Sunday, January 20, 2008

Academics Week 2-2

As usual, for more detail, see the notes under Augustine - 2nd Semester

Philosophy

We continued the conversation on free will until we arrived at Augustine's definition of freedom. Think about a time when you overcame your natural stingy-ness and gave someone some money. As you reached into your pocket, your hand grabbed the money and you willingly gave it away. The minute before you didn't want to, then something changed and you wanted to. Augustine calls this 'grace,' the power to do good that comes from God. Freedom under the lordship of Christ is a special kind of freedom; he works through our will to make us want to do good. He frees us from the compulsion of sinning, and causes our desire to change. We are not being forced against our wills (we don't feel like puppets), we are doing good out of our will.

We need to consider the welfare of our soul before we decide whether freedom meaning "unconstrained" is possible, beneficial, or desireable. When we are in a sinful condition, we are free to do what we want, but we don't want the right things. Sigh.

Onto Thomas Aquinas. Aquinas agrees with Augustine that the action of God in preparing our wills (giving us insight into good and then preparing us to will it), is not inconsistent with our freedom. God is the first cause of our actions, while we are the efficient cause, in the Aristotelian sense.

"Free will is the subject of grace by the help of which it chooses what is good."

"By moving them, he does not deprive their actions of being voluntary; but rather He is the cause of this very thing in them; for He operates in each thing according to its own nature."
-Aquinas


Reading: The Shorter Summa, On the Virtues

Art

We continued our discussion of the Renaissance. The usually story of the Renaissance as concocted by 19th century historians was that it was the age of humanism triumphing over religion. Man liberated himself from the bonds of faith and supersition, relying instead on reason and self-fashioning. BUT, is this really the case?

Tingley put forth the idea that the Renaissance men were not striving to get rid of God, but instead exploring the greatness of human nature as created by God. Man IS great. This does not mean that God is not greater, it just means that in God's image, we have a lot of amazing capacties that we should develop and not thwart. In striving to bring ourselves nearer to God, we glorify Him.
This story is hard for moderns to swallow (especially a Prot like me who is sold on total depravity. 'O what a rogue and peasant slave am I'). I want to say that man is nothing apart from God and is basically ruined by sin. Tingley makes the case that human NATURE was not ruined by the fall, but we are in a sinful CONDITION. Our task is to live in accordance with our God-given nature, liberated by Christ from our sin.

Granted, the Renaissance did have signs of going wrong, pieces of self-absorbed and perverse art as much as any other era. And it did pave the way for secularism, but it's achievemnets cannot be wholly claimed by secularism. They were still church men doing most of the art!

And we talked about art as well. Characteristics of Renaissance art are typically held to be greater naturalism, portrayals of space and perspective, greater interest in painting the world as we see it, and portrayals of the greatness of man.

Again I love the Tres Riches (15th c)- the first portrayal of night ever. Christ in Gethsemane, so beautiful. Other great works include Primavera, Michelangelo's David (circumcised or not?? that is the question), and works by Mantegna. How can you not appreciate the beauty of these works? Wish we had more time on them.

Reading: more Renaissance


Music

Handel's Messiah was the subject of study. Prof. Warren read us lots of juicy tidbits on Handel's life, he was quite a character. No doubt Messiah is an inspired work, I'll have lots of trivia to spout off next time I go see it.

to be cont'd




No comments: