Thursday, May 10, 2012

In Praise of Paleo

Up to this point in my life I have been a scoffer at fad diets. All the studies show they basically work the same, which is not well. And the results don't last (because we Americans just can't take deprivation for very long). BUT with that said, I do think it is miraculous when a diet works, even for a short term, so I have to rave a little.

It started with Dove and her gluten free quackery (j/k, love you Dove!). She convinced like 10 of us to "go Paleo" for the month of April, and we did to various degrees.

INCLUDED:
You can eat whatever our Paleolithic ancestors ate, namely things you can hunt and gather. Nothing after the advent of agriculture.
- meat
- fish
- eggs
- veggies
- fruit / juice
- nuts
- oil
and....yep that's about it.

EXCLUDED: dairy, wheat, refined sugar, corn, beans, lentils, artificial stuff, honey, diet coke.

The theory behind it is that our metabolisms evolved to process fresh things that are found in nature, and the rest is killing us slowly by inducing serious metabolic derangements. It makes some sense to me, and I like it because it is teleological, i.e. it asks the question, "what is the human body designed to run on?" And this is a great question. Our society very rarely speaks in these terms, we like to think we can do whatever we want and our bodies will just sort of adapt. Well, guess what modern man! The human body is not a garbage disposal! We should ask more teleological questions in other areas of life (like JPII in Theology of the Body, whoop whoop).

You could argue (and I would agree) that we are also evolved to digest grains, since bread is like the most basic human food in all of history. But let's not get technical, just go with it.

DATA:
http://thepaleodiet.com/published-research

PHASE 1: Cold turkey
For the first week, I felt like crap. I had a massive headache for 3 days, was super irritable, felt like I had the flu, and was hungry all the time. No energy at all. I imagined all my glycogen disappearing and my muscles withering away. Not to mention I was peeing all the time and my breath smelled like ketones. I am no biochemist, but I think this is basically withdrawal from all the refined sugar, which is apparently more addictive than cocaine.

I cheated a bit, I had processed meats, diet coke, potatoes, and some peanuts (which I guess are legumes).

PHASE 2: Good things
During the second 2 weeks, I probably lost between 5-10 lbs. I don't have a scale, but all my clothes certainly fit much looser on top and bottom. Most of what I had accumulated during medical training was gone, without even exercising, which is pretty freakin' cool. I stopped being so hungry all the time and started to get my energy back. My brain also started to work again. I may be imagining, but I think my vision improved too. In addition, my skin got better. No more eczema, acne, or seb derm. Wow. I had seen people talk about this, but I wasn't convinced. Now I am.

PHASE 3: Breaking the fast
On 5 de Mayo, I kind of threw it all into the wind. Ate up all the good stuff I had been missing. And the next day, I felt pretty crappy again. My brain fogged up, my itching skin came back with a vengeance, and I had all these myalgias like I had run a marathon or something. SIGH. Dang it. Maybe there is something to this after all.

Clearly I have a food allergy, and I gotta figure it out. This time, I will be more scientific. Go clean again for a week, then introduce the food categories one at a time.

SUMMARY:

The Drawbacks:
- it requires a lot of grocery shopping. (or else you are gonna pay a lot buying prepared food)
- cooking takes time
- you feel a little socially isolated, and rude when you turn down food.
- No bread!! No cupcakes!! whaaaa. whaaa. whaaaaa. This is so so super sad. (Addicted?)

The Good:
- see Phase 2
- but also, there's not that much deprivation involved. You can still eat carbs (some lists include potatoes, which I did, lots of fruit) and all the good avocado and steak you can stomach. So it's not like you're restricting calories, really. That's why it's so weird to me that you lose weight. I'm sure Dr. Foster could explain it to me.
- my basal body temperature seems to have lowered so I can keep my house at 78 F (money saver!)

SO ANYWAY, I'm doing it for one more month at least to sort out the food allergy thing. If anyone wants to join me, I just filled my fridge with good roughage and meat! (Vtang!)

1 comment:

docwilson2 said...

Hmm, interesting ideas. Wouldn't corn and lentils (as well as honey) be "gatherable"? They did have to grow in the wild somewhere before they were cultivated, no? Secondly, mankind is very gifted at adaptability, even in their most paleolithic form. Take for example medicus internus, he/she can detect uneaten conference food from 5 floors away to scavenge and survive on scraps and hot water poured over ground beans for days on end.