The "I Can't Believe I said This" Valedictory Address
[Insert disclaimers here, profuse apologies]
Once upon a time in Dallas TX, there was a man who was arrested on multiple occasions for endangering public safety with his excrement. This particular man started off rather crude in his methods, striking prominent venues like the Dallas public library, smearing his feces on stacks of books. I’m not sure which books, or if he had a plan regarding the placement of the offensive material. But we’ll give him the benefit of the doubt and assume they included low class romance novels or poorly translated copies of the Confessions. As you can imagine, the regular library patrons picked up on this behavior when they noticed the air had an even ranker stench than usual, and the dust on the books was notably…different. He was of course arrested and did some jail time, maybe a few nights.
When he was released, he wised up. He became more sophisticated and subtle in his strategy. This time he had a narrower and less public target, and a more compelling motive. As a regular visitor at the Fiesta grocery on Ross Ave., he felt slighted and ignored by the woman in the bakery. Everyone in the store began to get on his nerves, even the customers. They gave him strange looks and did not respond to his muffled greetings. He would make them feel his pain. Contemplating a range of devastating pranks, he settled again on feces. It was free, accessible, and relatively harmless when microwaved (he had made sure of that during a series of test runs which he passed with flying colors). He did not, after all, wish to physically harm anyone. The plan was so genius, he could not have been more satisfied with himself.
Over a number of weeks, he proceeded to collect specimens, microwave them until solid, and grate them with a cheese grater into “chocolate sprinkles.” Fortunately the donut case in Fiesta at that time was self-serve (that has since changed) and in the back of the bakery. The inattentive bakery woman made it all too easy for him to sneak into the case, and decorate the donuts at his leisure.
I have no idea how many donuts were sold that contained this secret topping, but it went on for a number of weeks. Unanswered questions plague my mind, mainly – what the heck was this man thinking? Well, having attended a year at Augustine, being steeped in the greatest minds of the West, I am much better prepared to answer this question than I was before. Let me begin with the man himself: St. Augustine.
St. Augustine would sympathize with this man. He would not be shocked at all, being intimately acquainted with the darkness of his own heart even from infancy. “The pears” he would say, “it all goes back to the pears. In my youth I stole pears from a neighbor’s tree for reasons not then clear to me. It all seemed so irrational and pointless at the time, we weren’t even hungry. But now I know. All sin is an attempt by a human to imitate God in His sovereignty, His absolute freedom, and His limitless power. While trying to assert his greatness over the perfection of a chocolate donut, all this man really accomplished was smearing and sprinkling his defiling badness on a good thing. Man’s attempts to imitate God result in short-lived joy, but immediate let-down. While he does know something the victims don’t know for a short period of time, tricking people into eating his poo is not the same as being omniscient. On top of that, it is a poor use of his time and creativity. This man will hopefully be illuminated by God to see the goodness of forgiving Fiesta, and that true power lies in doing the noble thing. He will be restless, and probably incarcerated, until his heart rests in God.”
What would Aquinas offer as an explanation of this seemingly irrational evil? He would first of all lay down for us his definition of evil: evil is the heedless pursuit of a good at the expense of another good. In other words, every evil action arises out of a desire for something good, but chooses the wrong means and so misses the true end. Men cannot be evil, he would remind us, only actions can be evil. Men, after all, are substances, created in the image of God, and so are good insofar as they exist. He would note that our friend is good not only because he exists, but because he is striving to use his reason, not just his instinct. Animals, after all, while they may fling feces, never microwave it and grate it. He deserves some credit for his concern for safety and aesthetic appeal. What good was he pursuing in his actions? Perhaps the good of being acknowledged as a person, justice for bad service, the importance of buying good library books, the freedom of accepting our bodies with all of their functions, the artificiality of social custom, the cholesterol in chocolate donuts, the ability of one man to make a difference in his community by shutting down a Fiesta that serves contaminated food. The list could go on. But of course, he ignored a few other goods in the process. Respect for others, honesty to customers, personal hygiene, the order maintained by public bathrooms, age old conventions about not handling excrement, etc. etc. The man needs to use his reason more perfectly, and maybe learn to communicate in ways that will gain him a hearing outside of court.
St. John Chrysostom would not be as generous with this man. Chrysostom really likes nice clean white garments, and I’m pretty sure this guy doesn’t have one of those. So Chrysostom would probably not have much to say to him besides “Please don’t touch me, you will soil my white garment and endanger my eternal future.” And then we could all pray for his salvation and cleansing.
Hume would remind us that the evil is not in the act itself, but in our offense at the act, but that doesn’t help us much. Mill would have to consult his friends who were competent judges of high and low pleasures, to decide whether or not pranking others with feces is a valid avenue to happiness, given that no one was hurt by the sprinkles. Kant would tell this man that he should have thought the sprinkles through from the perspective of the categorical imperative. “Is this a behavior you want everyone to be allowed to do in situations of social protest? Are you sure everyone would be as meticulous as you are? No. This behavior is not universalizable. It would likely result in a smelly and plague-ridden world. Back to the drawing board friend.” Then we would look at the Postmodern philosophers and they would shrug their shoulders at us. “Hey, he’s not hurting anyone. Just make sure to get your donuts from a sealed package, that’s all. The poor guy is expressing himself, crying out for help. Leave him alone, don’t judge OK?”
Finally, we would turn to Alasdair MacIntyre, the Scottish philosopher for help answering the question of what this man is actually trying to do, and if there is any hope we can help him. He would remind us that we live in a morally fragmented society; there is no longer a standard of objective truth that we could agree on, such as the universal badness of homemade chocolate sprinkles, that we can point this man to and expect him to understand. We must enter his world to discover what the goods are in his way of thinking, before we can show him how to better achieve them. “Yes, that lady done you wrong,” he would say to the poor fellow, “but you gotta rise above it. Doin’ time in jail ain’t getting’ you nowhere. Try cleaning yourself up a bit if you want people to be nicer to you. Vengeance is sweet for a while, but it doesn’t last.”
MacIntyre would remind us that we do not hold the hammer of truth with which to smash this poor sicko, the Clorox of truth with which to clean him up and disinfect his brain. Truth is a person, truth is Christ, and we are all following Him together. We should bring him to Jesus, and then, after some intense psychotherapy, he may begin to see things our way. Or rather, we will all begin to see things God’s way. Perhaps this man has something to teach us as well, about being a friend of sinners, the depths to which God’s mercy extends, and the importance of recognizing the personhood of the socially awkward.
So as you can see, this year has enabled me to think through the important issues, like donut selection, in a positive way. I can no longer just dismiss people as “crazies,” or “evil,” or “subhuman.” I see myself as a weak creature, a broken creature, but a striving creature loved by God. A homo viator, man on the way, with a nature created in the image of God and tending toward Him in all my actions, even when I miss Him by a mile. Thank you Augustine, for teaching me these things among many others, such as how to walk in the snow, bake bread, and tell time on an analog watch. I will miss all of the students and professors, and the spirited life-changing conversations that we had. I love you all, and hope that you and I will always encourage each other to be pointed toward Christ and moving in all of our future endeavors.
No comments:
Post a Comment