Monday, August 20, 2012

The Campaign: Misogynist Masterpiece

So I usually love Will Ferrell. I think he’s hilarious.  Some scenes from the Anchorman continue to run through my head, including “…I’m kind of a big deal,” and jazz flute which is classic. And there is a lot of 1970’s misogynistic humor in that movie, but it’s clearly a satire. Christina Applegate comes to the rescue and stands her ground, making the men look like the inappropriate pigs that they are. She casts light on the situation, so to speak.

In The Campaign, however, there is no shining light. I guess it's not Will Farrell's fault, but rather the writer Chris Henchy who has a rather long laundry list of garbage TV shows. There is only unopposed degradation of women via the chief stereotypes in our culture (From Hating Women):
  1. The Greedy Gold Digger : congressman’s wife who only stays with him when he is winning)
  2. The Publicity- Seeking Prostitute:  the staffer at the convention
  3. The Brainless Bimbo: Shana, the subject of the quasi-porn campaign ads
  4. The Backstabbing Bitch: the congressman’s wife also fills this role pretty well.

Don’t pay to see it in the theater, but rent it when it comes out on video. Ask yourself this question: Would any other minority group, when portrayed in this way, stand for it? Or would they be suing Hollywood and protesting in DC? Think about a movie which portrays all Jews as cheap and greedy, or all Africans as dishonest swindlers…insert your own race/ethnicity and the stereotypes that you battle against daily.

You can say it’s a satire. You can say it’s harmless comedy. But then you realize that it didn’t even make you flinch, because you are so accustomed to seeing women portrayed in this way that it doesn’t cause you any offense or shock at all.

That concludes my comments on the movie. ugh.

Sunday, August 05, 2012

Truth: What a Pain

This story aired on NPR last week. It's exploring the idea that human beings, while we pretend to be interested in finding truth, are actually not. We are interested in having our beliefs confirmed, and getting what we want even if it means lying. We have a great capacity to rationalize, justify, and deceive ourselves.  We are ok with our candidates lying to get ahead (Democrats more than Republicans), because we think the end result will be better when they are elected ("the end justifies the means").

But my question is this: can decisions/institutions built on lies (or partial truths) be good for us?

It's not so simple actually to figure out where our beliefs come from, and if they are true. We all have sacred cows: beliefs that we have taken to be core to our identity, and are unwilling to question. We like to think that we, as "intelligent people," have rationally chosen our beliefs. We have weighed them against other options and chosen ours for their superiority. But this is far from accurate. Most of our deeply held convictions are derived from a mix of experience (which can be clouded by alcohol, fatigue, anger, etc), habit, culture, and the authority of role models.  Most of our core is set in stone before we are teenagers.

For instance, take me. I cannot become Catholic (even though part of me sees all the true things about it) because if I do so, I will be admitting that the church I grew up in, and the people who taught me about God, are somehow sub-par Christians. One of my friends is an atheist because he objected to the dictatorial style of Catholic education, and saw his loving mother was a "cog in the machine." A college friend of mine is an atheist because (though he would never admit it), he has a spinal deformity that has prevented him from getting dates, so he has beef with God. etc etc. Our beliefs are determined by a range of situational and subconscious factors. You may say, "Not me, I'm more rational than that." I doubt it. I know I'm not! I believe what I hear on the radio!

Do you have sacred cows? Do you have a whole herd?
"I could never vote for a candidate who opposes gay marriage."
"I can't believe in a God who opposes sex outside of marriage. What does He know about love?"
"I could never marry someone who believes in predestination."
"I could never live in a country that won't let me carry a gun."
"I have to have a traditional wedding, even if I'm broke."
"You can't have kids in residency. They will be neglected and warped."
"You can't be a real Christian if you believe in evolution."
"I can't allow my daughter to date someone who is not a successful...x,y,z"
"The only way to move the economy forward is by government spending."

I'm not here to say these are true or false. I'm just saying they are foundational for many people and create a lot of conflict that may or may not be necessary.

Not only do we believe these things, but we continue to believe them despite a great deal of evidence to the contrary. But if we are presented with the evidence, we don't want to see it. (Capitol Hill, anyone?) It's so much WORK to rethink these things, so PAINFUL. Procrastinate, deflect, ignore. Procrastinate, deflect, ignore. Meanwhile the country grinds to a halt because our politicians can't agree on spending. Meanwhile our kids are missing out on potentially life changing interactions with people we cannot tolerate. Meanwhile patients are dying because we believe doctors should be infallible despite an unworkable system. Beliefs, and non-beliefs have consequences. There is an opportunity cost to action as well as to inaction.  We are a people of inertia.

I could go on, but you get the idea. Are these things really life or death? Is it even worth fighting about? Will the world really end if you allow yourself to question that central belief? I can tell you from experience. Yes and No. The world as you know it will end. The world that you have constructed for yourself. The world that is simple and comfortable and understood. My world has ended many times as I have brought out sacred cows one by one and tipped them over (and I still have a nice herd). It is not fun, it's actually quite disruptive to daily life. I recommend taking them on one at a time!

But No. The actual world will not end, a new reality may open to you. Guess what, it's really really big, and there is no box that we are required to live in. Reality is not simple, comfortable, or fully comprehensible. Am I saying that there is no Truth? No. I am saying that we place the heavy weight of our life and identity onto weak legs. Build our houses on sand, if you will. The only suitable foundation for a house is on a rock. And if you know me, you will know my opinion on where to find good rock. Sometimes the only way forward is to entertain the impossible.

I declare August "Sacred Cow Hunting Month." Or maybe I should move it to September, boards are coming up...=) Procrastinate, deflect, ignore.

- John 6:52-68


Sunday, July 29, 2012

Putting the persistent in vegetative state

In the mood for a total downer? OK. Read on.
I'm following this guy on consults.
63 yo male with schizophrenia, polysubstance abuse found down in his house in early June. The neighbor had noticed a foul smell coming from his house. The police go in and find the guy unconscious on the floor, covered in his various bodily fluids, and crawling with roaches. (This is actually not that unusual of a story if you work in a public hospital for long). So they get EMS there, he is still alive, but hypoxic, septic. Likely has aspiration pneumonia or infection from the deep wounds that have developed on his backside from laying down for so long. So they resuscitate him (why not!) and treat him with antibiotics. Somewhere in there he is determined to be in a "coma," though I see no notes from a Neurologist. Just b/c the MRI was normal and he wouldn't wake up, they called him anoxic brain injury.

Instead of locating family and having a goals of care discussion, then they ship him out to the VA for "placement," because he's a vet and the guy has no insurance. We got consulted for persistent fever, which is not surprising since he has these big infected ulcers. Anyway, they get a hold of some family in Louisiana. Turns out his sister is the next of kin. Interestingly, she herself reports to having been in a "coma" for a long time. Says she could hear the doctors telling people she was brain dead, and then "Look at me now!" Those dumb doctors, she thinks. She woke up. So who's to say my brother's not gonna wake up?

Oh my.

So it looks like we are getting ready to send this totally unresponsive guy to surgery for debridement of his ulcers and keep him on tube feeds indefinitely.

The questions are:
1) Would she be so eager to have everything done if she had to take him home with her? No way. Her tune would change real quick if she was footing the bills.
2) Where was she when he was alone in his apartment drinking himself to death?
3) What are the chances he will ever wake up?
4) Is it ok to let people die of infections in this situation?

oomph. Glad I'm not the primary team anymore!

PS. I should say that I am not in principle opposed to maintaining life in people with PVS. There are some amazing examples of families I have seen that take excellent care of their loved ones and it is an powerful testament of love and devotion to the wider world who see that kind of care as a waste. It is not a waste, love is never wasted. But I do have a problem with people who expect their family members to be taken care of indefinitely by paid strangers. To me there is nothing beautiful or amazing about simply deciding that your brother should be kept alive when you have no ongoing commitment or involvement with his care. I understand it is a complicated and delicate issue.

Saturday, July 28, 2012

Maternalism at its finest

One of the patients I feel the worst about from residency is a little guy named Mr. R that I treated at the VA. His dedicated wife brought him in (usually the case) because he was more or less wasting away at the age of 76. He had end stage renal and was on diaylsis, had no appetite and was losing a lot of weight. We admitted him b/c he had a pleural effusion (fluid on the lung). He had it before in 2007, and it was thoroughly evaluated and thought to be excess fluid from renal disease. But it had gone away and come back, so we were more worried about cancer. So we wanted to stick a needle in it.

Initially he declined, he was super flat and depressed and basically wanted to be left alone. But I prodded and finally he agreed. I did it overnight with my intern. I luckily found fluid when I was numbing, but I took the numbing needle out to put in the catheter and I could not find it again. Dang it! I stuck like 3-4 different places and could not find it again. So I convinced him to go to radiology to get it drained. He had over a liter in there, so I thought he would feel better.

So he goes to radiology and they drain it. We were ready to send him home, when the follow up Xray shows his lung is collapsed. Dang it! I'm sorry Mr. R!  Then I had to call the Pulm fellow to put in a chest tube, which is a rather more invasive and painful procedure. He did not like that at all. Over the night he got more confused and pulled out his chest tube. And then he died. Only we don't say died, that sounds too final. We say, he "coded," lost his pulse. The code team arrived, brought him back to life, and put him on a breathing machine. He was in the MICU for another 2 weeks.

So then, I rotated off wards and onto MICU and guess who was still there! Sitting on the ventilator. He looked so sad and annoyed all the time. You can't talk with a tube in your mouth. He hadn't gotten a tracheostomy because they kept hoping he would be able to breathe on his own, but every day he failed. He was so weak. We evaluated him for a neuromuscular disorder which it turns out he had. EMG showed some sort of peripheral demyelination, still don't know the initial insult. He was very awake, and not happy. He furrowed his brows at me a lot. I talked him into getting a central line in his neck, too (guess I hadn't learned my lesson), because he was febrile and we needed to get out the other IV. He hated me for that, the anesthesia is never perfect and he jumped and winced several times. Sorry again Mr. R! Poor guy.

Two days before I left service, I felt the need to resolve the Mr. R "issue." I decided to have a "goals of care" discussion. Not ideal with a patient partially sedated, intubated, languishing on the vent because his wife and some young doctors thought we knew what was best for him. So I brought him a piece of paper, he could still write in barely legible print. I asked if he wanted to continue to stay on the vent and he shook his head NO. Do you understand that if we take you off, you may die? YES. Do you understand that it may take a while for you to get stronger and that there is a potential you could come off later? YES. Ok, is there a time limit you are thinking in your mind that you would be willing to endure on the vent? I handed him the paper. He wrote "2" and continued to scribble, it was very difficult to read. 2 days? 2 weeks? months? Then he wrote "4." 24 hours. 24 hours? I asked him? YES. Hmmmm. Well, that's not very long, are you sure? (there I go again!) He said YES. [He must have really hated me by then.]

Then I brought his wife in the room and explained the situation. From the interactions I had with her, I had concluded that she was a very simple woman who had spent her whole adult life telling Mr. R what was good for him. How to dress, what to eat, what pills to take. Naturally, she felt very comfortable deciding when he was supposed to die. She had eternal hope that he would walk out of the hospital. ("Oh, he's coded lots of times," she told me proudly, "he always come back.") So I say, Mr. R has told me that he no longer wants to live on the ventilator. In fact, I'm pretty sure he never wanted to be on it in the first place. I don't think it's right for us to keep him on it against his wishes. She nodded. She thought about it for a while and started to tear up. "I'm not ready to let him go," she said. Oh my goodness. "Well, how long do you think you will need, to feel like you gave him the best chance and come to peace with it?" I can't remember if she said 30 days or 3 months. I think it was 30 days.

Then I go back to Mr. R, who is in bed listening to our conversation. "Well, Mr. R, do you hear that? She's not ready to let you go. Do you think you could stick it out for another month at a rehab facility and see if you get strong enough to come off? Just for 30 days?" He sighed a tiny little sigh, or maybe I imagined that. Then he nodded YES. Whew, ok, I thought to myself. Problem solved. DC to LTAC. And we did, we shipped him out that afternoon.

I feel horrible about the whole thing. The poor little old man, we should have just left him alone. He told us from the beginning he didn't want anything done. But what if that was the depression talking? What if what he needed was some celexa and TLC? (Which is of course, the VA's specialty). Ugh. Was it wrong to hope? In a sense, we doctors are always hoping that people will get better. We are eternal optimists, always pushing and treating until it is so clearly futile that we wake up one day and say, yep, it's over. We've done all we could. We are always talking people into interventions that we think are good for them.

Usually patients will say, "You're the doctor, do what you think is best." YES! Blank check! We do what we want. But when they say NO, then what? As a more experienced doctor, an older wiser doctor in the future, I will listen. I will stand up more strongly for the patient's wishes, especially when they are 76 years old and just tired of being in the hospital.

Live and learn.

Tuesday, July 24, 2012

the moment of decision

I've been thinking lately about clarity in two different senses. One is related to John 15, and then the other relates to CS Lewis and his view of history.

In John 15, Jesus makes it clear that "there will come a time when those who kill you think they are doing a service to God." The point that Mark made is that persecution makes choices very clear. Follow Jesus/ profess Jesus and die; or deny Him and live. This is not the society we live in, though it is the reality in the Middle East and parts of China where religious persecution is real. Things are simple, your life is decided for you, there is no hiding. Here in the U.S., the persecution is more subtle. It is more of embarrassment than violence. "Why would Satan spend all the effort to drum up a mass slaughter if he can effectively silence Christians with the threat of embarrassment?" So here we are, in this gray mish mash of religious "tolerance" which amounts to muted judgments and hatred, academic bias, and non-promotion as forms of persecution. Our decisions are not clear, or not as clear as it is in China. We live in a complex cultural environment.

Then the CS Lewis idea is very different. He talks about clarity not in a local context that is culturally conditioned, but in a universal "progression of history" context. His idea is that "everything is coming to a point" as time passes. While in the beginning of time, a wide range of moral choices were ambiguous or permitted, or unclear (i.e. Merlin and his magic, King Arthur in his court) with respect to God and His kingdom, NOW, things are more clear. We have more and more revelation as time goes by, therefore we are as a people more and more accountable as history progresses. We cannot say, "I didn't know" with the same credibility as Merlin did. We are post-Christ, and post-scripture, and post-internet. So really, we know. We have infinite knowledge at our fingertips. This "knowledge" of course is an indiscriminate mash of pop culture, church tradition, world news, comics, and Facebook status updates which occupy the same level of importance in our minds.

In a way, Lewis was right. And I want to agree with him that history is moving in one direction (You Don't Know You're Beautiful! hahahaha). But part of me thinks it is disintegrating. We should be closing in on truth, but we are losing it, voluntarily, and carelessly disregarding it. Are we accountable for the truth we ignore, or the truth that is drowned by media lies?

My question is, is there a connection between the clarity of Jesus' statement during times of persecution and the clarity that comes with the progress of TIME in Lewis' sense?

memories

when it's late, and I've had a little wine, and I'm tired, then I start thinking.

Of you, and y'all, and them, and him.
Of all the things that might have been.
No good can come, but in my mind
Some things I never leave behind.

I write letters I will never send
I dig and prod instead of mend
the wounds and thoughts that make me cry
the love and pain that never die.

Monday, July 16, 2012

fallen

Gonna take far more than water to rejuvenate this vine. it's not just dry, it's dead. It needs a resurrection miracle. There are roots, but they are thin, and wayfaring. They took a wrong turn somewhere. the world is gray and flat, even small things are beyond its reach. photosynthesizing is a major undertaking, and the demand for fruit is daunting, apathy-inducing, and demoralizing. what do they say? You can't get blood from a turnip? Nor can you get fruit from a bug-eaten, rot ravished, leaf shrunken has been vine. So don't even try. You better look somewhere else.

Over there, yes, over there. That one looks good. How does it get so tall and green and lush in this desert? It must have someone watering it. Or its roots have found an aquifer, a little known secret supply that the rest of us have overlooked. Doesn't seem fair. How come he gets all the attention and pruning while the rest of us get pulled up and tossed into the compost bin? But I've heard this rumor...that the vine is accepting applications, for grafters. It is a dangerous proposition, but they say it can work. I see a couple of near-composters who managed to weasel their way in. Or someone put them there, stuck them on, glued them and tied them until they stuck. Til the good juice filled their veins and they came alive. Only not exactly like themselves, but better.

It's a risky proposition, but...the alternative is a sure fire failure. Anybody got any better ideas better speak up now.

Saturday, July 07, 2012

Good Like Yoda

Good is insidious like wind on clay
Whispers and gnawings fester inside
It doesn't demand of you "Walk this way."
But eats at the roots of consumption and pride

If evil is entropic
And was unopposed
Then the world would have burned
And long since been hosed

Love gathers and holds divergence together
Sustains and maintains and orders
It can be opposed, but finally never
Defeated, unhooked, or thwarted

You can deny it, ignore it
Defy it, distort it
Stab it and bleed it
But all actions need it

Good rises undaunted
The wave sweeps you under
Forever you're haunted
Not alone nor asunder

Good quietly, stealthily, behind closed doors
in schools, hospitals, wages its wars
Of saying true things and doing small things
Slowly through time eternity springs

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

From Florence

I am a little obsessed with her, so thought I would shout out some of my favorite lyrics from Florence and the Machine. 


All This And Heaven Too
And the heart is hard to translate
It has a language of its own
It talks in tongues and quiet sighs,
And prayers and proclamations
In the grand days of great men and the smallest of gestures
And short shallow gasps

But with all my education I can’t seem to command it
And the words are all escaping, and coming back all damaged
And I would put them back in poetry if I only knew how
I can’t seem to understand it

And I would give all this and heaven too
I would give it all if only for a moment
That I could just understand the meaning of the word you see
‘Cause I’ve been scrawling it forever but it never makes sense to me at all

And it talks to me in tiptoes
And it sings to me inside
It cries out in the darkest night and breaks in the morning light

No, words are a language
It doesn’t deserve such treatment
And all of my stumbling phrases never amounted to anything worth this feeling

All this heaven never could describe such a feeling as I'm hearing
Words were never so useful
So I was screaming out a language that I never knew existed before


Shake it Out

Regrets collect like old friends

Here to relive your darkest moments
I can see no way, I can see no way
And all of the ghouls come out to play
And every demon wants his pound of flesh
But I like to keep some things to myself
I like to keep my issues strong
It's always darkest before the dawn


And I've been a fool and I've been blind
I can never leave the past behind
I can see no way, I can see no way
I'm always dragging that horse around
And our love is past it's such a mournful sound
Tonight I'm gonna bury that horse in the ground
So I like to keep my issues strong
But it's always darkest before the dawn


Shake it out

And it's hard to dance with a devil on your back
So shake him off


I am done with my graceless heart
So tonight I'm gonna cut it out and then restart
Cause I like to keep my issues strong
It's always darkest before the dawn



It's hard to dance, with a devil on your back
And given half the chance would I take any of it back
It's a fine romance but it's left me so undone
It's always darkest before the dawn
Oh woah, oh woah...

And I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't
So here's to drinks in the dark at the end of my rope
And I'm ready to suffer and I'm ready to hope
It's a shot in the dark and right at my throat
Cause looking for heaven, found the devil in me
Looking for heaven, found the devil in me
Well what the hell I'm gonna let it happen to me

Monday, June 25, 2012

I am Salt

I am salt. Let me work into your wounds.
Let me burn and sting and coax the poison from the gashes.
Rub me between your fingers
season your life with me.

I am oil. Let me pour over your feet, your hands, your head
to loosen the accumulated crust.
Keep me in a vial near your heart
that I may diffuse and soothe the pulse of anguish.

I am perfume. Let me run with luxurious excess
over your dead and rotting memories.
Dab me on your wrists
let my scent revive you when stench prevails.

I am water. Let me gush
around you, and into you, and over you.
Drink me and live deeply
live always in buoyant satisfaction.

I am wine. Let me drip onto your tongue and down into your stomach
where I will leave you jovial and inspired.
Swirl me in your glass and toast me
to healing, and resurrection.

I am light. Let me blaze and blind and bedazzle you from your hiding place
into the freedom of planets massive yet weightless.
Stoke and shelter me always
that I may fire your fragile love.

I am bread. Let me fill you 'til you're bursting
with my strength entire.
Digest me and absorb me until I am a part of you
our boundaries obliterated

You are there. Come to me. Let me be.

--John 6-7; Psalm 16

Monday, May 14, 2012

Ear Worm

Am I the only person with this problem? I know everyone has a song in their head from time to time, but in my case, I think it's approaching pathology. This was brought to my attention on my CCU rotation when my co-residents kept commenting in progressively more annoyed voices about my incessant humming. So what's the deal. Why am I always singing?

And there's the answer. Cuz right now a song pops into my head which goes, "I sing because I'm happy. I sing because I am free..." and then I go all black African choir and starting belting "whooooaaa His eeeeyeee. is onnnnnn, the sparrowwwww." and you'd better hope I'm not in your vicinity, because it probably won't stop until another phrase I hear triggers another song and the process starts all over. It's NON. STOP. I'm telling you. NON. STOP. I even annoy myself sometimes, when I'm conscious of it, but most the time I don't even know I'm humming until everyone gets quiet and I realize I've got Justin Bieber in my head and people are staring.

I have a hard time teasing apart nature from nurture on this question. There was a lot of music in my house, maybe moreso than in other houses. We often broke out into Sound of Music at every opportunity, and memorized all our scripture verses to Psalty songs. (Amen). One of my earliest memories with my mom is her holding me in her lap, "singing me to sleep," when I was much too old to be in her lap and my neck was all crunched. But I went with it, because, hey, it's rude to interrupt someone when they're in a groove, and she had an awesome voice that sent resonant vibrato through my whole body. Needless to say, it did not put me to sleep.

Then when I got older, we moved around a lot, and so...I had no friends. But I didn't really need friends, because I had discovered - tape recorders!! I would sit in my room in Kansas City and make mix tapes. Not for anyone in particular, but just so I could record my favorite songs off the radio. In the 1990s, I was in my country phase, so it was Brooks and Dunn Neon Moon, Suzy Boggus Outbound Plane, Mary Chapin Passionate Kisses, George Strait Carried Away, and of course lots and lots of Garth. Over and over and over and over.  Nobody listened to them but me. I would call into the radio station and request my favorites and then literally fall asleep by the radio listening for them. They never played them (tear, tear). I remember one year when I stayed up all night waiting for The Chair and my parents felt bad for me. They just went out and bought me the CD. What a novel concept, buying a CD! But I was too cheap for that. If I did that for every song I wanted I would quickly go broke. I also wrote letters to my favorite stars, but they never wrote me back (more tears). I was a pathetic groupie, but I was not deterred.

High school was a similar story. Then there was college. You can imagine my elation when Napster came around. Holy Moses. Instant access to every song I ever wanted to hear...for free.  I had downloaded like 3G of music in my first month. Sorry, God, I know this later was ruled stealing, and I deleted most of it (some of it?). I got to sing in the CCC Worship band, which was like a dream come true. Hanging out with other folks who were also music nerds was total paradise. (see, there it goes again...Para-para-paradise...para-para-paradise). It's kind of a shame I never did band, but i was really too lazy to practice for real.

And then, I got a guitar and a year off medical school. The rest is history. I can make my own darn music, suckas! Don't need no radio, don't need no illegal downloading, don't need no $1.29 I-Tunes. ROCK ON. I may be a little obsessed.

The good thing about having a non-stop soundtrack to my life is that it's hard to stay truly depressed for very long. b/c then I get Emo songs in my head and end up laughing at my own pathetic-ness as I imagine the guy with long black hair in the music videos. The other good thing it gives me is an alternate channel in my immediate subconscious which also functions as a potential prayer medium. Some day I hope to replace Justin Bieber with Brother Lawrence 100% of the time, but right now the ratio is about 99:1. I have a long way to go, but I came a long way.

Aaaand here it goes again...

Came aaaaa long wayyyy. Came a a long waaaay ay. Here here, I know you're also singing Heartless Bastards right now. 

To those who have to work in the same room as me all day, I sincerely apologize. But I do take requests =) If you approach me and offer a penny for my thoughts, you will likely get a song. 





Thursday, May 10, 2012

In Praise of Paleo

Up to this point in my life I have been a scoffer at fad diets. All the studies show they basically work the same, which is not well. And the results don't last (because we Americans just can't take deprivation for very long). BUT with that said, I do think it is miraculous when a diet works, even for a short term, so I have to rave a little.

It started with Dove and her gluten free quackery (j/k, love you Dove!). She convinced like 10 of us to "go Paleo" for the month of April, and we did to various degrees.

INCLUDED:
You can eat whatever our Paleolithic ancestors ate, namely things you can hunt and gather. Nothing after the advent of agriculture.
- meat
- fish
- eggs
- veggies
- fruit / juice
- nuts
- oil
and....yep that's about it.

EXCLUDED: dairy, wheat, refined sugar, corn, beans, lentils, artificial stuff, honey, diet coke.

The theory behind it is that our metabolisms evolved to process fresh things that are found in nature, and the rest is killing us slowly by inducing serious metabolic derangements. It makes some sense to me, and I like it because it is teleological, i.e. it asks the question, "what is the human body designed to run on?" And this is a great question. Our society very rarely speaks in these terms, we like to think we can do whatever we want and our bodies will just sort of adapt. Well, guess what modern man! The human body is not a garbage disposal! We should ask more teleological questions in other areas of life (like JPII in Theology of the Body, whoop whoop).

You could argue (and I would agree) that we are also evolved to digest grains, since bread is like the most basic human food in all of history. But let's not get technical, just go with it.

DATA:
http://thepaleodiet.com/published-research

PHASE 1: Cold turkey
For the first week, I felt like crap. I had a massive headache for 3 days, was super irritable, felt like I had the flu, and was hungry all the time. No energy at all. I imagined all my glycogen disappearing and my muscles withering away. Not to mention I was peeing all the time and my breath smelled like ketones. I am no biochemist, but I think this is basically withdrawal from all the refined sugar, which is apparently more addictive than cocaine.

I cheated a bit, I had processed meats, diet coke, potatoes, and some peanuts (which I guess are legumes).

PHASE 2: Good things
During the second 2 weeks, I probably lost between 5-10 lbs. I don't have a scale, but all my clothes certainly fit much looser on top and bottom. Most of what I had accumulated during medical training was gone, without even exercising, which is pretty freakin' cool. I stopped being so hungry all the time and started to get my energy back. My brain also started to work again. I may be imagining, but I think my vision improved too. In addition, my skin got better. No more eczema, acne, or seb derm. Wow. I had seen people talk about this, but I wasn't convinced. Now I am.

PHASE 3: Breaking the fast
On 5 de Mayo, I kind of threw it all into the wind. Ate up all the good stuff I had been missing. And the next day, I felt pretty crappy again. My brain fogged up, my itching skin came back with a vengeance, and I had all these myalgias like I had run a marathon or something. SIGH. Dang it. Maybe there is something to this after all.

Clearly I have a food allergy, and I gotta figure it out. This time, I will be more scientific. Go clean again for a week, then introduce the food categories one at a time.

SUMMARY:

The Drawbacks:
- it requires a lot of grocery shopping. (or else you are gonna pay a lot buying prepared food)
- cooking takes time
- you feel a little socially isolated, and rude when you turn down food.
- No bread!! No cupcakes!! whaaaa. whaaa. whaaaaa. This is so so super sad. (Addicted?)

The Good:
- see Phase 2
- but also, there's not that much deprivation involved. You can still eat carbs (some lists include potatoes, which I did, lots of fruit) and all the good avocado and steak you can stomach. So it's not like you're restricting calories, really. That's why it's so weird to me that you lose weight. I'm sure Dr. Foster could explain it to me.
- my basal body temperature seems to have lowered so I can keep my house at 78 F (money saver!)

SO ANYWAY, I'm doing it for one more month at least to sort out the food allergy thing. If anyone wants to join me, I just filled my fridge with good roughage and meat! (Vtang!)

Saturday, April 21, 2012

Senior- itis

You could say there is light at the end of the tunnel, which is a good thing because the fuel on my headlamp is dwindling. Three more calls, EVER, and I can't wait to be done!!

You know you are a senior when:
- you see the input of your attending as "helpful suggestions"
- you do not see homelessness as a barrier to discharge
- you have no qualms giving people "just a handful of norco" to get them out of the hospital
- you feel a great freedom in telling people what is good for them
- you spend your days off reading Hunger Games instead of MKSAP
- you don't really trust your intern, but you go to sleep anyway
- you can gather all of the pertinent history in 3 minutes or less

The large and serious things looming on my mind these days are:
- the Internal Medicine Boards in August. Yet another $1000 exam. Sigh.
- how do I find the highest yield moonlighting gigs with the least work
- when can I start paying off my student loans
- I hope ID fellowship is not as bad as residency

The more immediate things currently displacing the important large things are:
- what kind of piñata should I get for Cinco de Mayo, and where can I hang it?
- where should I plant this cantaloupe seedling where it can get sun and avoid the mowers?
- what kind of shoes should I wear with this dress to the graduation party?
- why can't the film festival play Juan of the Dead one more time when I can go?!

Sigh. Say it again, "You must go to work. This is not Cracker Barrel, people's lives are depending on you. Pull it together...You must go to work. People are counting on you..."

Thursday, January 19, 2012

The Prophecy of Ayn Rand


So there's a movie out now at Studio Movie Grill (only 2 nights, Jan 17th and 26th) called Ayn Rand & the Prophecy of “Atlas Shrugged.” I have to admit I have never read the 1200 page tome, but since I had a Groupon to SMG, I decided to go. Verrry interesting. Supposedly, her early 20th century ideas "perfectly predicted" the economic mess we are in now. http://atlasshrugged-thedoc.com/

The theater was full of 50 somethings, and there was a lot of verbal agreement from the audience when Rand would say something they liked. Almost like "amen," if old secularists were to say it. The one life-experience I have with the book is this guy I knew who held it as his "life philosophy." He was kind of a jerk and went onto be a neurosurgeon, so I decided at that point that whatever the book stood for, it must be whacked out.

From what I understand, Ayn Rand was pretty upset that the communists took all her dad's property when she was young. So she came to the states with the hope for a new life of freedom where the government would let you make your money and leave you alone. Then the Progressive Era came along when the politicians were laying a major guilt trip on the money-making American business class with regards to giving to the poor. So that's when the welfare state came into being and taxes went up, etc. So the way Rand perceived the state of things was the division of the world into the "producers" and the "moochers." She wasn't really against benevolence or charity as such, just against mandatory taxation for "charity." This is where her ethics of self-interest comes into play. If everyone would just do what's right for them, the economy would hum along and....I dunno, poverty would disappear?? Not quite connecting the dots on how she thinks it would solve the world's problems. I guess I should read it.

The book is supposed to ask the question, "what would the world look like if all the contributing members went on strike and did not show up to work, what then?" It's an interesting thought.

So I went into the theater expecting to hate Ayn Rand, but I think she has some valid points. I agree with points of Objectivism and the importance of Reason. But as a Christian I have to disagree that reason is the only source of information about life. And I also have to disagree with the ethics of self-interest because it has a lot of potential to go awry and leave the little guy completely helpless and trampled beneath the powerful. I bet, though, that if you were to present Rand's ideas to most evangelicals, who also happen to be right wing tea party types, they would agree whole heartedly. (Despite the fact that she was blatantly anti-religious and saw Christian ethics as a part of the problem).

My question is this: is it possible to develop a political system that is completely just, honors individual freedom, but also has protections for the genuinely poor? I don't think so, but that's because I'm jaded and am just waiting for Jesus to come back and run for President.

Anyone?

Saturday, December 24, 2011

Deep Christmas Thoughts

Tonight is Christmas Eve. Bascially I'm baking for tomorrow (sheath cake, chocolate bourbon pecan pie, peppermint brownies), and sipping on some home made spiked cider, which is amazing, and thinking of what I want for Christmas. It boils down to Aragorn. Aragorn in the modern day. Where have all the kings and heroes gone? All I want is a guy to stride in through the fortress doors with some sort of plan and courage to side with the good against all hope.

Best clip ever. Takes my breath away.


So if Aragorn and Legolas were running around in Dallas, what would they look like and what would they be doing...this is the question at hand. If you see him let me know. I'm working on my elvish ears. Since there are not really any physical battles going on in Dallas...actually I take that back, the VA is a war zone where people are getting shot and beat up all the time. Maybe he is a security guard at the VA. hmmm.






Tuesday, December 13, 2011

Melancholia


If you wanna see the movie, DON'T READ!


***

For those who will not shell out the cash to go see this movie, brief overview. The story is basically a contrast between two sisters, Justine and Claire, and their divergent responses to the impending crisis that Earth is facing. The planet Melancholia is on a collision course with Earth. Some scientists say it will pass by, others say it will swing back around and destroy the Earth. Everyone in this movie has it made from a material comfort perspective. They are beautiful, rich, and successful (an the scenery is awesome). But Justine manages to be super depressed despite that, and to ruin her own wedding day by emotionally escaping. She is controlling, spiteful, dramatic, and incapable of true relationships. She sees life as completely meaningless and is unable to really engage in it willingly. Her sister Claire is dutiful, thoughtful, disciplined, and caring. She is the only one who puts up with Justine’s drama and is a really beautiful example of a self-effacing saint, bathing Justine in the depth of her depression and making her favorite meatloaf to lure her out of bed, cooing at her like an infant. However, she is extremely anxious and a little OCD. She also has a rational scientist husband and a lovely little son to take care of.

You can guess how they respond to the thought of the world ending. Justine is overall pleased with the idea, since the world is “evil” anyway. As the end nears she has this eerie serenity about the whole thing. Claire is freaking out. She is attached to the world and wants to see her son grow up in it. Her husband kills himself as soon as figures out the scientists are wrong and the planets are gonna collide after all.

The best parts of the movie are the opening and the closing scene. The beginning is this slow motion series of snapshots right before the planets collide. Birds falling from the air, electricity coming out of Justine’s fingertips, horses falling over. It’s awesome. Then the end is Justine, Claire, and Claire’s son sitting on a hilltop as Melancholia approaches. And then WHAM! They are all vaporized. Total blackout, silent credits. Its pretty much a downer.

The middle is a lot of character development which is slow, but effective. He’s getting you to take sides – who do you identify with?

            ***
So of course, I have to offer my observations, which are totally colored by my understanding of life as understood by the Jews and Christians for the past several thousand years, and more recently by Walker Percy. This guy was a Catholic who became a Psychiatrist, and then an author of fiction. He writes about the “malaise” of upper middle class life in the South in books like The Moviegoer (yeah, I fall under the critique of that book hard core), and the Second Coming. I didn’t finish the Second Coming b/c I left it on a plane…but the Moviegoer is a classic. Both of them are filled with characters that have it all and yet are living a vacuous existence, trying to fill it with something/ anything. Anyway, he lays out his cards a little more clearly in Lost in the Cosmos: The Last Self-Help Book.  (This book is friggin’ amazing, everyone needs to READ IT!!) His thesis is basically that the more we understand the cosmos from a scientific perspective, the less we understand ourselves and our purpose for living. It’s hard to describe. It’s kind of joking but also serious. Better just to quote it.
---
Chapter 11: THE DEPRESSED SELF: Whether the Self is Depressed because there is Something Wrong with it or Whether Depression is a Normal Response to a Deranged World.

The suicide rate among persons under 25 has risen dramatically in the last twenty years. A recent survey disclosed that the symptom of depression outnumbered all other medical symptoms put together. On a daytime radio psychotherapy talk show, 80% of all women calling in reported they were depressed…(etc, more examples)

Question (I): Are people depressed despite unprecedented opportunities for education, vocations, self-growth, cultural enrichment, travel, and recreation
a)    Because modern life is more difficult, complex, and stressful than it has ever been before?
b)   Because, for men, competition in the marketplace is fiercer than ever?
c)    Because, for women, life as a housewife is lonelier than ever, what with the vanishing of the traditional community of women around the well, sitting on stoops, gossiping across back fences?
d)   Because, for young people, education is more inferior than ever, leaving one unprepared to face the real world?
e)    Because belief in God and religion has declined and with it man’s confidence in the place of the self in the Cosmos, in the Chain of Being, and in its relation to others?
f)     Because the self nowadays is other-directed rather than inner-directed and depends for its self-esteem on its perception of how others evaluate it – something like a beggar in a crowd with its hand out?
g)    Because the self, despite an embarrassment of riches is in fact impoverished and deprived, like Lazarus at the feast, having suffered a radical deprivation and loss of sovereignty? With the multiplication of technologies and the ascendance of experts and expertise in all fields, the self has consented to the expropriation of every sector of life by its appropriate expert – even the expropriation of its, the self’s own life. “I’m depressed Doctor. What’s wrong with me?”

Thus the rightful legatee of the greatest of fortunes, the cultural heritage of the entire Western World, its art, science, technology, and literature, philosophy, religion, becomes a second-class consumer of these wares and as such disenfranchises itself and sits in the ashes like Cinderella yielding up ownership of its own dwelling to the true princes of the age, the experts…They know why I am fat and they know secrets of my soul which not even I know…


h)    Because modern life is enough to depress anybody? Any person, man, woman or child, who is not depressed by the nuclear arms race, by the modern city, by family life in the exurb, suburb, apartment, villa, and later in a retirement home, is himself deranged.
------------
Wow, that took a while to type, and that’s not even near enough to really get the point across. That's just the question. He goes through all this stuff in an ironic and Socratic way, and he has an interesting take on the many ways the modern world has alienated us from ourselves. Anyway, he obviously does believe that suicide is a reasonable option for a person in our predicament, and that the destruction of the world is not really all that bad if this is all there is. He would say Justine is justified in her embrace of melancholy. However, there is an alternative to suicide, i.e. the Judeo Christian understanding of life. He spends the last chapter on that…

I won’t ruin it for you. Read the book! Watch the movie! So good!

Ok, my eyes hurt. Bedtime. 

Saturday, December 10, 2011

Dr. Cobb's Art

Tonight I went to Dr. Cobb's art opening at the Wine Therapist. It was great! I like the horses the best...impressionistic funky cowboy art. Check it out!

http://www.stancobbcowboypainter.com/paintings.html

Friday, December 09, 2011

You Will Never be My Fool

The theme of I and Thou (Martin Buber) has been on my mind a lot lately. Of all the books we read at Augustine (and honestly I haven’t even read the whole book), it penetrates the most into my daily life. I see it everywhere, it has changed the way I think. It is yet to totally transform the way I live and treat people, but I hope that will happen eventually.

Here’s a little tidbit of mind-bending Buber.
“The world is twofold for man in accordance with his twofold attitude.
The attitude of man is twofold in accordance with the two basic words we can speak.
The basic words are not single words but word pairs. One basic word is the word pair I-You. The other basic word pair is I-It…The basic word I-You can only be said with one’s whole being. The basic word I-It can never be spoken with one’s whole being.”

WHAT???

“I perceive something. I feel something. I imagine something. I want something. I sense something. I think something. The life of a human being does not consist merely of all this. All this and its like are the realm of IT. But the realm of YOU has another basis.

Whoever says YOU does not have something for his object; he has nothing. But he stands in relation.”

WHAT???

“ The YOU encounters me by grace- it cannot be found by seeking. But that I speak the basic word to it is a deed of my whole being. It is my essential being. The YOU encounters me. But I enter into a direct relationship to it. Thus the relationship is election and electing, passive and active at once…All actual life is encounter.”

Basically, what he spends the book saying in cryptic and beautiful ways, is that human beings are to be encountered, related to, NOT used. If we treat people as THINGS, as means to an end, as objects for our pleasure, as pawns on our game board, as problems to be solved and managed, we diminish them as well ourselves. We are not engaged in life (which is only found in the mysterious and uncontrollable “encounter”) but rather some destructive and fruitless game.

Notes from the Buber lecture at Augustine, after the Nietzsche part

* * *

So I just got back from the TRG (Theology Reading Group) with the St. Basil Society. They are the Catholic group on campus for medical people and do a great job of picking important topics for discussion. This week’s discussion was Pope John Paul II’s Theology of the Body, which is fascinating and has the potential to revolutionize the Church if it is understood and taught. Trish did a great job summing it up, and I’m not gonna try. But what stood out to me this time was the idea of objectification as the main effect of the fall.

Prior to sin, Adam and Eve were in married bliss in the garden. They loved each other perfectly, imitating and incarnating the self-giving love of God Himself as revealed in the Trinity. They were “all about” each other. I wish Genesis gave us more detail of this unfallen day to day life. But mostly what we know is that they were “naked and not ashamed.” That’s huge. What would it take to be naked and not ashamed? Is it even possible? The answer is “to know that you are truly loved,” meaning that you trust the other person to love you and not use you. You are not an object of their fantasy and gratification, but a human being deserving of honor and unconditional acceptance.

For most of my life, I have gone to great lengths not to be used or objectified. Growing up in the church, the realm of “using” that gets the most attention is, of course, sex. It is a very unnerving feeling to be hollered at, stared at, leered at, lusted after. For some reason, I think we women got the idea that it’s “our fault.” If we don’t dress modestly, we are “causing men to stumble,” and that is inexcusable. But Jesus threw it back on the dudes when he said “if you even look at a woman with lust you have already committed adultery in your heart.”  The problem is not external in clothing or behavior; the problem is in our hearts. WE want to use people. Our inner wasteland causes us to crave and consume others, thinking that consuming will satisfy us. But it doesn’t. Real satisfaction comes in the “encounter,” the grace filled giving and receiving that happens in a relationship built on the solid ground of love, not the quicksand of need. If we were right in our hearts, we could all walk around naked and never lust. Can you imagine???

But the truth is, most of the using in the world does not happen in sex. It happens in everyday life, in work, family, friendships, and in the media. We can’t help but think of how the people in our lives could make us happy, benefit our social standing, give our careers a boost, lighten our mood, challenge us intellectually, or make us look more stylish. The most prized moments between friends are those where there is no secondary gain, just the pleasure of one another’s company for the sake of their company.  I am blessed to have many good friends that enjoy each other just because. But I don't just want to treat friends this way, I want to treat ALL people this way. Patients, stewardesses, baristas, janitors, bosses. Oomph. It's hard. Sometimes I'm just like, "hurry up and give me my latte already!"

Why do we all have this deep seated fear and loathing of objectification? Simple: because we are made in the image of God. We are creatures of dignity, the crowning of God’s creation and we all possess instincts that protect this dignity. We are repulsed by rape, child abuse, political games. I continue to be appalled by pornography, strip clubs, and even romantic comedies which separate sex and relationship, body and soul. How much more beautiful to imagine a Christ-like figure who lays down his life for his woman rather than see her dishonored? It’s not imaginary, though, I have seen it in numerous marriages and it’s awesome.

Anyway, I would settle for Regina Spektor’s promise, “You will never be my fool.” OK, getting tired and my thoughts are starting to blur. I’ll have to finish Buber another day. 

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Twilight and the Mercy of Death

Watching Breaking Dawn (twice) has gotten some wheels churning about the whole question of mortality. Why do we humans die, and is it good or bad. Overall, I would lean toward saying that it is a good thing that everyone on earth dies, and that when my time comes, don’t keep me on some machine. Here are my ill-formed musings.

1) Watching Edward and Bella together makes me wish for sweet death. Their acting is SO BAD!!! (I’m Team Jacob all the way).

2) The world would be way overpopulated if no one died.

3) No one would be motivated to achieve anything. Haven’t some people hypothesized that all achievement is driven by our desire for immortality? Our desire to leave a lasting legacy so people can remember us? If we were already immortal we’d have to find a different reason to build the pyramids. If we all lived forever, that would mean that we had eternity to figure stuff out. There would be no sense of urgency to life, we would all just procrastinate and lolly-gag around. I’m gonna say the more quantity of time, the less quality. Only up to a point, that is. I’m sure there is a sweet spot where we would all feel our lives were long enough to get things done, fulfill our purpose, enjoy our family but not so long as to get super boring.

4) Immortality in a world where evil has not been eradicated is a recipe for hell on earth. Evil would multiply itself faster than good. I feel like when good comes up against evil, it’s so fragile. If have no doubt that if humans were immortal (in the present state of earth, i.e. prior to the coming of Christ’s final victory) evil would triumph. Why? Because it is a lot faster and easier to destroy something than to build it, and there always seem to be a lot more evil people running around in places of power than good people. I mean, the battle is hard enough when the bad guys die. But I’m picturing a world full of Gollum’s, of people withering and wasting away, being eating by their own sin. I think the only way to argue this point is to insist on the Biblical assessment of sin and its effects on the human person, i.e. spiritual ruin and death. Unless we are remade spiritually, then our immortal bodies will be prisons for our slowly decaying souls.

We doctors all know that there are things worse than death – isolation, rejection, despair, suffering. In the current state of affairs, death can be a mercy indeed. If you’re going to get rid of death, then you have to get rid of all the things that lead up to it.

5) Immortality means no more change (in the Twilight series). There is no aging or illness but also there is no more heart beat, no gestation, no birth. I like the scenes where Bella’s vessels basically get petrified with the venom and her blood is all squeezed out. In the movie, I think we are supposed to be excited about this (yay! She gets to be with Edward forever and have cool powers!) but I found it super depressing. When I think about my future (and I think I only say this because I am human and am predisposed to love humanity with all its limitations – I love Aragorn and the pitiable and glorious race of men more than the Elves) I want to see gray hair and wrinkles. To me, that means wisdom, experience, battles fought and won. I think our bodies should reflect to some extent the number of years we have lived and thus the respect that is due us (maybe vampires have another way to tell?) I think that a good death is a very beautiful thing. It comes with a sense of completion, a life well lived. If we never change and never die, there is no progress and no endpoint. (There would be no circle of life, just a line! No Lion King!)

Change is so good for us. Change, I think, is essential to being alive and to gaining strength (to get bigger and stronger, you have to change). All biological and organic life is engaged in building, destroying, digesting, taking in, and repairing. If you are not able to take in nutrients, assimilate them into your body, and excrete the waste, you are not alive. You are like petrified bone that has been overexposed to bisphosphonates – brittle, weak, and ametabolic. (ha!) And this is why all tales of immortal races blow my mind! HOW? I mean, the vampires look alive, but they are not. They can’t be. I don’t know how petrified bodies operate. Do they not have to regulate their temperatures? If they are gonna sweat, they need pores and ion channels. If they don’t change temperature, then they are not made out of matter. MIND BLOWN.

Anyway, I have a category for angels – spirits with spiritual bodies, and humans – spirits with physical bodies, and for immortal humans in heaven. But I think this vampire category is non-sense. So this is what’s really intriguing about the Christian view of resurrected human beings. It seems that we will have physical bodies that are capable of change (for example Christ eats fish after he is raised, so there must be some digestion going on) but will also be immortal and indestructible. The connection between the body and soul in the world that God has actually created (not the world of Twilight) is super tight. The interplay is inevitable. If there is life in the spirit, there is life in the body. If the spirit is dead, the body will continue to decay. I’m not sure exactly how that will work.

Am I crazy to not want to be immortal? Well, I DO want to be immortal, don’t get me wrong. Just not in this life, on this earth, with all these psychos running around who would also be immortal and making my life miserable. When Jesus comes in and makes everything new again, destroys sin and death, heals this rift between us and the created order, and builds His Kingdom on earth, then count me in.

Thursday, September 15, 2011

Carried

I was lying in my pit, on my cot, resigned
They told me it was permanent, this paralysis and unmitigated
There is no point in fighting it, se la vis
I accepted defeat, believing the doctors prognostics

Years went by and no movement returned. After a while, the feeling started to go.
Then the desire to move faded, and all was bleak perpetuity
I shriveled away, a shadow. A wraith, atrophic flesh and breath.
Sometimes I waited for a rescuer, but hope is tiresome when disappointment is the rule.

Then all the sudden, I felt the weight of my body resisting gravity
Almost like...I was being lifted
I opened my eyes and saw 2 faces, one at each foot
There were voices behind my head, chatting in fevered conspiratorial whispers

"He can." One said insistently, and a response, "This is crazy."
And then a "Come on, just hurry."
So I levitated and jolted to the top of a roof
Lower lower lower...and down to the floor

Another face inspected me. I wanted to disappear altogether, all these people stared and gasped in horror.
But the face was ________________
------------------------------------------------------


That's all I can write in the story right now. You know the one. This is where I am. I have been wallowing for a long time. Just this week, I have made my paralysis known to my friends. My faithful friends who have started to pray for me. Julie and Barbara annointed my head and prayed for me as I blubbered into some tissues. They brought me food on call, and prayed for my shift. And for the first time in recent memory, I had a good call. Got straightforward patients, capped early, and slept for an unprecedented 5 hours. I got a text message at 7 am that says "We are holding up your arms," a reference to the OT story (I think) of Moses, when his arms get tired. So Aaron held them up so they kept winning the battle. I still cannot see the face of God, or hear His voice. But I think the ashes are stirring. Thank you.