Sunday, August 05, 2012

Truth: What a Pain

This story aired on NPR last week. It's exploring the idea that human beings, while we pretend to be interested in finding truth, are actually not. We are interested in having our beliefs confirmed, and getting what we want even if it means lying. We have a great capacity to rationalize, justify, and deceive ourselves.  We are ok with our candidates lying to get ahead (Democrats more than Republicans), because we think the end result will be better when they are elected ("the end justifies the means").

But my question is this: can decisions/institutions built on lies (or partial truths) be good for us?

It's not so simple actually to figure out where our beliefs come from, and if they are true. We all have sacred cows: beliefs that we have taken to be core to our identity, and are unwilling to question. We like to think that we, as "intelligent people," have rationally chosen our beliefs. We have weighed them against other options and chosen ours for their superiority. But this is far from accurate. Most of our deeply held convictions are derived from a mix of experience (which can be clouded by alcohol, fatigue, anger, etc), habit, culture, and the authority of role models.  Most of our core is set in stone before we are teenagers.

For instance, take me. I cannot become Catholic (even though part of me sees all the true things about it) because if I do so, I will be admitting that the church I grew up in, and the people who taught me about God, are somehow sub-par Christians. One of my friends is an atheist because he objected to the dictatorial style of Catholic education, and saw his loving mother was a "cog in the machine." A college friend of mine is an atheist because (though he would never admit it), he has a spinal deformity that has prevented him from getting dates, so he has beef with God. etc etc. Our beliefs are determined by a range of situational and subconscious factors. You may say, "Not me, I'm more rational than that." I doubt it. I know I'm not! I believe what I hear on the radio!

Do you have sacred cows? Do you have a whole herd?
"I could never vote for a candidate who opposes gay marriage."
"I can't believe in a God who opposes sex outside of marriage. What does He know about love?"
"I could never marry someone who believes in predestination."
"I could never live in a country that won't let me carry a gun."
"I have to have a traditional wedding, even if I'm broke."
"You can't have kids in residency. They will be neglected and warped."
"You can't be a real Christian if you believe in evolution."
"I can't allow my daughter to date someone who is not a successful...x,y,z"
"The only way to move the economy forward is by government spending."

I'm not here to say these are true or false. I'm just saying they are foundational for many people and create a lot of conflict that may or may not be necessary.

Not only do we believe these things, but we continue to believe them despite a great deal of evidence to the contrary. But if we are presented with the evidence, we don't want to see it. (Capitol Hill, anyone?) It's so much WORK to rethink these things, so PAINFUL. Procrastinate, deflect, ignore. Procrastinate, deflect, ignore. Meanwhile the country grinds to a halt because our politicians can't agree on spending. Meanwhile our kids are missing out on potentially life changing interactions with people we cannot tolerate. Meanwhile patients are dying because we believe doctors should be infallible despite an unworkable system. Beliefs, and non-beliefs have consequences. There is an opportunity cost to action as well as to inaction.  We are a people of inertia.

I could go on, but you get the idea. Are these things really life or death? Is it even worth fighting about? Will the world really end if you allow yourself to question that central belief? I can tell you from experience. Yes and No. The world as you know it will end. The world that you have constructed for yourself. The world that is simple and comfortable and understood. My world has ended many times as I have brought out sacred cows one by one and tipped them over (and I still have a nice herd). It is not fun, it's actually quite disruptive to daily life. I recommend taking them on one at a time!

But No. The actual world will not end, a new reality may open to you. Guess what, it's really really big, and there is no box that we are required to live in. Reality is not simple, comfortable, or fully comprehensible. Am I saying that there is no Truth? No. I am saying that we place the heavy weight of our life and identity onto weak legs. Build our houses on sand, if you will. The only suitable foundation for a house is on a rock. And if you know me, you will know my opinion on where to find good rock. Sometimes the only way forward is to entertain the impossible.

I declare August "Sacred Cow Hunting Month." Or maybe I should move it to September, boards are coming up...=) Procrastinate, deflect, ignore.

- John 6:52-68


2 comments:

Vicky T. said...

sacred cow hunting month?! oh dear...

Jacob said...

When Jesus came to this world, he spoke radically about who he was and what he came to do. He says in John 14 (as I am sure you are familiar with) that he is the way, the truth, and the life. And no one will go to the Father (or have eternal life) unless it is through him. 1 Timothy 2:5 says there is one God and one mediator between God and man- Jesus.

With the biblical position in place, there are only 2 options. This is truly the truth that everything hinges on. Government spending, political hooplah...not important. Not compared to what we think about Jesus. The position of Jesus in the bible as Lord and Savior is indisputable. People can debate whether or not they believe him to be the Christ, but that does not affect the bible's position. So 2 options: The first is that Jesus Christ is not Savior and is still dead. The second is that he truly rose from the dead and saves people from their sins unto eternal life.

The bible teaches that salvation is completely by grace, through faith, all because of the redemptive work of God, through Christ, for sinners. In Ephesians 2, it says that our faith is a gift from God. When one is saved they experience a grace from God that drives them unto faith that Jesus is their Savior for their betrayal of God.

Belief in this truth truly does have eternal implications. And there are only 2 options. No middle ground, no grey areas, no relative opinons, no maybes, no compromises.