For those of you who are afraid to read philosophy, read David Stove. He's a great thinker, but also mercilessly sarcastic and entertaining. The book Dr. Patrick recommended to us is Darwinian Fairytales, which takes apart the foundations of Darwin's theory starting from Malthus' theories on population. The interesting thing is that he is not a religious person of any sort, only standing up for common sense and decency as he sees it.
Stove isn't arguing for creation or trying to say that natural selection doesn't operate in other species, he is just saying that when it comes to the human race, it's not the only factor at work in deciding who lives and dies. Darwin's theory is an "insult to the race," he says.
One point that stuck out to me was the lunacy of trying to "enforce" natural selection. IF natural selection is a "universal law for all times and places" then it shouldn't need our help!! And if the human race is always working against this law, with things like birth control, medicine, celibacy, etc, then we are exceptions to the rule, even if it does operate in plants and animals.
The 2 fundamentals of Darwin's theory are
1) organisms vary over time in heritable ways, and
2) populations always increase to the limit of the food supply
Therefore, there is always a competition for food, and those genetic variants that succeed are the ones who get passed on --> evolution.
Stove takes apart this second point in many ways, but most obviously by the fact that the most privileged classes throughout history have been the poorest reproducers, i.e. royal families. As the song says, 'The rich get richer and the poor get children.' (See the movie Idiocracy, which is awesome.) If food is the primary determinant of the struggle for life, why is this the case?
This any many other points are summarized in this article by Stove, a shorter version of the book. But I highly recommend the whole book, especially the bits on Selfish Genes, the new religion.
No comments:
Post a Comment