If you wanna see the movie, DON'T READ!
For those who will not shell out the cash to go see this
movie, brief overview. The story is basically a contrast between two sisters,
Justine and Claire, and their divergent responses to the impending crisis that
Earth is facing. The planet Melancholia is on a collision course with Earth.
Some scientists say it will pass by, others say it will swing back around and
destroy the Earth. Everyone in this movie has it made from a material comfort perspective. They are beautiful, rich, and successful (an the scenery is awesome). But Justine manages to
be super depressed despite that, and to ruin her own wedding day by emotionally
escaping. She is controlling, spiteful, dramatic, and incapable of true
relationships. She sees life as completely meaningless and is unable to really
engage in it willingly. Her sister Claire is dutiful, thoughtful, disciplined,
and caring. She is the only one who puts up with Justine’s drama and is a
really beautiful example of a self-effacing saint, bathing Justine in the depth
of her depression and making her favorite meatloaf to lure her out of bed,
cooing at her like an infant. However, she is extremely anxious and a little
OCD. She also has a rational scientist husband and a lovely little son to take
care of.
You can guess how they respond to the thought of the world
ending. Justine is overall pleased with the idea, since the world is “evil”
anyway. As the end nears she has this eerie serenity about the whole thing.
Claire is freaking out. She is attached to the world and wants to see her son
grow up in it. Her husband kills himself as soon as figures out the scientists
are wrong and the planets are gonna collide after all.
The best parts of the movie are the opening and the closing
scene. The beginning is this slow motion series of snapshots right before the
planets collide. Birds falling from the air, electricity coming out of
Justine’s fingertips, horses falling over. It’s awesome. Then the end is
Justine, Claire, and Claire’s son sitting on a hilltop as Melancholia
approaches. And then WHAM! They are all vaporized. Total blackout, silent
credits. Its pretty much a downer.
The middle is a lot of character development which is slow,
but effective. He’s getting you to take sides – who do you identify with?
***
So of course, I have to offer my observations, which are
totally colored by my understanding of life as understood by the Jews and
Christians for the past several thousand years, and more recently by Walker
Percy. This guy was a Catholic who became a Psychiatrist, and then an author of
fiction. He writes about the “malaise” of upper middle class life in the South
in books like The Moviegoer (yeah, I
fall under the critique of that book hard core), and the Second Coming. I didn’t finish the Second Coming b/c I left it on a
plane…but the Moviegoer is a classic.
Both of them are filled with characters that have it all and yet are living a
vacuous existence, trying to fill it with something/ anything. Anyway, he lays
out his cards a little more clearly in Lost
in the Cosmos: The Last Self-Help Book. (This book is friggin’ amazing, everyone needs to READ IT!!) His
thesis is basically that the more we understand the cosmos from a scientific
perspective, the less we understand ourselves and our purpose for living. It’s
hard to describe. It’s kind of joking but also serious. Better just to quote
it.
---
Chapter 11: THE DEPRESSED SELF: Whether the Self is
Depressed because there is Something Wrong with it or Whether Depression is a
Normal Response to a Deranged World.
The suicide rate among persons under 25 has risen
dramatically in the last twenty years. A recent survey disclosed that the
symptom of depression outnumbered all other medical symptoms put together. On a
daytime radio psychotherapy talk show, 80% of all women calling in reported
they were depressed…(etc, more examples)
Question (I): Are people depressed despite unprecedented
opportunities for education, vocations, self-growth, cultural enrichment,
travel, and recreation
a)
Because modern life is more difficult, complex,
and stressful than it has ever been before?
b)
Because, for men, competition in the marketplace
is fiercer than ever?
c)
Because, for women, life as a housewife is
lonelier than ever, what with the vanishing of the traditional community of
women around the well, sitting on stoops, gossiping across back fences?
d)
Because, for young people, education is more
inferior than ever, leaving one unprepared to face the real world?
e)
Because belief in God and religion has declined
and with it man’s confidence in the place of the self in the Cosmos, in the
Chain of Being, and in its relation to others?
f)
Because the self nowadays is other-directed
rather than inner-directed and depends for its self-esteem on its perception of
how others evaluate it – something like a beggar in a crowd with its hand out?
g)
Because the self, despite an embarrassment of
riches is in fact impoverished and deprived, like Lazarus at the feast, having
suffered a radical deprivation and loss of sovereignty? With the multiplication
of technologies and the ascendance of experts and expertise in all fields, the
self has consented to the expropriation of every sector of life by its appropriate
expert – even the expropriation of its, the self’s own life. “I’m depressed
Doctor. What’s wrong with me?”
Thus the rightful legatee of the greatest of fortunes, the cultural
heritage of the entire Western World, its art, science, technology, and
literature, philosophy, religion, becomes a second-class consumer of these
wares and as such disenfranchises itself and sits in the ashes like Cinderella
yielding up ownership of its own dwelling to the true princes of the age, the
experts…They know why I am fat and they know secrets of my soul which not even
I know…
h) Because modern life is enough to depress anybody? Any person, man, woman or child, who is not depressed by the nuclear arms race, by the modern city, by family life in the exurb, suburb, apartment, villa, and later in a retirement home, is himself deranged.
------------
Wow, that took a while to type, and that’s not even near
enough to really get the point across. That's just the question. He goes through all this stuff in an ironic and Socratic way, and he has an interesting take on the many
ways the modern world has alienated us from ourselves. Anyway, he obviously
does believe that suicide is a reasonable option for a person in our
predicament, and that the destruction of the world is not really all that bad if this is all there is. He would say
Justine is justified in her embrace of melancholy. However, there is an
alternative to suicide, i.e. the Judeo Christian understanding of life. He
spends the last chapter on that…
I won’t ruin it for you. Read the book! Watch the movie! So
good!
Ok, my eyes hurt. Bedtime.