-criticism. Of course brainwashing takes place, religious leaders manipulate credulous people, and power is abused. BUT the interesting thing is that he often used Jesus' words to criticize religious leaders for sins like nationalism and greed. So he acknowledged that while Jesus did have some good teachings, the church doesn't follow them, and THAT's where the problems come in. However, the issue of OT violence came up, which is a tough one. He also ruled out any miracles as coincidence and dismissed people's personal testimonies as evidence, so you have to wonder how "open" he was to start. He asked a question I think a lot of people ask: If God is real, why doesn't He just show up and destroy the devil and put it all right? That's an interesting question.

The end kind of took a nose dive into his own soap box: the violence of religion. He painted an apocalyptic scenario where all the religions of the world will kill each other over the Holy Land or something. His parting thoughts were that we should all just grow out of this Santa Claus delusion and act like civil adults. "Grow up, or die." Wow.

Guess he's never heard of Communism and the violence that accompanied atheist states, but we won't talk about that. Or the fact that if we are products of natural selection, the religious impulse is inexplicable altogether. Or the fact that religious people throughout history have been the strongest proponents of peace and human rights. Or the fact that the Christian story does not paint man as an angel, but as a fallen sinner, and so corruption doesn't really disprove it. However, if the atheist story of naturalistic evolution is true, the facts that we don't all kill each other and/or have as many babies as possible are difficult to account for. Hmmm.
Whatever. The thing that was clear to me about this movie is that the things of God are indeed foolishness to the world. If someone has not had an encounter with God that they feel is personally compelling, you can't argue them into belief. Jesus says the sheep hear His voice, and ultimately, that's not something we can transfer to others. Also, the church should face its problems and not just get offended for people bringing them up. We need to listen to Jesus a little closer before we claim to be speaking for Him. And when people ask valid questions, don't answer with "the Bible says so," if they don't stinking believe in the Bible! Try to give comprehensible answers, please. It's not easy, but it has to be done without us always retreating into the cocoon of "faith."

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Great comments! I thumbed through an article in the magazine Mother Jones at the airport. The article highlighted this movie. And in the interview Bill just went off on God and religion and spirituality in general. Not surprising in a radical mag like MJ!

But, I have to say that it's difficult to take Bill Mahr seriouisly. He's got a lot of sensationalism in him. I basically think he's kind of a living cartoon. More shock jock than serious journalist.

That being said, imho, our role really isn't to argue with detractors. There's tons in scripture about this. Have you ever heard of anyone ever getting argued into the Kingdom of God? Me neither.

Our road is a narrow one in part b/c we are called to love DESPITE the detractors. When they hate us we are told to love and bless in return. How very hard this is! But we CAN do it in the power of Christ.

How can we be Christ in response to these accusations? How can we trust God more to not take offense to it but to bless what He is blessing?

Good stuff Sister!

See you next week at LGBC!

Rich

http://www.acupofrich.com

Anonymous said...

Oh...I want to add that it sounds like some of Bill's criticism is well deserved. Much of the church DOES need to grow up in Christ!

Blah. Peace!

Anonymous said...

I'm a fan of Bill Mahr's political humor, but his stance on religion turns me off. It's not that what he says is ever invalid. It's just a matter of degree. Yes, there are many mindless people who have faith in religion just as there are many mindless people who have faith in the Republican party or the Democratic party. Putting a microphone in front on such people is always an easy laugh, but doesn't really reflect the depth of the issue.

There are so many positive things about religion's role in the world that Mahr fails to realize. Setting aside the issue of the afterlife, people learn their basic values from religion. Religion provides a framework with how one can live and intereact in a civil society. Religion provides comfort to countless people. In the world of medicine, I'm always amazed how people with faith tend to weather crises to a much greater extent.

Does this outweigh the Crusades or 911? Actually, yes - I think it does. A handful of events over several thousand years versus billions of people taught by, raised on and comforted by God. I think the balance is strongly towards religion.

Now certainly religious organizations must be more self-regulating than ever. There is far more scrutiny than ever before. However, it's really a positive thing. It holds us all to a higher standard. Tolerance must be a mantra of all religions.

My 2 cents...

Anonymous said...

Yeah, I think that religion has had a real stimgma attached to it and rather unfairly. To me religion is just a tool or a frame work. No more, no less. Can it be over elevated and abused? Sure, but so can food (look at the obesity epidemic for a good example of that...:)...). But as you say, it CAN do a lot of good.

Yeah absolutely! Imho, there has always been true followers of Christ through out history who have humbly and selflessly loved and served others. Recently a friend of mine and I had a good discussion about the middle ages. She kind of went off about them being a bad time for the church in that it was horribly corrupt and produced things like the crusades and the inquisitions. And that's irrefutable. And I told her that it's unfair to paint the entire Church in the middle ages with a stereotyping broad stroke. The same Church that produced the crusades also helped to produce St. Francis, St. Claire, and St. Hildegarde of Bingen and many others!

I think there is a great deal of wondrous depth and mystery and richness in religious practices WHEN they are centered in Christ. And that may be the real key. They can be wonderful tools to aid people into entering into the presence of God. And surely that is a good thing.

And as you say, it's something the Bill Mahr's of the world can't seem to understand. But they aren't the enemy. They are our customers! We are the wait staff!

Great stuff, Andy! Keep 'em coming!

Anonymous said...

Errrrrrrr...I meant to say Great stuff "JENNY". But then I was really replying to Andy. So great stuff Jenny and ANDY. Phew!