Sunday, January 13, 2008

Academics - Week 2-1

So back from the break, we dived in with both feet...

Philosophy

We entered into the ever-dreaded discussion of "free will and predestination." Tingley introduced the discussion last semester and we read Augustine (On Grace and Free Will) over Christmas. Basically, Augustine says 1) of course we have free will or else God wouldn't command us to do anything and offer consequences based on our actions 2) our will is free to do evil apart from God's grace but not good 3) in doing good acts, God prepares our will to act (operation) and then helps us act when our will has chosen a course (co-operation). We are told to pray for this grace so that we will be able to obey.

When it comes down to it, all good actions that we do are preceded by some kind of "illumination" that makes us see, desire, intend, and do a good thing. This illumination is not from us, but God.

We should remember that He says, "Make you a new heart and a new spirit," who also promises, "I will give you a new heart, and a new spirit will I put within you." Ezekiel 36:26 How is it, then, that He who says, "Make you," also says, "I will give you"? Why does He command, if He is to give? Why does He give if man is to make, except it be that He gives what He commands when He helps him to obey whom He commands? There is, however, always within us a free will,—but it is not always good; for it is either free from righteousness when it serves sin,—and then it is evil,—or else it is free from sin when it serves righteousness,—and then it is good. But the grace of God is always good; and by it it comes to pass that a man is of a good will, though he was before of an evil one. (Ch. 31)
***
God commands some things which we cannot do, in order that we may know what we ought to ask of Him. For this is faith itself, which obtains by prayer what the law commands. (Ch. 32)...

For it is certain that we keep the commandments if we will; but because the will is prepared by the Lord, we must ask of Him for such a force of will as suffices to make us act by the willing. It is certain that it is we that will when we will, but it is He who makes us will what is good, of whom it is said (as he has just now expressed it), "The will is prepared by the Lord." Proverbs 8:35 Of the same Lord it is said, "The steps of a man are ordered by the Lord, and his way does He will." Of the same Lord again it is said, "It is God who works in you, even to will!" Philippians 2:13 It is certain that it is we that act when we act; but it is He who makes us act, by applying efficacious powers to our will, who has said, "I will make you to walk in my statutes, and to observe my judgments, and to do them." Ezekiel 36:27 When he says, "I will make you . . . to do them,"what else does He say in fact than, "-->I will take away from you your heart of stone," from which used to arise your inability to act, "and I will give you a heart of flesh,"Ezekiel 36:26 in order that you may act?

***

So where is the justice? How can God hold us accountable if He has not given us the grace to obey? Augustine says that God is never unjust. Every man is sinful and worthy of condemnation on his own. God can be merciful and give good things to evil people, or be just in giving bad things to evil people. But He is never unjust; He never renders punishment for goodness.

It's all very mysterious. We didn't actually come to Augustine's definition of freedom, but we will this week.

Reading: Thomas Aquinas, Shorter Summa Theologica.

Art

We were going to talk about Renaissance Art, but Tingley got side-tracked because of our final exams. It seems many students talk as if having faith is somehow higher than reason. So he went into a long discussion about how God created our minds to honor Him, and that not using reason is throwing His gift back at Him, settling for animality. Reason is all we have to tell us when we are going wrong, and where to look to correct it. Our premises are wrong, we can err in our beliefs, but the process of reason itself helps us correct ourselves all the time.

Also, since God is truth, seeking truth is seeking God. Not caring about the truth of a particular issue (i.e. the history of the Renaissance) is being indifferent to God and the world He placed us in. We should seek the truth of a subject if we are to speak about it. Otherwise, we should keep our mouths shut! Though we realize we will never have the full picture, this does not mean our search is useless. It just means we should be humble in talking to others about it.

Reading: Gombric on the Renaissance

Music
More on Handel vs. Bach. Handel is light and fluffy, much easier to follow than Bach, but not nearly the genius Bach was, according to Warren.

Reading: Classical Music in Grout

Literature

We talked about the stories we wrote for Tucker. I was a bit frustrated, seeing as how he gave us no direction before the stories were due, and lectured on story writing afterwards. But whatever, I'm pretty sure I can never bring myself to write the style he is looking for, i.e. over the top. So I'll stick to the research paper option this term. (sour grapes, yeah, yeah, I know.)

Reading: Lilith
Science

John Patrick told the story of how we got to atheistic science from the highly religious scientists in the Middle Ages. Basically, once they began experiment and theorizing, they developed a method which was highly successful for discovering physical truth. God was no longer "needed" for the doing of science. There is no problem as long as one understands that this is an atheistic fiction, a useful model within limits. The problem arises when it is extended into all realms.

No comments: