For those of you who were sorely disappointed that I petered out in the last month, I'm gonna do short summaries of the things I'll take away from the last part of the year.
Utilitarianism
You meet a lot of people who claim to be Utilitarian, they say they make decisions based on the "greatest good for the greatest number of people." (especially in medicine, where utilitarian means that doctors consider the expense of the treatment and whether or not the patient is "worth it.") Utilitarian also means that "the ends justify the means," or it doesn't matter how you do something, as long as you get the result you want. This goes back to Machiavelli, but the formal statement of Utilitarianism is from John Stewart Mill (1806-1873). The things that stuck out to me in class were:
1) He claimed, based on the fact that there is controversy in ethics, that mankind had not figured out how to determine right and wrong. What's interesting about this thought, is that he assumes that if people had find a perfect ethics, they would accept it without argument, like proof of gravity or something. But in fact, all of us seem hardwired to fight against the greatest of ethical systems because those systems often make demands on us that are difficult. So Tingley pointed out that controversy in ethics is only proof that we aren't always looking for truth if it will cost us something.
So Mill sets out to solve the controversy once and for all by proposing a simple calculation for doing good...net pleasure> net pain, with a few qualifications.
2) This is the source of the idea: "do whatever makes you happy as long as it doesn't hurt anyone." Mill does say that happiness is having overall more pleasure than pain. But he also says that not all pleasures are equal. He says men are not pigs, and should prefer "higher pleasures" like spiritual and intellectual things, to lower ones like beer. But unfortunately, no one read that part of Mill after a while, and the lower pleasures have triumphed in a major way in North America.
3) Mill asserts a version of the golden rule: do unto others as you would have them do unto you. He even says we should sacrifice ourselves if it will result in the good of the majority. But WHY should we care about the good of the majority? He only says "because that's the kind of society people want to live in." Seems like a pretty weak motive to me.
4) Major flaw: Is anyone ever able to accurately calculate the impact of their actions before they do them? The world is so complicated, and life so unpredictable, it seems it would be better to have an ethical system that could determine if an act was good or bad on it's own, regardless of consequences.
No comments:
Post a Comment