Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Twilight and the Mercy of Death

Watching Breaking Dawn (twice) has gotten some wheels churning about the whole question of mortality. Why do we humans die, and is it good or bad. Overall, I would lean toward saying that it is a good thing that everyone on earth dies, and that when my time comes, don’t keep me on some machine. Here are my ill-formed musings.

1) Watching Edward and Bella together makes me wish for sweet death. Their acting is SO BAD!!! (I’m Team Jacob all the way).

2) The world would be way overpopulated if no one died.

3) No one would be motivated to achieve anything. Haven’t some people hypothesized that all achievement is driven by our desire for immortality? Our desire to leave a lasting legacy so people can remember us? If we were already immortal we’d have to find a different reason to build the pyramids. If we all lived forever, that would mean that we had eternity to figure stuff out. There would be no sense of urgency to life, we would all just procrastinate and lolly-gag around. I’m gonna say the more quantity of time, the less quality. Only up to a point, that is. I’m sure there is a sweet spot where we would all feel our lives were long enough to get things done, fulfill our purpose, enjoy our family but not so long as to get super boring.

4) Immortality in a world where evil has not been eradicated is a recipe for hell on earth. Evil would multiply itself faster than good. I feel like when good comes up against evil, it’s so fragile. If have no doubt that if humans were immortal (in the present state of earth, i.e. prior to the coming of Christ’s final victory) evil would triumph. Why? Because it is a lot faster and easier to destroy something than to build it, and there always seem to be a lot more evil people running around in places of power than good people. I mean, the battle is hard enough when the bad guys die. But I’m picturing a world full of Gollum’s, of people withering and wasting away, being eating by their own sin. I think the only way to argue this point is to insist on the Biblical assessment of sin and its effects on the human person, i.e. spiritual ruin and death. Unless we are remade spiritually, then our immortal bodies will be prisons for our slowly decaying souls.

We doctors all know that there are things worse than death – isolation, rejection, despair, suffering. In the current state of affairs, death can be a mercy indeed. If you’re going to get rid of death, then you have to get rid of all the things that lead up to it.

5) Immortality means no more change (in the Twilight series). There is no aging or illness but also there is no more heart beat, no gestation, no birth. I like the scenes where Bella’s vessels basically get petrified with the venom and her blood is all squeezed out. In the movie, I think we are supposed to be excited about this (yay! She gets to be with Edward forever and have cool powers!) but I found it super depressing. When I think about my future (and I think I only say this because I am human and am predisposed to love humanity with all its limitations – I love Aragorn and the pitiable and glorious race of men more than the Elves) I want to see gray hair and wrinkles. To me, that means wisdom, experience, battles fought and won. I think our bodies should reflect to some extent the number of years we have lived and thus the respect that is due us (maybe vampires have another way to tell?) I think that a good death is a very beautiful thing. It comes with a sense of completion, a life well lived. If we never change and never die, there is no progress and no endpoint. (There would be no circle of life, just a line! No Lion King!)

Change is so good for us. Change, I think, is essential to being alive and to gaining strength (to get bigger and stronger, you have to change). All biological and organic life is engaged in building, destroying, digesting, taking in, and repairing. If you are not able to take in nutrients, assimilate them into your body, and excrete the waste, you are not alive. You are like petrified bone that has been overexposed to bisphosphonates – brittle, weak, and ametabolic. (ha!) And this is why all tales of immortal races blow my mind! HOW? I mean, the vampires look alive, but they are not. They can’t be. I don’t know how petrified bodies operate. Do they not have to regulate their temperatures? If they are gonna sweat, they need pores and ion channels. If they don’t change temperature, then they are not made out of matter. MIND BLOWN.

Anyway, I have a category for angels – spirits with spiritual bodies, and humans – spirits with physical bodies, and for immortal humans in heaven. But I think this vampire category is non-sense. So this is what’s really intriguing about the Christian view of resurrected human beings. It seems that we will have physical bodies that are capable of change (for example Christ eats fish after he is raised, so there must be some digestion going on) but will also be immortal and indestructible. The connection between the body and soul in the world that God has actually created (not the world of Twilight) is super tight. The interplay is inevitable. If there is life in the spirit, there is life in the body. If the spirit is dead, the body will continue to decay. I’m not sure exactly how that will work.

Am I crazy to not want to be immortal? Well, I DO want to be immortal, don’t get me wrong. Just not in this life, on this earth, with all these psychos running around who would also be immortal and making my life miserable. When Jesus comes in and makes everything new again, destroys sin and death, heals this rift between us and the created order, and builds His Kingdom on earth, then count me in.

1 comment:

Vicky T. said...

#1. I will refer the ethics committee to this post if anyone ever places you on a vent...

#2. Psychos are all God's children, embrace them as I have embraced your crazy driving...

#3. Team-R eal person all the way!