Saturday, July 28, 2012

Maternalism at its finest

One of the patients I feel the worst about from residency is a little guy named Mr. R that I treated at the VA. His dedicated wife brought him in (usually the case) because he was more or less wasting away at the age of 76. He had end stage renal and was on diaylsis, had no appetite and was losing a lot of weight. We admitted him b/c he had a pleural effusion (fluid on the lung). He had it before in 2007, and it was thoroughly evaluated and thought to be excess fluid from renal disease. But it had gone away and come back, so we were more worried about cancer. So we wanted to stick a needle in it.

Initially he declined, he was super flat and depressed and basically wanted to be left alone. But I prodded and finally he agreed. I did it overnight with my intern. I luckily found fluid when I was numbing, but I took the numbing needle out to put in the catheter and I could not find it again. Dang it! I stuck like 3-4 different places and could not find it again. So I convinced him to go to radiology to get it drained. He had over a liter in there, so I thought he would feel better.

So he goes to radiology and they drain it. We were ready to send him home, when the follow up Xray shows his lung is collapsed. Dang it! I'm sorry Mr. R!  Then I had to call the Pulm fellow to put in a chest tube, which is a rather more invasive and painful procedure. He did not like that at all. Over the night he got more confused and pulled out his chest tube. And then he died. Only we don't say died, that sounds too final. We say, he "coded," lost his pulse. The code team arrived, brought him back to life, and put him on a breathing machine. He was in the MICU for another 2 weeks.

So then, I rotated off wards and onto MICU and guess who was still there! Sitting on the ventilator. He looked so sad and annoyed all the time. You can't talk with a tube in your mouth. He hadn't gotten a tracheostomy because they kept hoping he would be able to breathe on his own, but every day he failed. He was so weak. We evaluated him for a neuromuscular disorder which it turns out he had. EMG showed some sort of peripheral demyelination, still don't know the initial insult. He was very awake, and not happy. He furrowed his brows at me a lot. I talked him into getting a central line in his neck, too (guess I hadn't learned my lesson), because he was febrile and we needed to get out the other IV. He hated me for that, the anesthesia is never perfect and he jumped and winced several times. Sorry again Mr. R! Poor guy.

Two days before I left service, I felt the need to resolve the Mr. R "issue." I decided to have a "goals of care" discussion. Not ideal with a patient partially sedated, intubated, languishing on the vent because his wife and some young doctors thought we knew what was best for him. So I brought him a piece of paper, he could still write in barely legible print. I asked if he wanted to continue to stay on the vent and he shook his head NO. Do you understand that if we take you off, you may die? YES. Do you understand that it may take a while for you to get stronger and that there is a potential you could come off later? YES. Ok, is there a time limit you are thinking in your mind that you would be willing to endure on the vent? I handed him the paper. He wrote "2" and continued to scribble, it was very difficult to read. 2 days? 2 weeks? months? Then he wrote "4." 24 hours. 24 hours? I asked him? YES. Hmmmm. Well, that's not very long, are you sure? (there I go again!) He said YES. [He must have really hated me by then.]

Then I brought his wife in the room and explained the situation. From the interactions I had with her, I had concluded that she was a very simple woman who had spent her whole adult life telling Mr. R what was good for him. How to dress, what to eat, what pills to take. Naturally, she felt very comfortable deciding when he was supposed to die. She had eternal hope that he would walk out of the hospital. ("Oh, he's coded lots of times," she told me proudly, "he always come back.") So I say, Mr. R has told me that he no longer wants to live on the ventilator. In fact, I'm pretty sure he never wanted to be on it in the first place. I don't think it's right for us to keep him on it against his wishes. She nodded. She thought about it for a while and started to tear up. "I'm not ready to let him go," she said. Oh my goodness. "Well, how long do you think you will need, to feel like you gave him the best chance and come to peace with it?" I can't remember if she said 30 days or 3 months. I think it was 30 days.

Then I go back to Mr. R, who is in bed listening to our conversation. "Well, Mr. R, do you hear that? She's not ready to let you go. Do you think you could stick it out for another month at a rehab facility and see if you get strong enough to come off? Just for 30 days?" He sighed a tiny little sigh, or maybe I imagined that. Then he nodded YES. Whew, ok, I thought to myself. Problem solved. DC to LTAC. And we did, we shipped him out that afternoon.

I feel horrible about the whole thing. The poor little old man, we should have just left him alone. He told us from the beginning he didn't want anything done. But what if that was the depression talking? What if what he needed was some celexa and TLC? (Which is of course, the VA's specialty). Ugh. Was it wrong to hope? In a sense, we doctors are always hoping that people will get better. We are eternal optimists, always pushing and treating until it is so clearly futile that we wake up one day and say, yep, it's over. We've done all we could. We are always talking people into interventions that we think are good for them.

Usually patients will say, "You're the doctor, do what you think is best." YES! Blank check! We do what we want. But when they say NO, then what? As a more experienced doctor, an older wiser doctor in the future, I will listen. I will stand up more strongly for the patient's wishes, especially when they are 76 years old and just tired of being in the hospital.

Live and learn.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

This is good stuff. Thanks for taking care of the old people.

Landon

Anonymous said...

maybe go visit him on your own time? It's so easy to think "Can I do something" but it's hard to step back and "should I do anything?" These sort of interactions make it worth while though.

Lisa