Thursday, March 06, 2008

Going for the gold

Ottawa is on track for a record snow fall this year. We have had 11.6 FEET of snow, second only to 1970 when they had 14.6 feet. If we get the predicted 50 cm this weekend, and one more snow like that, we might make it. We have had 83 days of snow this winter, and only 25 without. WOW. Texans aren't made for this stuff. I can't decide whether or not I want it to stop now, or keep going for the win....actually, who am I kidding. Stop the madness.

Sunday, March 02, 2008

Academics Weeks 2-6 and 2-7 (short)

We are going strong friends, so I'll make it short. See notes for details!

Philosophy -
Descartes throws everything in doubt except for the fact that he thinks. Is an evil demon deceiving our senses all the time? hmmm.

Hume "discovers" that moral judgments are not in the realm of truth, but only subjective perceptions. Thanks Hume!

Art

Venetia Art is beautiful. But it got boring to try to outdo the old masters, so the Mannerists just tried to make stylistic changes as their own trademarks. i.e. long necks and strange looking people. Individualism is born in art.
Baroque art - hello grotesque and violent images. The Catholic Church invents the term "propoganda," to refer to things used to propagate the Church.
Music
We looked at the amazing Beethoven who paved the way for Romanticism (emotional, supernatural, breaking away from confines of Classicism).

Literature
We studied GK Chesterton, The Man Who Was Thursday, which could be interpreted as a retelling of Job. Now we are reading Godric, which is very good so far.

Science
John Patrick talked about....I can't remember, it wasn't that great a class on evolution. But I am reading Darwinian Fairytales, which is entertaining and informative. Then he talked about homosexuality and read us excerpts of this amazing article defending traditional marriage and "fundamentalism" (by Lee Harris, a homosexual male).

Scripture
Starting Martin Luther, preface to Romans, who after reading Aquinas and Augustine seems very straight forward! Though I do think he was a bit crazy.

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

trip to Toronto

Toronto Angst man!
Rosie, Starr, and me preparing for a night on the town.
Starr and Rosie and I had a great time in Toronto. Pictures can be viewed here. We stayed in the McKernan's (haunted! for real) house, went cross country skiing, and toured the big city. It was warmer and sunnier than here, so that was refreshing. We saw the University, all the trendy shops, Honest Ed's, the theater district, and ate some great street meat. We visited the ROM museum for a small period of time while it was free, saw some hieroglyphs and mummies. Then we ate out at an Italian place which was fabulous. I also had my first 'poutine,' a Canadian original: fries, brown gravy, and cheese curds. Over the top.

The McKernan's are the most amazing and talented family ever. They are all involved in some sort of creative art, dance, voice, music, or something, and have a flare for performance. Rosie was of course then perfectly prepared for the karaoke night at Fox and Fiddle. Hilarious. She dressed me in these apparently newish trendy "high" pants and a french beret. When I got up to karaoke, the DJ introduced me as a mime. Then we all realized he was right, i TOTALLY looked like a mime! But that didn't stop me from belting out some Jefferson Airplane.

Now it's back to the ol grindstone. I'm trying to sort out issues on gender, evolution, personhood, the Fall, and other fun topics. I may or may not come up for air to blog much the next few weeks. Intense!! Pray for me, ok?
Skiing outside Rosie's place in King City. I suck. Pulling up from the tragic fall from standing.

Monday, February 18, 2008

Visitors from TX


This was the winning snow sculpture from Winterlude, it's incredible. Amber and Erin, other Texans in exile, came to visit me this weekend. It was so much fun! We got to slide down the giant snow slides, eat some Beaver Tails, and see some snow sculptures.
As we were touring the market, they wanted souvenir syrup. But I told them they couldn't buy that stuff except from the Wheelers. So on short notice, they let us come up and stay for a bit. It was fabulous as always. Erin and Amber have had a rough month due to a recent tragedy, and said the getaway was the first time in a while they felt distracted from the grief. That's all owing to the beauty of the snow, the good company of the Wheelers, a nice sauna, and excellent syrup.
After that we came back home for dinner with Susan and Starr, and then went to see Landon play at Rainbow Bistro. Hooray Landon! I want a CD. Please produce one. We skated over the sidewalks over the freezing rain, seeing as how we didn't get to go on the canal, sadly.


So we saw the girls off this morning, and I attempted to brainstorm for my papers, quasi-sucessfully. Better luck tomorrow. I'm feeling a bit less crazy this week, recovering from the cabin fever and craving to see something green. Looking forward to getting back to Dallas soon for match and Easter. whew, this winter is hard core.

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Academics Week 2-5

More fun times at Augustine College.

Philosophy

This week we are entering the transition to Modern thought. We looked at Martin Luther (excerpts from On the Bondage of the Will, and On the Freedom of a Christian) and Machiavelli, who both take into account for the first time, the INDIVIDUAL in ethics. Luther and Machiavelli both depart from the traditional Catholic understanding of man's nature and happiness.

Luther has a strong idea of the Fall, that in the fall nature was totally corrupt. Before this, we had been making a distinction between man's nature (essentially good as created by God) and his condition (paralyzed in seeing and doing the good). Luther does away with this, and says that apart from God we can do only evil. This is hard for me, because I have been raised in this thinking. All our righteousness is filthy rags before God. I guess the difference would be that our good deeds are never good enough to save us, but our desires and nature are still able to lead us to God if aided by grace? Hmmm.

Machiavelli is pretty awful, but Tingley tried to make the argument that he was essentially looking to bring about the good of his fellow Italians. It's just that he had a radically different ethic: self-preservation is the central good (opposite of Socrates, Jesus, and others). He is the first to judge the merit of an action by its consequences. He assumed that he could calculate the consequences, but this is an error. What human being can possibly calculate all the consequences of an action? Nobody! He also came up with the idea of "reasons of state," the justification to commit acts which would normally be considered atrocities.

Here's some appalling quotes for you.
"for love is preserved by the link of obligation which, owing to the baseness of men, is broken at every opportunity for their advantage; but fear preserves you by a dread of punishment which never fails..." - Chapter XVII

"For my part I consider that it is better to be adventurous than cautious, because fortune is a woman, and if you wish to keep her under it is necessary to beat and ill-use her; and it is seen that she allows herself to be mastered by the adventurous rather than by those who go to work more coldly. She is, therefore, always, woman-like, a lover of young men, because they are less cautious, more violent, and with more audacity command her." - Chapter XXV

reading: Descartes and Pascal excerpts

Art

We looked at art of the Northern Renaissance (Flemish, German, French). It was very interesting. You really see a movement toward emotional expression, imaginative grotesque stuff (Bosch), and a shift in the way the devil is viewed. I posted a giant PDF of the lecture with pics, so if you want to look at it, download it now before I take it down...

We talked about how the artist's works were mainly for use in prayer and contemplation. The subjects they choose to paint next to one another help you to put together truths you might not otherwise think about. A lot of interpretation of the paintings rests on knowing the legends and folklore of the time, which we are getting little by little. I really liked this picture called Ecce Homo (Massys), the first piece that changes the camera angle so to speak, putting the viewer in the crowd.


Music

This week, we finished Haydn and started Mozart. What an incredible guy, he only lived to be 35! Even within the strict musical rules of classical music, he was such an innovator. I loved the solo from Magic Flute of the Queen of the Night, and his piano sonatas.

Next week: Beethoven

Scripture

We continued talking about Aquinas on the atonement and resurrection. I liked his idea that we have a two-fold life and two-fold death. We have a body connected to the soul for physical life, and a soul connected to God for a spiritual life. Both of these were damaged in the fall, so both needed to be restored by Christ. My question is whether or not Christ actually experienced separation from God. It seems to me he had to take on Himself the physical death, but in His divine nature, could He be separated from God? I don't really like splitting up Jesus and saying his "human" part was separated from God. Hmmmm.

Science

We are going through Denton, Evolution: a Theory in Crisis, and looking at the arguments for and against evolution. This week, Chapters 1 and 2 just talked about Darwin's history. He was actually a creationist and a Biblical literalist. He felt the evidence for speciation by natural processes was compelling, and saw this incompatible with the Biblical worldview. He saw no alternatives. It turned out he was right about speciation, the "line of fixity" is not at the level of species but higher up.

The tricky part for me in this is that we know God uses natural causes to affect His will in the earth, so if He intervenes, it doesn't follow that won't be able to detect a natural process that corresponds to His intervention.

JP also went through an argument for showing people that the world is created (since the law of entropy is true, the universe is not eternal. Since a self-creating universe is a logical impossibility, it's not acceptable. So it must be created or an illusion.)

Trivium

We looked at MLK's I have a Dream speech. So amazing.

Literature

We talked about Til We Have Faces, and Lewis' idea of mytopoeia. He had this idea that if your imagination is properly formed, you can read any good story and the true morals or images will jump out at you. The idea of Christ as the fulfillment of all myths throughout history. Each person has some aspect of the Christian story that they will identify with, if the story is true and universal.

Wednesday, February 06, 2008

Restless Hearts Cafe

Last night was the annual Augustine College "Restless Hearts Cafe." The title is taken from the first page of the Confessions:

"Thou movest us to delight in praising Thee; for Thou hast formed us for Thyself, and our hearts are restless till they find rest in Thee..."

In honor of the saint, or Valentine's or something, we put on a sort of talent show. We were congratulated by all the faculty for having put on one of the most memorable shows in a while (maybe ever). This doesn't surprise me given the talent in our class for music, humor, dance, writing, and self-humiliation.
Even the faculty participated. JP had us rolling with his Monty Python Philosopher's Song, and The Sermon (from old British comedy show). Bloedow wrote a great poem, too.

Trevor wrote an entire speech using the letter "P," about puns - AMAZING. Stephanie read her narrative view of some Hamlet scences, Starr and Rosie dueted, Rosie and her sister did a hip hop routine, Michelle did ballet, and Landon played his guitar and harmonica, then ukelele. So great. Starr conscripted me to play the ugly witch in the Wicked number, "Popular." It was hilarious! I have no problem playing the chick in need of a makeover. I also read my poem (see previous post), and did a skit with Susan and Jasmine. Harold and Rebekah sang a hymn, as did another trio. The night finished with a "gang version" of the jazz standard "Like Someone in Love," sung by all the guys, accompanied by Landon on guitar. Awwww, so cute.

Our skit was a full-on satire of the school, but it went over really well, we didn't get expelled and Tingley laughed pretty hard. We presented Jasmine as a patient suffering from obsessive thoughts and socially inappropriate behavior since enrolling in Augustine. So we had to stimulate various brain areas to elicit what recent memories were tormenting her. She performed perfectly, quoting Latin and Milton, imitating JP's deep sniff, and shouting "False Dichotomy!" We pronounced her bleak prognosis, seeing as how her entire brains was involved. It was pretty funny, if I may say so.

During all the performances, I had this strong sense that I'm gonna cry like a baby when I have to leave these folks. All in all, I wish I had a video camera for the evening.

poem of a restless heart as shaped by western culture and femininity

I wish I had a second self
Growing out my side
Seamless access to my soul
Finding where I hide

Alike with me in virtue
Aristotelian friend
But if I lose all virtue,
That would quickly end.

A source of continuity
Heel-digging tree of life
To be there when I lose my way,
Take from my hands the knife

Someone who travels where I go
And knows the folks I meet
To rattle teeth and walk in snow
And bear the Houston heat

Someone to let me know the time
And what my feelings mean
To sort which memories are mine
And which belong in dreams

A closer bond than romance
With Sky Father* on his game.
We’d sort through endless differences
But never be the same

Lovers on earth are one in flesh
But at the end of life
All vows dissolve from bodies fresh
You’ll no more be his wife

Your husband will belong to me
As ever he to you
Like angels from our shadows free
We’ll sing as spirits true

No one can plunge my matters grey
Or make my belief true
Chasms hold minds far away
Though closeness we pursue

The grip of death
Blood delivers me

Drowning
Sinking
Swallowed up

Lifting
Rising
Gazing into light

He sees His Son in my new eyes
No longer is my flesh disguise
I hold unearned the martyr’s prize

Awake and steadfast
Friendship surpassed
A lover at last
------------
* a reference to CS Lewis, 4 Loves; chapter on Eros, taken from his pagan universal theory, a hilarious must read interpretation

Sunday, February 03, 2008

Winterlude



The 30th annual winter carnival. We went to see the ice scuplture competition. Amazing! My favorite was the unicorn, but "Canada's Ambassador to the Galaxy was pretty ridiculous. See some pics if you want.















Academics Week 2-4

Hey folks!

This is going to be short, given that I am recovering from a cold and am tired! I'll refer you to the notes, which I put up for last week and this week if you want all the gory details.

Philosophy
We continued to talk about Aquinas, and his view of happiness, or "the chief end of man." It's a difficult thing to sort through, but basically, he talks about how many of the things we pursue are not actually able to deliver permanent happiness: power, money, bodily pleasure, honor, etc. He goes on to say that true happiness is an activity of the soul, contemplating God. The "beatific vision" as he calls it, worth reading about.

Aquinas is more positive on sex and bodily pleasure than people give him credit for. He doesn't say that sex is only for procreation, he says it is for the good of the species. So Tingley made the point (not sure if it's in Aquinas), that sex, romance, attraction, and all that within marriage are good for the preservation of the species. Sex as a means of bonding makes a happy marriage, happy kids, and a good basis for society.

Art
He talked about northern Renaissance art, and talked a little bit about interpreting the pieces. He cites a scholar (Erwin Panofsky) on "Iconography," studying the meaning of art works. His levels of meaning require learning about the artistic conventions of the time, like knowing that the gospel writers are represented by different animals, etc. When you learn the language of the time, then you can get more meaning from them. That's the challenge - it takes a career to learn all those conventions! But the goal of this class is to learn how to get the most from them without learning the codes.

During the Renaissance, one of the devices that came into vogue was "disguised symbolism." Since people were trying to paint the world as they saw it (naturally), but also to represent the world symbolically as in previous Christian art, they resorted to placing symbolic items in natural-looking positions. Leaving you to do the work of figuring it out.

Music
We looked at the origin of classical music. It was really sweet - Warren played us some Mozart sonatas piece by piece on the piano, showing us where the themes were and when they got transformed. I really liked it and feel like I understand some more about them now. Then he went on to teach us about Haydn...

Scripture
Aquinas again, this time on "original justice." He has this idea that as created in the garden, there was a hierarchy of order. God was over man's soul, which was over his body, which was over the rest of creation. With the fall, the soul was no longer subject willingly to God. Therefore, in parallel, the body rebelled against the soul, and the creation rebelled against man's body. Sounds pretty accurate, right?

Literature
C.S. Lewis! Hooray! We are doing Til We Have Faces. Tucker introduced Lewis's life and some themes of the book: pagan religion, God in the dock, etc. Looking forward to the rest.

Sunday, January 27, 2008

St. Alban's Retreat

This weekend we left Ottawa with the St. Alban's College and Career group for a retreat in Sonshine Cove. The lodge was in this gorgeous place with hills and a frozen lake below. We got to go sledding and engage in many other juvenile activities. I have some pretty significant back pain today from my brave sledding attempt. I managed to hit both jumps, and the second without the sled. It was sweet.
We had a great speaker from Vancouver come who talked about how God approaches humanity in Christ (gospel of John). It sparked a lot of good thought and was encouraging to me. Meeting new people was great, since we haven't gotten very involved with the church yet. Now I'm back in Ottawa, back at the homework! Here's a few pictures...


Susan and I.
"HELLO GOD" on the lake. aliens?






Big men on little sleds (including a Little Mermaid sled).

Friday, January 25, 2008

Academics Week 2-3

Philosophy

Continuing onto Aquinas, we talked about his concept of evil. Aquinas confuses me on this point, but he concludes that evil does not "exist" as such. He equates goodness with existence or being, and says that the more perfect something is, the more "real" it is. [This makes sense thinking about The Great Divorce, where CS Lewis describes that even the grass in heaven is so much more real than we shadowy mortals. We would cut our feet on it if we were to go there in our imperfect state.] So evil, as the opposite of good and being, is a non-entity. He also says that God created everything, and everything He created is good, so evil does not exist.

It follows from this that evil does not apply to creatures (implications for capital punishment?), only to actions or morals. People in all their actions are aiming at what they perceive to be good, not evil. i.e. a murderer is seeking justice or release of anger, or some other apparent good. Evil therefore is NOT the absence of all good, but the absence of a particular good. For example, the murderer forgets the good of valuing life, or mercy. Evil is never the aim, only incidental to a sought-for good.
Aquinas advocates for the goodness of our mind ruling over the desires of our bodies. The good we tend to leave out most often is the rational ordering of desire. Yes, eating ice cream is good and pleasurable to our bodies, but it is good for us in every sense, or in excess? No, the evil of gluttony is the failure to apply the good of temperance over the good of pleasure.

We also talked about the various divisions of the soul, appetites, and man's chief end (happiness). But you'll have to read the notes for that.
Reading: Aquinas Summa, continued.

Art - it was cancelled.

Music - I skipped it to cook Indian food (shhh). But they covered Handel's oratorio, Israel and Egypt, and introduced classical music.
Reading: Grout on classical music, Haydn.

Science and Medicine

John Patrick talked about the beginnings of experimentation, people looking for answers ("fact-finding") for themselves instead of trusting tradition. The Royal Academy was founded in teh 17th century, with the motto "show me." In the wake of Protestantism, society was becoming more egalatarian. The academics were mingling with the craftsmen in Europe in the Royal Society to mutual benefit (i.e. lens grinders developing telescopes, microscopes). He mentioned innovators in different fields. William Harvey worked out the circulation system given the fact that veins have valves. The heart was seen as a pump, and the mechanistic displaced Aristotle's idea of the heart as the seat of the soul.

John Ray, the father of modern botany, began the work of classifying plants and animals by morphology and function. He also developed the idea of "natural theology," that you can know about God's nature by studying the creation.

He also talked about Hooke and Boyle, who were also Christians and members of the Royal Society. The myth of the Royal Society and "scientific revolution" defeating the superstition of religion is not true, because most of the founding members were believers. They were rational believers.
He also gave his talk on the 4 levels of happiness, which is worth reading from the original source at some point.

Literature

We finished talking about George Macdonald and Lilith. The story is basically an allegory of man struggling against sin and accepting death. It's so hard to describe, you just have to read the story. It's so weird and wild. Macdonald was an anti-Calvinist Christian, and also the father of fantasy. Good combo, huh? He was a huge influence on CS Lewis and Tolkein in their fiction.


Then we moved onto Rebecca Harding Davis, an American conservative Christian feminist. LOVED what we read of her. Life in the Iron Mills is this story of a worker in the hellish iron mills of West Virginia, and the inhumanity of the industrial revolution. She is an interesting writer, taking breaks to preach every once in a while. She marked part of the transition from Romanticism to Realism in literature (1860's).




Reading: Til We Have Faces, Lewis. and we are finishing Paradise Lost, Books 11-12.

Scripture

We read through Augustine on Romans 8, and also on original sin. The points Augustine makes which are interesting have to do with the creation. When scripture says that "the creation was subjected to futlity in hope," and that it longs to see the redemption of the sons of God, he includes US in the creation. Creation is not just he rest of nature, it includes our souls and bodies as well. We groan, we are subject to futility, and we too long to see our bodies ushered into glory as our spirits have begun to be.

With regard to original sin, he makes the point that the image of God is not erased by sin. It is twisted and distorted, but we are not beyond recognition. Our nature is not fallen, we are in a fallen condition of sin. He also lays the foundation for infant baptism, since none are born clean, and all need regeneration. I'm not really in agreement with that, but I'll have to study it more...

Reading: Aquinas, Compendium of Theology, Part 2 on Hope, sections 7-10 (really good!!)

Curry Overdose

Last weekend, I had this desire to make curry. So I spammed the class to see who was interested and 4 people replied. Now I've wanted to make curry, the good restaurant style stuff, for many years. Many variations I have tried (including the curry bricks that melt into sauce...), and all have failed to measure up. But I found this website (The Curry House) run by this Brit who is obsessed with replicating restaurant curry at home. It looked a little labor intensive but promising. I paid the 7 Lb and joined on.

Then it got out of control. A few more people wanted to come, and I kept finding dishes I wanted to try. Desh Grocery got to know me pretty well as I came in daily, asking for more "exotic" spices. Amchoor, fenugreek leaves, mango chutney, all new to me. Before it was all over, there was 3 kinds of curry (madras, korma, tikka masala), saag aloo (spinach and potatoes), carrot salad, califlower bhaji (which I forgot to serve), tarka dhal (lentils), samosas, and pilau rice. The grand total was over 1 L of peanut oil! trying not to think about that. Our dean, Prof. Tingley, came bearing milk-based desserts floating in sugar, and other various forms of Indian sweets to add to the decadence of the evening. Wow.

Folks came, they ate, they chatted. It was great. Next day reports included a number of restless nights, sloshing stomachs, and vivid dreams. At least no bacteria were spread, though I am interested now in which of the spices causes weird dreams =) I am still recovering from the peanut oil, and will be unable to think about eating curry for a very long time. Cooking curry is one goal I can cross off the list.

Sunday, January 20, 2008

Love

Love seems to be the topic of many conversations, sermons, book club, and prayers these days. Father Hayman read this poem by George Herbert before class started. I liked the idea of love inviting us to partake rather than demanding that we be worthy.
For book club, we are reading CS Lewis, The Four Loves. He goes through Affection, Friendship, Eros, and Charity. For each one, he traces the common life situation where these things arise, their relationship to God, and their common distortions. He makes a lot of interesting distinctions. First the difference between Need-love and Gift-love. Mostly we have Need-love for God, and He has Gift-love for us. But in our relationships with each other, these combine. Affection is a love that happens with time and familiarity, mostly in families. It often has a "need to be needed," and is jealous when the object needs it no longer. He tells some funny stories about Mrs. Fidget who sits up late for her children to get home, just "to make sure they're safe" and drives everyone crazy working to the bone and forcing them to help her with useless tasks.

Another distinction I liked was between nearness by likeness and nearness of approach. He makes the point that we are near to God in likeness b/c we are made in His image. But this does not mean that we are near to His heart, drawing near to Him. In this sense, we are nearest in approach to God when we are farthest from Him in likeness. When we are aware of our spiritual poverty, that's when we are nearest to God. "A broken heart and a contrite spirit He will not despise."

Lewis. Glad he wrote books.

Academics Week 2-2

As usual, for more detail, see the notes under Augustine - 2nd Semester

Philosophy

We continued the conversation on free will until we arrived at Augustine's definition of freedom. Think about a time when you overcame your natural stingy-ness and gave someone some money. As you reached into your pocket, your hand grabbed the money and you willingly gave it away. The minute before you didn't want to, then something changed and you wanted to. Augustine calls this 'grace,' the power to do good that comes from God. Freedom under the lordship of Christ is a special kind of freedom; he works through our will to make us want to do good. He frees us from the compulsion of sinning, and causes our desire to change. We are not being forced against our wills (we don't feel like puppets), we are doing good out of our will.

We need to consider the welfare of our soul before we decide whether freedom meaning "unconstrained" is possible, beneficial, or desireable. When we are in a sinful condition, we are free to do what we want, but we don't want the right things. Sigh.

Onto Thomas Aquinas. Aquinas agrees with Augustine that the action of God in preparing our wills (giving us insight into good and then preparing us to will it), is not inconsistent with our freedom. God is the first cause of our actions, while we are the efficient cause, in the Aristotelian sense.

"Free will is the subject of grace by the help of which it chooses what is good."

"By moving them, he does not deprive their actions of being voluntary; but rather He is the cause of this very thing in them; for He operates in each thing according to its own nature."
-Aquinas


Reading: The Shorter Summa, On the Virtues

Art

We continued our discussion of the Renaissance. The usually story of the Renaissance as concocted by 19th century historians was that it was the age of humanism triumphing over religion. Man liberated himself from the bonds of faith and supersition, relying instead on reason and self-fashioning. BUT, is this really the case?

Tingley put forth the idea that the Renaissance men were not striving to get rid of God, but instead exploring the greatness of human nature as created by God. Man IS great. This does not mean that God is not greater, it just means that in God's image, we have a lot of amazing capacties that we should develop and not thwart. In striving to bring ourselves nearer to God, we glorify Him.
This story is hard for moderns to swallow (especially a Prot like me who is sold on total depravity. 'O what a rogue and peasant slave am I'). I want to say that man is nothing apart from God and is basically ruined by sin. Tingley makes the case that human NATURE was not ruined by the fall, but we are in a sinful CONDITION. Our task is to live in accordance with our God-given nature, liberated by Christ from our sin.

Granted, the Renaissance did have signs of going wrong, pieces of self-absorbed and perverse art as much as any other era. And it did pave the way for secularism, but it's achievemnets cannot be wholly claimed by secularism. They were still church men doing most of the art!

And we talked about art as well. Characteristics of Renaissance art are typically held to be greater naturalism, portrayals of space and perspective, greater interest in painting the world as we see it, and portrayals of the greatness of man.

Again I love the Tres Riches (15th c)- the first portrayal of night ever. Christ in Gethsemane, so beautiful. Other great works include Primavera, Michelangelo's David (circumcised or not?? that is the question), and works by Mantegna. How can you not appreciate the beauty of these works? Wish we had more time on them.

Reading: more Renaissance


Music

Handel's Messiah was the subject of study. Prof. Warren read us lots of juicy tidbits on Handel's life, he was quite a character. No doubt Messiah is an inspired work, I'll have lots of trivia to spout off next time I go see it.

to be cont'd




Sunday, January 13, 2008

Academics - Week 2-1

So back from the break, we dived in with both feet...

Philosophy

We entered into the ever-dreaded discussion of "free will and predestination." Tingley introduced the discussion last semester and we read Augustine (On Grace and Free Will) over Christmas. Basically, Augustine says 1) of course we have free will or else God wouldn't command us to do anything and offer consequences based on our actions 2) our will is free to do evil apart from God's grace but not good 3) in doing good acts, God prepares our will to act (operation) and then helps us act when our will has chosen a course (co-operation). We are told to pray for this grace so that we will be able to obey.

When it comes down to it, all good actions that we do are preceded by some kind of "illumination" that makes us see, desire, intend, and do a good thing. This illumination is not from us, but God.

We should remember that He says, "Make you a new heart and a new spirit," who also promises, "I will give you a new heart, and a new spirit will I put within you." Ezekiel 36:26 How is it, then, that He who says, "Make you," also says, "I will give you"? Why does He command, if He is to give? Why does He give if man is to make, except it be that He gives what He commands when He helps him to obey whom He commands? There is, however, always within us a free will,—but it is not always good; for it is either free from righteousness when it serves sin,—and then it is evil,—or else it is free from sin when it serves righteousness,—and then it is good. But the grace of God is always good; and by it it comes to pass that a man is of a good will, though he was before of an evil one. (Ch. 31)
***
God commands some things which we cannot do, in order that we may know what we ought to ask of Him. For this is faith itself, which obtains by prayer what the law commands. (Ch. 32)...

For it is certain that we keep the commandments if we will; but because the will is prepared by the Lord, we must ask of Him for such a force of will as suffices to make us act by the willing. It is certain that it is we that will when we will, but it is He who makes us will what is good, of whom it is said (as he has just now expressed it), "The will is prepared by the Lord." Proverbs 8:35 Of the same Lord it is said, "The steps of a man are ordered by the Lord, and his way does He will." Of the same Lord again it is said, "It is God who works in you, even to will!" Philippians 2:13 It is certain that it is we that act when we act; but it is He who makes us act, by applying efficacious powers to our will, who has said, "I will make you to walk in my statutes, and to observe my judgments, and to do them." Ezekiel 36:27 When he says, "I will make you . . . to do them,"what else does He say in fact than, "-->I will take away from you your heart of stone," from which used to arise your inability to act, "and I will give you a heart of flesh,"Ezekiel 36:26 in order that you may act?

***

So where is the justice? How can God hold us accountable if He has not given us the grace to obey? Augustine says that God is never unjust. Every man is sinful and worthy of condemnation on his own. God can be merciful and give good things to evil people, or be just in giving bad things to evil people. But He is never unjust; He never renders punishment for goodness.

It's all very mysterious. We didn't actually come to Augustine's definition of freedom, but we will this week.

Reading: Thomas Aquinas, Shorter Summa Theologica.

Art

We were going to talk about Renaissance Art, but Tingley got side-tracked because of our final exams. It seems many students talk as if having faith is somehow higher than reason. So he went into a long discussion about how God created our minds to honor Him, and that not using reason is throwing His gift back at Him, settling for animality. Reason is all we have to tell us when we are going wrong, and where to look to correct it. Our premises are wrong, we can err in our beliefs, but the process of reason itself helps us correct ourselves all the time.

Also, since God is truth, seeking truth is seeking God. Not caring about the truth of a particular issue (i.e. the history of the Renaissance) is being indifferent to God and the world He placed us in. We should seek the truth of a subject if we are to speak about it. Otherwise, we should keep our mouths shut! Though we realize we will never have the full picture, this does not mean our search is useless. It just means we should be humble in talking to others about it.

Reading: Gombric on the Renaissance

Music
More on Handel vs. Bach. Handel is light and fluffy, much easier to follow than Bach, but not nearly the genius Bach was, according to Warren.

Reading: Classical Music in Grout

Literature

We talked about the stories we wrote for Tucker. I was a bit frustrated, seeing as how he gave us no direction before the stories were due, and lectured on story writing afterwards. But whatever, I'm pretty sure I can never bring myself to write the style he is looking for, i.e. over the top. So I'll stick to the research paper option this term. (sour grapes, yeah, yeah, I know.)

Reading: Lilith
Science

John Patrick told the story of how we got to atheistic science from the highly religious scientists in the Middle Ages. Basically, once they began experiment and theorizing, they developed a method which was highly successful for discovering physical truth. God was no longer "needed" for the doing of science. There is no problem as long as one understands that this is an atheistic fiction, a useful model within limits. The problem arises when it is extended into all realms.

Ottawa in Winter


Thankfully, it's been "warm" since we came back. Nice and sunny, most the snow has melted. So I took the opportunity to run around taking pictures of the city. If you want to see the park and random shots of trees, feel free.
I also got to visit the Wheeler's again after break. Their place was gorgeous as ever, with fields of snow everywhere, more than I've ever seen. Looks like a wonderland. Hey that sounds like a song...Anyway, sat in Tim's sauna, which was HOT, like Houston in July. The only novelty is getting to jump in the snow afterward, which makes you all tingly. Fun relaxing weekend before getting back to the city.

Acdemics - Last Semester

Since I stopped summarizing with 3 weeks left, I'll direct you to the notes for the last weeks, under "Augustine." It ended with a bang, lots of good stuff.

Philosophy
We talked about the New Testament toward the end, trying to see if we could derive an ethics from it. Basically, looking at the 4 questions: WHY be good, WHAT to do in specific cases, what STANDARD to appeal to when things aren't nailed down, and finally, HOW do I control my will and actually do good things?

The New Testament is very difficult to read with a system like this in mind. All the books have different (but complementary) answers to these questions. I remember liking the definition of good Jesus puts forth, basically equating GOOD and LIFE (Luke 6). A guiding principle for behavior should be to support and promote life rather than destroy it. And not just physical life, but spiritual life as the real lasting thing.

Is it lawful on the Sabbath to do good or to do evil? To save life or to destroy it? - Jesus

Over the break, we read Augustine - On Grace and Free Will...

Art
Tingley ended with a lecture about culture which I found really interesting. His point was that mankind needs cultivating, like the plants. We are not born as fully human as we could be, we often fall into acting like animals, or thinking we are angels. Culture is that set of activities that contributes to the growth of the human person. It is necessary, and everyone is affected by it. Art, music, literature, TV, etc. all should function to make us more able to act like the humans we were created to be, instead of mere animals, or worse, demons.

Reading on the Renaissance.

Music
We finished up with Bach, Late Baroque. "A rigorous academic mind," and a very pious man. he wrote so much music! He's intense to listen to, quite the fugue pioneer. Now we are moving to Handel and the Classical Composers (Beethoven, Mozart).

Literature
We continued the Romantic poets, who I didn't really get much out of, and then the Christmas Carol by Dickens. Apparently in Dicken's England, the Puritans had banned Christmas! So the book, while at times sentimental, is trying to remind us of the wild spirit of generosity that gives life flavor. It asks us to examine our hearts and see how we can meet and exceed the needs of those around us. Without Christ, it quickly becomes humanistic, but Dickens has the gift of the incarnation in the background.

Reading - Lilith by George MacDonald

Science
With John Patrick, we looked at the beginnings of Reductionism (the tendency to treat your partial description of something as the whole picture) in science. All the early scientists were within the Church, were Christians, and were concerned with keeping God omnipotent. However, they made the first steps severing research from theology in the Late Middle Ages. William of Occam was a bit extreme, he said that most intangible things were not real, except for God. He began to move toward saying that quantifiable things were more important than qualitative things.

Then came the "atheistic fiction": the realization that you don't need the idea of God to carry out experiements very successfully. Science indeed is able to proceed on this basis, but tends to forget that is a fiction. And that most things people care about are not subject to experiment.

Reading: on the Copernican Revolution, something on William Harvey and John Ray

Thursday, January 10, 2008

Full Bodied


These comments inspired by a recent discussion with a certain set of brothers-against-fatness. You know who you are =)
Fatness is a strange thing. In some places and times, it's beautiful, a sign of prosperity and prestige. But in our particular time, it's basically the number 1 sin. As a recent article in the Utne Reader states,

"Short of burning obese people in effigy, it’s hard to imagine how we could stigmatize fat more in this culture. Body hatred is regarded as a feminine virtue."

Given this negative side of hating fat people, calling them gluttons, etc. that our society engages in, where should I "stand"? Not that I really have to have a stand per se in order to treat them like I treat everyone else (which all around needs improving). Is it beautiful? Or is it ugly? Should I celebrate it or just tolerate it?

As a human, I can say every person contains beauty. Period. Women who carry themselves with grace and beauty come in all sizes. I think movies like Shallow Hal and recent photo shoots have made the much needed argument that beauty is more than being thin and blonde.

As a future doctor, above a certain threshold, obesity increases disease, but not as much as traditionally thought. A fat person who is active is medically in much better health than a thin person who is active. I'll do my part to recommend things for weight loss, but in my limited experience, weight loss is a community effort. Most of the people who are obese do not have the supports in place to make the life-altering changes that weight loss requires. Moving to a place where you can exercise, getting away from your desk job, etc. Big changes.

There's so much to it, so many choices, emotions, moods, stigmas, and judgments that surround food and weight. I just know that I am totally ANTI- the Hollywood image that fuels anorexia and bulimia. So we all need to "expand" our idea of the ideal female figure for sure. I have no problem with the present attempts to glorify the generous figure; it's a necessary over-correction to the American dogma of Barbie.

As for the celebrate vs. tolerate question, I do think that obesity is not God's ideal state of health for many people, the genetic cases aside. But others do need help, and they, if they are our friends, need support from us. Peggy Noonan's comments on the new America's attitude (toward a pregnant teen at graduation) I think can apply to those cases where moral issues may be at play...when over eating is endangering the individual and society (via medical expenses and mortality).

The old America had a delicate sense of the difference between the general (“We disapprove”) and the particular (Let’s go help her”). We had the moral self-confidence to sustain the paradox, to sustain the distance between “official” disapproval and “unofficial” succor. The old America would not have applauded the girl in the big graduation gown, but some of its individuals would have helped her not only materially but with some measure of emotional support. We don’t so much anymore. For all our tolerance and talk we don’t show much love to what used to be called girls in trouble. As we’ve gotten more open-minded we’ve gotten more closed-hearted.

Thoughts?

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

Men with Beards

So the guys at Augustine did a "no shave November" in school tradition to see who could grow the most facial hair. It was pretty amusing, clearly some people are more gifted in the whisker arena than others. I came across this site which I think articulates perfectly the impulse behind "No Shave November."

I agree. Love it!...most the time. No neck hair - for the love...

Also see Whiskerino and World Beard Champions.


Whiskerino from George Kelly on Vimeo.

Monday, December 31, 2007

Martha Martha Martha


Last night Kris threw me a "coming home" party, which was really overboard but I appreciated immensely. Kristin is pretty much the queen of party hostesses, an aspiring Martha Stewart. I assisted while she made mini quiches, pigs in a blanket, cookies, peppermint brownies, and trays of veggies, dip, cheese, and candies. I threw in some spinach dip, but it was pretty much superfluous. It was gorgeous and perfect, on par with other events she has pulled off in the past. We hosted quite a few little gatherings in the old apartment here, and she hasn't done one since 4th year started. People are on different schedules and are all over the country. So it was great to get to have friends over and just talk.

Thanks to all who came! I enjoy talking hearing about the adventures of interviews, and chatting with the 3rd years about the wards. As much as I try to explain Augustine, it just never seems to be understood. It's really hard to describe in a sentence or 2. Basically, I give a different tidbit to every person, depending on what course comes to mind. No way to boil down all I have learned, but I am glad I went, in spite of missing out on 4th year with my classmates.



Cheers everyone, I am truly blessed with friends like the ones I have in Dallas. Especially Kristin!!