Our topic: Evil, suffering. Why does evil exist if there is an all-good and all-powerful God?
Our answer began by doing away with all the "theodicy" business, i.e. trying to explain that God must have a good reason for evil. Starting with the following follies:
1) Metaphysical optimism - this is the best of all possible worlds! This view has in mind a Deist clockmaker God who wound up the world and has it perfectly tuned to balance good and evil in order to maximize....the joy of the redeemed? Hmmm. Voltaire ranted against this in the 1700's. It's a bad answer, because it seems cruel to say that a little girl's death is justified by the growth of her mother's character.
2) Determinism - This was my view before, aka (radical) Calvinism. Both good and evil come from God, He is completely and directly sovereign over all events on heaven and earth. Nothing is outside His will. Hmmmm. While we assert that God can "cause" evil but not "be" evil, it seems to defy imagination how that can be so. But it does preserve the absolute sovereignty of God!
3) Education - God is using it to wake us up, to teach us to come back to Him and rely on Him. Hmmm. But the garden of Eden was good in and of itself. We didn't need sin to teach us that God should be listened to, even though God can use evil for this purpose.
----------------------------------------------
So then we moved into discussing Doors of the Sea, by David Bentley Hart, a brilliant Eastern Orthodox theologian. Everyone should read the book. Here is an outline of it, but it's only 100 pages.
He starts by reminding us that the Biblical teaching about nature is not like ours. The New Testament does not speak of the physical world we live in as morally neutral, but as a battle ground of spiritual forces that are hostile to God. Therefore suffering and disease, which originally resulted from the moral fall of man (another discussion), are not God's intent, but a corruption of it.
Nature itself and also the human realm are being interfered with by forces that are truly other than God, opposed to His will. God allows a "provisional dualism" of sorts. Therefore He is not completely and directly sovereign over each event. He is the primary cause of secondary wills (Aristotle). Then those secondary wills cause their own effects which can be opposed to Him. God's action in history will not take the shape of a mathematician balancing an equation, but of a victor triumphing over the opponent.
Ok, so then Hart looks at Ivan Karamozov's argument: If God foresaw this world where horrible things would happen, He shouldn't have created it. It would have been better for the world to not exist than for it to include the possibility of free wills choosing to separate themselves from Him and suffer, die, go to hell, etc. "I return my ticket," he says.
Hart says this is the only argument that should give Christians pause for serious reflection. He says there is really no easy way to answer this in words. But he does say a couple of things.
1) We dont' have the perspective to really weigh the choices rationally. As finite creatures within the system, we cannot step out of it and see if the good "outweighs" the bad.
- One is confronted with only this bare choice: either one accepts that the union of free spiritual creatures with the God of love is a thing so wonderful that the power of creation to enslave itself to death must be permitted by God; or one judges that not even such rational freedom is worth the risk of a cosmic fall and the terrible injustice of the consequences that follow from it. But, then, since there can be no context in which such a judgment can be meaningfully made, no perspective from which a finite Euclidean mind can weigh eschatalogical glory in the balance against earthly suffering, the rejection of God on these grounds cannot really be a rational decision, but only a moral pathos. (p. 70)
- Along these same lines is the research (Dan Gilbert) that has been going on recently in "affective forecasting." Even in this life from day to day we are very bad at predicting what will make us happy, or how we will respond to frightening events. We make big decisions based on our anticipated emotional return, but we're always wrong! Studies show people that win the lottery and those that lose a leg have the same level of happiness a year later!! It turns out we have some mysterious ability to "synthesize happiness," to protect ourselves from the storms of life. If this is true in the realm of our experience, in decisions we have a lot of context for (car-buying), why do we think we know that eternity will be any less surprising to us??
2) Bad can never fully erase or outweigh good, or else it would cease to exist. Things are good insofar as they exist, because God is the source of all things created. (Aristotle, Aquinas, Augustine). If you don't buy this, you should think about it. Therefore evil is the absence of a due good, but cannot totally corrupt the good. Zosima argues that there is, for those who have eyes to see, visible glory in all creation and people. Though it is veiled by corruption, the beauty is undeniable.
- This can be stated in many ways: Good and bad are not quantitatively subtractable. Existence in any form is better than non-existence. It is better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all. It is better to share genuine love for one day than have someone who is forced to love you for a lifetime. It is better to have children than to have predictable dogs.
- My friend Sarah lives this position to the max. Even though she's had many a boyfriend, and therefore many a painful breakup, she doesn't regret them. She says she has learned from them and is happy for the time it lasts. She also loves every atom of creation, from grass in sidewalk cracks to butterflies and Maui waves. She sees the glory, and she's not even a Christian. This is how people really live.
- But this is a faith position. This doesn't mean that it's irrational, I don't take faith to be opposed to reason. Instead it is a supranatural position. Faith alone can include all rationality, though pure rationality has no place for faith. Faith is the bigger vessel. I take faith to be a 6th sense by which we see things that are real but not explicable in logical terms that are transferrable to others. (Like seeing the Magic Eye pictures. Foolishness to those who can't see.)
- Ask anyone about their conversion story. One girl last week said "I was 5 years old and watching Jaws. For the first time I knew that there was evil in the world and I was terrified. I knew that I wanted Jesus." What???!! Yep, that's how she became a Christian. C.S. Lewis went to the zoo not believing Jesus was God. When he came back, he did. No explanation, but a real change had happened at the subconscious level, tacit knowledge as JP would say.
3) God is on our side. He hates suffering more than we do! He is not somehow satisfied with death and disease, He is heart-broken by it. This is why He came and died on a cross, to begin the reversal of the Fall and the restoration of His original order.
- Therefore, we cannot ever be holier than God, or have more righteous anger than God, or more moral outrage at all the sick people in the world.
- While many modern people do have this attitude, it depends on a Judeo-Christian expectation that God should be good and do the right thing. In some ways, we have forgotten that we are the sinful creatures and that God stands in judgment of us, not vice versa (God in the Dock) p 244.
- Abraham challenged God and God allowed him to voice his outrage, but God was right in the end. He was not unjust in destroying the city.
- God will set it right in the end. He is not deaf to our cries and will win in the end.
We don't have to explain evil. It is absurd and has no proper place in God's creation. It is an invader and must be opposed, hated, and worked against until we die.
No comments:
Post a Comment