
These comments inspired by a recent discussion with a certain set of brothers-against-fatness. You know who you are =)
Fatness is a strange thing. In some places and times, it's beautiful, a sign of prosperity and prestige. But in our particular time, it's basically the number 1 sin. As a recent article in the Utne Reader states,
"Short of burning obese people in effigy, it’s hard to imagine how we could stigmatize fat more in this culture. Body hatred is regarded as a feminine virtue."
"Short of burning obese people in effigy, it’s hard to imagine how we could stigmatize fat more in this culture. Body hatred is regarded as a feminine virtue."
Given this negative side of hating fat people, calling them gluttons, etc. that our society engages in, where should I "stand"? Not that I really have to have a stand per se in order to treat them like I treat everyone else (which all around needs improving). Is it beautiful? Or is it ugly? Should I celebrate it or just tolerate it?
As a human, I can say every person contains beauty. Period. Women who carry themselves with grace and beauty come in all sizes. I think movies like Shallow Hal and recent photo shoots have made the much needed argument that beauty is more than being thin and blonde.
As a future doctor, above a certain threshold, obesity increases disease, but not as much as traditionally thought. A fat person who is active is medically in much better health than a thin person who is active. I'll do my part to recommend things for weight loss, but in my limited experience, weight loss is a community effort. Most of the people who are obese do not have the supports in place to make the life-altering changes that weight loss requires. Moving to a place where you can exercise, getting away from your desk job, etc. Big changes.
There's so much to it, so many choices, emotions, moods, stigmas, and judgments that surround food and weight. I just know that I am totally ANTI- the Hollywood image that fuels anorexia and bulimia. So we all need to "expand" our idea of the ideal female figure for sure. I have no problem with the present attempts to glorify the generous figure; it's a necessary over-correction to the American dogma of Barbie.
As for the celebrate vs. tolerate question, I do think that obesity is not God's ideal state of health for many people, the genetic cases aside. But others do need help, and they, if they are our friends, need support from us. Peggy Noonan's comments on the new America's attitude (toward a pregnant teen at graduation) I think can apply to those cases where moral issues may be at play...when over eating is endangering the individual and society (via medical expenses and mortality).
The old America had a delicate sense of the difference between the general (“We disapprove”) and the particular (Let’s go help her”). We had the moral self-confidence to sustain the paradox, to sustain the distance between “official” disapproval and “unofficial” succor. The old America would not have applauded the girl in the big graduation gown, but some of its individuals would have helped her not only materially but with some measure of emotional support. We don’t so much anymore. For all our tolerance and talk we don’t show much love to what used to be called girls in trouble. As we’ve gotten more open-minded we’ve gotten more closed-hearted.
Thoughts?
No comments:
Post a Comment